Food dilemma
You see,my favourite choice in season 1 was the one where I chose who gets to eat in episode 2.A scenario crossed my mind.If Carver/William/George/Bill keeps the group unfed for revenge or I don't know.
If you had 4 items of food with you, to whom would you offer some?You have to chose from these guys:
-Clementine
-Carlos
-Sarah
-Rebecca
-Kenny
-Sarita
-Nick(if alive)
-Alvin(if alive)
I would give some food to Sarah,Carlos and Rebecca,and the I'd eat it myself.
How would you chose?
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
That's interesting. I'd chose in first place Clem, then Sarah, Kenny and Alvin.
Nick Kenny Sarah Rebecca
This decision would be pretty easy for me, because Nick and Alvin are both already dead in my playthough.
There are 3persons in this group, that should always get to eat the food. Clementine and Sarah, because they are both still just " children " and everyone in the group will be agreeing on that and Rebbeca because she is pregnant (even thouh i don't think Carver would let his pregnant feyonce starve to death...). The last food item is determinated, i would give it to my Bro Kenny, just because Kenny is my Bro.
If there will be such a decision, there would be some different outcomes. If you try to give the food to Carlos for example, he would most likely tell you to give the food to his daughter first (similar to Kenny in Season1). If you try to give the food to Alvin on the other hand, he would most likely tell you to give the food to his pregnant women Rebbeca first and Kenny will probaply tell you to eat the food yourself and give some of it to Sarita.
I'd handle it like this: Give Rebecca, some, she has to keep her strength up, being pregnant and all. Also, by giving her food, Alvin and I would be on good terms too, so I don't need to give him some. Sarah of course, she's just a kid after all and Carlos would appreciate my concern for her. Nick, so he sees that I care about him. And Sarita, so Kenny is satisfied, kind of like he was happy with me giving food to his son in season 1. This way, everyone's pleased, one way or another.
Rebecca- Pregnant
Sarah- A child
Nick- I promised Uncle Pete
Clementine- I think it would be interesting if you didn't feed yourself for there to be a minor consequence, such as passing out later or getting a more difficult QTE.
Sarah, Rebecca, Sarita and Nick.
Playing as Clem with this decision:
1. Rebecca -> pregnant + Alvin (if alive) will be happy
; 2. Sarah -> Carlos will be happy
; 3. Sarita -> Kenny will be happy
; 4. Nick.
If I was playing as myself with this decision, I'd pick Clem instead of Nick
I would give food to Rebecca because of her pregnancy.
Though I don't think Carver would starve Rebecca out, because she was the whole reason for him to follow the cabin group and he is after his child after all.
Then I'd feed Carlos. He's a doctor, and you always have use of a doctor around.
After that I'd give Sarah food, because she is just a kid, and also because she is the doctor's daughter.
Wouldn't want him to be mad at me for not feeding his daughter.
I would keep the last piece for myself too, because Clementine really needs it. She is the smallest and still needs to grow.
It was different with Lee, because he was a grown up man, but...she's just a little girl, Luke!
Rebecca She evil but she's pregnant not a monster
Sarah So innocent be huge culture shock in this episode so give her food to help her deal with it
Kenny His my bro a hero after what did for ben risked himself for person he hated a true hero
Carver But poison the food with bit of zombie meat muahaha
Trying be creative like clem feed her 4 times but to predictable
Clementine She deserves it because not only she survived throughout without Christa for some days but because she was brave to stitch her arm by her self.
Kenny Been through a lot with that guy...Saved both Clementine and Lee and sacrificed his self for Ben.
Rebecca I wouldn't give her food because of her bad attitude and rudeness but since she is pregnant,I'd give her the benefit of the doubt.
Luke He was the only one that believed that it was actually a dog bite and disagreed into locking you in the shed.He is also trustworthy and a great friend to have in this Apocalypse...
Sarah: She's a kid ; Sarita : I would much rather give it to Kenny but Im sure he would pull a Season 1 Episode 2 on Us and Tell us to give it to his girl first ; Rebecca : She's a pretty little pregnant lady ; Nick : I would give it to Clem but we know she's not gonna die and a piece of food is not gonna help her that much anyway so I might as well use it to get on someone's good side.
" Luke He was the only one that believed that it was actually a dog bite and disagreed into locking you in the shed. "
Nope...that was uncle Pete, remember? Luke said " Fuck, fuck, fuck what are we gonna do here? If you get bitten you get killed, that's how we do things. " Or something like that.
