Small possibility?
Okay, i really only just thought of this and i know i should think about it more before posting but...Is there a possibility there was a connection between Becca and Clementine? as in they could of been friends, or instead of friends they just knew eachother.
You're probably thinking that the age difference is too much because while Clem was in elementary it seems that Becca was in middle school, but who knows? the school could of been a K-8 center. A good bit of people think Becca is the mystery girl in the trailer, and Clementine has every right to believe the kids from her school are dead.
Could she be the ''I thought you were dead'' person? I know alot of people hate Becca and i'm gonna point out i really don't know if they ever say what part of the world the pitstop is located in, but maybe Becca could of switched schools? or they could of simply just drove from their hometown and met up with Roman's group, This theory probably has a lot of flaws i'm not noticing and i might get dislikes but....eh.
Comments
It's possible. Remember Shel and Becca were fighting zombies outside of Clems neighborhood...maybe she glimpsed some of the attack. Or maybe they lived in the the same area. Who knows? Yeah but I'm betting its someone we've seen Clem interact with. like Kenny, Lilly, or Christa.
Its not impossible, It would make sense since supposedly Becca will appear in Episode 2 its gonna be interesting to see how they interact even if they have no idea who the other is
No dislike from me
While I suppose it is techincally possible it would be a terrible idea. Such a huge plot convinience would destroy the illusion of randomness that TWD is known for. It would take 'what are the chances' to a whole new, unbelievable level. IMO of course.
Jaw Drop
That's so clever ! I didnt think of it ... That's a good theory ! I guess we'll just see !
Shel and Becca were fighting outside of clem's neighborhood? I didn't see them -_-
To be honest, I think it would be a lot easier establishing a connection between the two after Lee dies and Clem is traveling with Christa and Omid. Gil's Pitstop is the one thing that links Clem and the 400 days survivors as they've all been in that area at some point and it's possible Clem and company could've crossed paths with them before that unfortunate incident with Michelle.
EDIT: Scratch that idea. The area around the Pitstop in All That Remains has pine trees around it whereas the one in Days does not. So they're different locations.
Is it just me or do I think the bathroom where Omid died could've been the diner from 400 days?
Shel and Becca were fighting zombies outside of Clementine's neighborhood....? What makes you think that? Do you have any proof or evidence?
I mentioned something along those lines above you. I had to reconsider the idea though since I realized that the trees are different around the Gil's Pitstop featured in All That Remains. It's most likely a different location that's part of a chain of stores. So much for that idea.
Reply to Night_Owl : Well it has been a 16 month time difference, maybe the trees have grown?
NO, nobody likes Becca
According to the Walking Dead wiki it is. I think it would be pretty confusing to use a different diner location right at the start of season 2 after establishing Gil's so solidly in 400 Days. I'm pretty sure we're meant to make the connection.
I'm okay with her character.
You're okay with a kid who wanted to kill her friend?
The same kid who can't bring herself to do it if you give her the option? You may never like her as a person but it helps trying to look a little deeper into her actions if you want to understand why some don't hate her. I actually like what she could bring to the story if handled right.
It is possible but I doubt it. The "I thought you were dead" just seemed a much bigger cliffhanger than that... I guess we'll find out soon enough though!
It's true. Vince was in Macon at the time of the prison bus scenario in 400 Days, when Vince looks out the window he sees Shel & Becca running from walkers. But still it isn't outside of Clems neighborhood.
It's not a case of growth. They're completely different types of trees. The ones featured in Days have broad leaves as opposed to the long thin ones associated with pine trees. And the shapes are different too with the pines being narrower and taller in general.
Oh. Thank you for clarifying that, I guess I didn't notice it was them. I'll replay Vince's episode of 400 days.
You've got a point there..
and pirate, anyone can edit the wiki.
Of course, but look at the edit history, it's not like there's some big controversy over whether it's the same diner or not.
It has the same exact sign prominently displayed right at the start of season 2 when the last thing we played was 400 Days which focused almost exclusively on that diner. The way the sign is featured in the shot screams "look guys we're back here again". It's continuity between 400 Days and season 2. If it was supposed to be a different location there's no way a writer wouldn't have put up their hand and said "uh, this is going to confuse people" at which point the location would be changed to a strip mall or a motel or something more obviously different.
The trees do look different. I'm guessing continuity error. They were using pine forest later in the episode so they threw a bunch of those same tree models in the background of the first scene figuring no-one would notice rather than digging out the tree assets they'd used in 400 Days and adding them.
Good points. And your explanation about the continuity error could work. I guess we'll just have to wait and see.
Maybe Clem had a telescope in her treehouse...ok nevermind. But is it still possible Clem, Shel and Becca knew each other.
Well It wouldn't mean that everyone in the apocalypse is connected somehow. It's not so outlandish to think at least one person knew another(not related or not in a group already) before walkers roamed free.
Well, it ain't Becca, so your argument is invalid
"My argument" was never about whether or not it was Becca.