The credit for this choice goes to someone else who made a discussion on this, but save Sarita or Sarah?
Regarding the choices other people suggested, I would save Christa over Luke, would forgive Lilly (but never forget), I CANT CHOOSE BETWEEN RUSSELL OR WYATT, name Rebecca's baby either Christa/Diana or Lee/Omid, and show mercy to Vernon (but never fucking forget).
Because I suck at making up choices, I will just state what I'd do:
1) Christa. We know her for far longer, and I don't trust Luke at all… more.
2) No. Never. Even if I could empathize with her a little, shooting Carley/Doug was too much.
3) Wyatt, because I think he's funnier than Russell
4) I can't remember any name of the name list in Episode 1 anymore.
5) No. Vernon and the Stranger are the reason for the group falling apart/Lee's Death. Stole the boat like a real scumbag. Asswipe. I hope I get to kill him if he isn't dead yet.
damn... I was gana say the first one.
i will say this:
you just shot carver multiple times that could be life threatening. you leave h… moreim behind laying on the floor suffering. right before you walk out the door he says "i will kill you"
* a bomb has been planted in the building. and there are walkers starting to invade, although the bomb remote wont work from a distance. so you have to make up your mind because there are so many zombies coming. although luke and sara are still in the building.
1)blow up the building killing carver but will also kill Luke and sara.
2)don't detonate the bomb letting luke and sara live but also carver.
Name Rebecca's Baby.
If it's a boy: Ed, Lee, Omid, (Silence).
If it's a girl: Diana, Lilly (Carley Determinant), Christa, (Silence).
You have 8 seconds to decide.
What about Christa, or her baby? Like either save the baby's life, but have to kill Christa, or have Christa somehow not have the baby? I dunno. Or maybe saving Lilly, or someone else like someone new, that we don't really like... I'll leave you guys to decide who that is....lol
1) Save Luke or Christa: Luke, but it would be close. I can tell TTG is going for an older brother/younger sister vibe with Luke and Clem, and I respect that.
2) Forgive Lilly or not: In all fairness, my Lee has dropped Ben in several playthroughs, so if S2 Clem were to meet her again, I could see her forgiving Lilly.
3) Save Russell or Wyatt: Wyatt. Russell's grown on me a bit, but something about the tough exterior he projects feels forced to me, and that always got on my nerves a bit. Plus yeah, Wyatt gets some good lines.
4) What to name Rebecca's baby: Not sure what would seem meaningful without cheap. I could see Ed, Lee, Omid as choices, but I don't like any of those that much.
5) Show mercy to Vernon or not: have Clem give him the glare and cold shoulder. Worst punishment ever.
After trying to escape from the camp, Carver finally manages to catch Clementine and cabin group. With two men follows him, he drags her to a dark room has nothing but two chairs, one long black desk and a little light on the top.
Carver: ''Tie her to the chair. We can't take any chances at this point.''
This two man ties Clementine to the chair.
Carver: ''Leave us alone. Now!''
Two man leaves the room.
Carver: ''You have no idea what you've done sweetheart.''
Clementine glares at him.
Clementine: ''What are you gonna do my friends?''
Carver: ''The same thing we do everytime. We will do what we do to those who betray us. That includes you too. You see sweetie, you and your friends just made a HUGE mistake. And in our community, nothing goes unpunished. So we're gonna make sure you and your so called ''Friends'' here will regret what you've done.
Carver puts a bag in front of table. Clementine realizes that's her backpack.
Carver: ''What? You seem surprised. Of course I'm not gonna beat you to death. Why would I do such a thing? I have very special punishment for you. I bet you have a really personal stuff in this backpack. Am I right?
Clementine: ''Don't. Touch. That.''
Carver: ''Yeah, seems like.''
Carver shows Clementine a photo.
Carver: ''Who's this? Is he your father?''
Clementine: ''I SAID DON'T TOUCH THAT!''
Carver: ''Is he the one who gave you that hat?''
Clementine: ''Why do you care so much?''
Carver: ''If he's not your father why are you carrying that man's photo with you? Oh, I get it. That's the man that Kenny guy mentioned. Lee is it?''
Clementine: ''Don't. Talk. About. Him.''
Carver: ''Is he your father or not? Answer my question or I'll make sure that all of your friends have a bullet in their heads!''
Clementine: ''He's not.''
Carver: ''But I'm betting that he was like a father to you.''
Clementine: ''...''
Carver: ''Yeah, definitely he was. Otherwise, why would you carry a photo of a stranger? Right?''
Carver stands up to his chair and comes close to Clementine. He reaches his hand to her hat.
Carver: ''This must be very important for you. I'm betting again that your ''Original'' father gave that to you.''
Carver picks up Clementine's hat.
Clementine: ''GIVE ME MY HAT!''
Carver: ''I'm afraid I can't guarantee that sweetie, but you can.''
Carver pulls a lighter out of his pocket.