And also...he isn't even with the group at the moment.
Clementine: Should be self explanatory
Nick: Still evidently weak and unsure, plus I really want him to live as long as he can
Kenny: Friend
Sarah: Annoying as she may be, she's the scared child and should eat
That was his initial reaction. After a short period of time his conclusion was as JeraFlow stated.
Yes this was his initial reaction, but the only reason Clem didn't get killed right away is because uncle Pete trusted her that it isn't a Lurker bite.
I'm not saying that Luke is a bad guy, he isn't!
I'm just saying that good old uncle Pete is the real hero and savior of the day here!
Luke didn't want to lock Clementine in the shed. Pete was okay with the idea. He didn't even try to argue further after the shed idea was out there. Luke argued and defended Clementine until the end. He even apologized for it even though it wasn't his fault.
Pete did try to protect Clementine as much as, or maybe even more then Luke did. Luke just said that " She is just a little girl. " That's all he did. Pete made an argument for cuting Clem's arm off, that might sound rude to you...but they were all considering the fact that Clementine might have been bitten and this could have saved her life.
He didn't say "she is just a little girl." He tried to convince the group that it was a dog bite and to not put her in the shed. Pete didn't believe her and suggested they cut her arm off. Luke even convinced the group to release Clementine from the shed. You can even hear Luke demanding they let her out of that shed during the kitchen conversation when you're sneaking in the house. That's why Luke was the first one to open the shed. Luke even told Nick to apologize to Clementine and he fed Clementine too. I'm not discrediting Pete, but simply crediting Luke.
That's debatable to say the least, If you go back to the moment they found out about the bite Luke doesn't completely believe it was a dog bite while Pete wasted no time to get on Clem's good side and gave her the benefit of the doubt, They both Trusted Clementine in their own way so its worth nothing trying to figure out who looked out for her the most. Concerning locking her in the shed, There's not much he could do about it since The majority of the group thought she was bitten and it was better not to take the risk. ( And I Recon he didn't want to be responsible for the death of a child or a pregnant woman since supposedly Clem was "bitten" )
" He tried to convince the group that it was a dog bite and to not put her in the shed. Pete didn't believe her and suggested they cut her arm off. Luke even convinced the group to release Clementine from the shed. "
Pete didn't believe her and suggested to cut her arm off...did we even play the same game? The only reason why Clem didn't get killed by Luke in the first place is because Pete trusted and believed Clem when she told him that it's just a dog bite.
Luke even convinced the group to release Clementine from the shed...no he didn't. Clementine got " released " from the shed, because the group found out that Clementine got attacked by a Walker and stitched herself up.
If Pete did believe her then why did he want to cut Clementine's arm off? It's not because he's sadistic.
"The only reason why Clem didn't get killed by Luke in the first place is because Pete trusted and believed Clem when she told him that it's just a dog bite."
Did Luke suggest that they murder Clementine? Did he give any indication that he was planning to kill her? I've seen Luke kill lurkers and he doesn't waste his time. If he wanted Clementine dead, she would be dead.
Are you saying that the group heard Clementine getting attacked by a walker during an incoming storm, sound of other walkers roaming around the cabin, and not to mention they were in two different building talking while the shed is a good distance away. They didn't hear Clementine. Luke convinced them to let her out. That's why they were so surprised to see a walker in the shed.
" If Pete did believe her then why did he want to cut Clementine's arm off? It's not because he's sadistic. "
He suggested this, because he was trying to help her. It's better to cut Clementines arm off then just letting her die...Pete knew he couldn't convince the group that Clem wasn't bitten, so he tryed to convince the group to cut her arm off and save her life, instead of locking her into a shed and letting her die.
" Did Luke suggest that they murder Clementine? Did he give any indication that he was planning to kill her? I've seen Luke kill lurkers and he doesn't waste his time. If he wanted Clementine dead, she would be dead. "
Yes he did suggest to kill her. He said with his own words: " If you get bitten, you get killed. "...ofcourse he didn't just slash her head off like he would do it with a Walker, they needed to think about it first.
" Are you saying that the group heard Clementine getting attacked by a walker during an incoming storm, sound of other walkers roaming around the cabin, and not to mention they were in two different building talking while the shed is a good distance away. They didn't hear Clementine. Luke convinced them to let her out. That's why they were so surprised to see a walker in the shed. "
They were there, because they found out that Clementine stole supplies from the group...remember what Carlos told her: " You convinced my daughter, to steal from us. I want you to stay away from her. "
Look i never said Luke isn't a good guy, he is...i just said that Pete was the one that saved her life, when Luke and Pete found out that she had been bitten.
