Character VS Thread
MORE WILL BE ADDED IF THREAD STAYS ALIVE
Ok so what we do is say two characters to vs each other and if you want explain who you think would win and why and also no TV show characters (That is right no Daryl) just comic and game characters
I'l start with a few
Clem vs Comic Carl
Comic Rick vs Lee (Asshole Playthrough)
The Governor vs Carver
Ben vs Nick
Carley vs Comic Andrea
Who would win out of these and why? also lets try to come up with some other vs that we can discuss 
GO!
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
Sorry but comic carl would win as he has no emotion left whatsoever. He's psycho
Clem's clearly better than Carl at melee but she would loose a gunfight.
I didn't read the part where the Governor appears, but, for the little I know, he was never very threatening by himself. It was his minions, who followed his sick orders, what made him dangerous. So, armies aside, Carver should win.
Nick. He fucks up a little but Ben's a total pussy.
EDIT: Lee, 'cause he's Lee. Nothing beats his efforts in "No Time Left", in my opinion.
And Andrea. Carley was tough and a good shot, but, with or without guns, Andrea is just too battle-hardened for her.
Win in what a fight or a saltlicking contest?
Carl wins in a gunfight, otherwise Clementine has the advantage because of her age.
Governour is much more evil than Carver but I actually doubt that an one-armed man can actually beat anyone at all.
Nick wins easily, Ben would just run away and then get shot in the stomach from behind.
Edit:
Rick wouldn't win in a fight against Lee because he's generally very bad at fighting, but I think he'd do something like biting Lee's eye out or something like that to win, so I'm not sure about that.
Andrea is a sniper, Carley a girl with a gun, it's obvious who will win.
Rick and Lee seem to disagree with that statement
Rick never won a single fight after he lost his hand, he just another way to finish off his opponent. Lee, on the other hand, was fairly strong and his opponent was a psychotic wimp.
Well, you choose how to play Clementine and you can play her as quite a cold and dangerous individual. I think that one is up in the air.
Comic book Rick...only one arm left, still more badass and better fighter than TV show Rick!
She is smarter than all of them. All of them
Carl wins I'm sorry to say... Either being a melee or a gun fight, the game right now is very close to the comics. And people who are up to date with them knows Carl has done some pretty cool things.
Carver wins the second one. Pretty easy actually.... We know The Governor wasn't in the same condition as the tv Governor after the fight with Michonne(If you ask me, Michonne should have died right there and then in both situations).
As for the third one, I'm pretty sure Nick and Ben will find some way to blow each other's brains off in no time. So it's a draw. Joking aside, I'd say Nick will take this.
I don't know who would win the Clementine vs Carl one. They are both extremely skilled survivors. From what I've seen, Clementine....isn't the best shooter, but in melee she can fight grown men, and she's extremely witty and skilled at using her environment to her advantage. But, Carl's an emotionless killer who's a lot better with guns. So, I think either of them could win.
Carver. He can take a rifle gunshot in the shoulder and stand up like he just got a ball of fluff thrown at him and clearly he is strong enough to make people not even consider agitating him, for the most part.
Nick. He can actually fight and he's not a total pussy like Ben.
alright guys lets also try to think of some other good vs we could discuss too along side discussing my ones
Clementine vs. Carl is a close one! S2 Clementine has a physical advantage due to the growth spurt she experienced between Seasons and because she retains use of both eyes. Carl is more comfortable with firearms and killing in general, having few moral scruples left. Plus he has an angry one-handed dad. O have to give a slight edge to Carl.
Carver vs. Governor: Carver is tough as nails and built like a beast. Both are very intelligent and charismatic. However, Carver has both his eyes, which is a huge advantage (I say this as someone who is functionally blind in one eye).
Nick vs. Ben: BANG! That was the sound of Nick accidentally killing Ben before the fight starts.
1.Carl would win because he's an ass***e, but ask that question again at episode 5 and I think it'd be Clementine because she'll get better at shooting and trust nobody probably. She also took out Winston who was like twice her size.
2. Nick, Ben would just get shot
3. I don't know about the other ones.