[removed]
You think Luke would have killed her before coming to his reasonable conclusion? I doubt that
It's debateable...maybe he wouldn't have. The point is, we can't know that.
I was just coming in here to argue that point but someone beat me to it lol
He was freaking out but he wasn't going to shoot her. From his character traits I find that hardly debatable.
You know what they say, A guy always knows what his twin brother is gonna do :P
1) Sarah: she's clem's friend (or she thinks) and carlos would be happy
2) Kenny or sarita: either of them would make the pother happy so no problem
3) Rebecca: Alvin would be happy (thou I think he'll be beaten to death by carver in episode 3)
4) Nick: He needs reassurement and luke isn't around
Anyway i think Telltale won't giv us such a choice. The group is way too small and its members are well connected to eachother. In S1, the group was larger and there were constant problems between Larry and Lilly on one side, Kenny and family on the other and Clementine and ben in the middle.
Giving around food like in s1 would not have any kind of consequence, and chacachters would not argue with clem for her decision.
Also, clem's is still percieved as a little girl. I doubt Carlos would task her with giving around food
At least Luke never suggested anything that would harm Clementine. Putting her in the shed to die? If Pete knew that then why didn't he say anything? Pete believed Clementine wasn't bitten so putting her in the shed shouldn't be a problem if it wasn't a lurker bite.
Nick was the one who said that. Here's the conversation:
Nick: This isn't how we do things, man. When you're bit, you get put down. End of story. I'm not going through this again.
Luke: No one's suggestin' that
The group didn't know about the stolen supplies. Here's evidence when they went to the shed:
Luke: You patched yourself up...?
Nick: Where'd you get that stuff?
Rebecca: Did she STEAL from us!?
Think about it. They didn't hear Clementine getting attacked by a walker, they didn't know she stole any supplies, and it wasn't morning yet. Like I said, Luke convinced them to release her from the shed.
Sooo did you feel it when I stubbed my toe this morning? :O
" Pete believed Clementine wasn't bitten so putting her in the shed shouldn't be a problem if it wasn't a lurker bite. "
She would have died if she wouldn't have taken care of the bite...her arm would have got infected, why the fuck do you think we needed to sneak into the house and steal the cabin groups supplies?
" Think about it. They didn't hear Clementine, they didn't know she stole any supplies, and it wasn't morning yet. Like I said, Luke convinced them to release her from the shed. "
Ofcourse they knew about the fact that Clementine stole their supplies, Luke is a nice guy...but he isn't the Superhero you want him to be!
Just going to interject here and say that Pete should probably get the credit for not killing Clem from the get go since the initial decision making was left up to him. Luke thought it was a Lurker bite but then very obviously did not want to make the hard decision that came with it. He left it up to Pete the moment he said, "so what do we do now?". Also remember that even after Pete said he believed Clem Luke still protested and Pete said if he knew anything it was that he wasn't going to leave her out in the woods to die.
As to the food dilemma, I would probably go with Rebecca, Sarah, Carlos and Clem. The most physically vulnerable and the one person who is both useful in a fight and for medical help. Though I could also switch out Clem for Nick if only because Clem might worry that he take things the wrong way and he's already feeling pretty isolated.
I knew something had happened to you ! "Nick's Voice" Something ain't right.
What she said...thanks for interjecting!
Rebecca: She's pregnant
Alvin: He gave us a apple juice, we need to pay that debt
Sarah: Child
Kenny or Nick: Haven't decided, yet
That's what I was trying to say. Why didn't he say anything then? Why did he stay quiet and not tell them that she would get infected either way? He could have said to at least disinfect the wound.
I just showed the evidence on how they didn't know that Clementine stole their supplies and you replied "Ofcourse they knew about the fact that Clementine stole their supplies" with no evidence. They didn't know. Carlos probably talked to Sarah after he found out that Clementine stole from them wondering if she knew anything about it. Sarah who can't keep a secret and under Carlos' pressure told him.
As I did in season one I would give the food to the ladies (Rebecca and Sarita), the kids (Sarah) and someone who could help me through the story (Kenny-Luke).
I will act smart here and stop this discussing...we could go on like this for hours, but i see i can't convince you to believe me. This discussion isn't part of the thread anyway...this thread is about food dilemma!