Carver: ''I said I have a very special punishment for you. And there it is.''
Clementine: ''No! No, no, no, no, no. STOP!''
Carver: ''Haha of course I will, don't worry. But you have to decide first. Who is the most important person for you? What person are you gonna let go of your life? Clocks ticking. Oh by the way if you're thinking stay silent and saying nothing, don't bother. You have to choose one of them. Because if I'm not hearing a one single answer from you, well, I'll burn both of them. Oh and don't try to struggle either. It'll just gonna make things even worse for you. Believe me my dear, I'm a man of my word. Choose carefully. No going back.''
[Let Carver Burn Photo Of Lee] [Let Carver Burn The Hat]
1) I don't know enough about Luke yet to say for certain, but I'd lean toward saving Christa.
2) If she's remorseful and it's clear she has suffered for her crime, forgive, but don't forget.
3) it would be close, probably Wyatt.
4) Name him Lee if it's a boy, or Diana if it's a girl.
5) Of course! I think Lee and the group forced his hand by bringing all those Walkers down on the city when we arrived. No way he and his cancer patient friends would have made it if they didn't take pains to get the fuck outta dodge, ASAP.
I think the worst one would be if they turned this entire series into being completely evil or good, Betraying your group and staying with Carver or Leaving Carver's group. It's really unlikely and it reminds me of a scenario or two from infamous but you never know...
Clementine is sneaking by Carver's quarters, when she hears yelling on the inside. A man is being tortured inside by Carver and his crew. You can cause a distraction, drawing the Carver and his guards out of his quarters, but it runs a higher risk of getting caught by Carver. Or, you can let the man be tortured, and you can escape, nearly unscathed.
After trying to escape from the camp, Carver finally manages to catch Clementine and cabin group. With two men follows him, he drags her to … morea dark room has nothing but two chairs, one long black desk and a little light on the top.
Carver: ''Tie her to the chair. We can't take any chances at this point.''
This two man ties Clementine to the chair.
Carver: ''Leave us alone. Now!''
Two man leaves the room.
Carver: ''You have no idea what you've done sweetheart.''
Clementine glares at him.
Clementine: ''What are you gonna do my friends?''
Carver: ''The same thing we do everytime. We will do what we do to those who betray us. That includes you too. You see sweetie, you and your friends just made a HUGE mistake. And in our community, nothing goes unpunished. So we're gonna make sure you and your so called ''Friends'' here will regret what you've done.
Carver puts a bag in front of table… [view original content]
I think the worst one would be if they turned this entire series into being completely evil or good, Betraying your group and staying with C… morearver or Leaving Carver's group. It's really unlikely and it reminds me of a scenario or two from infamous but you never know...
Hmm.....I'll make up a one, with explanation, and answer the main 5 everyone is answering. Here: Luke returns, to help everyone in a prison break. He was aware Carver's group was getting close to the ski lodge, so he hid, and followed them back to the camp, so he could kill Carver, and escape again. The plan is put into action, as Clementine, Kenny, Sarita, Carlos, and Sarah, all go to take out Carver himself, while Nick (determinant) Alvin (determinant), Rebecca, and Luke, all go to take out the guards, leaving a clear path. By the time you reach the area near Carver's office, you hear Troy (the other guy from Carver's group who went to the ski lodge) was killed by Luke, when the group who was clearing the way was arrested by other guards. Sarita ends up causing a distraction, leading the guards far away, and Carlos stays outside, making sure nobody gets in. you take Carver on, as you hear Carlos firing his rifle. Kenny manages to beat Carver up, and Carver is bruised bloody, and barely alive, but alive. Kenny says he gave his gun to Sarita, and that he needs yours, when you hear carver yell that he's out of ammo, and that he needs help. You have 1 bullet left, and Carlos is pinned down by a walker, although you may have enough time to go save him, and Sarah is begging you to go help, but Kenny is demanding you pass him your gun. What do you do?
Now for my answers.
Luke or Christa? Christa is one of my favorite characters, but Luke is up there too, and has more to live for. Sorry Christa, tough call, but I'd go with Luke.
Forgive LIlly? NOPE. She killed my bro! Doug! My favorite character! I ditched her for a reason.
Names? If it's a boy: Doug (see #2) If it's a girl: Diana (I love the name)
Russel or Wyatt? Wyatt. He's my favorite protagonist from 400 days.
Mercy to Vernon? Nah, he's such an ass, I don't think I can forgive him, unless he seems genuinely sorry, like Nick did in episode 1
Kenny or Luke are the last two members of your group alive and are fed up with each other. They refuse to stay together any longer. Which one do you go with? Note, both of them have saved Clementine's life multiple times in this scenario.
After navigating around the tool department at carvers camp Clem finally comes upon what she was looking for for Kenny
Picks up the tool'
Clementine: "Yes" (Whisper)
Movement occurs somewhere behind her
Choice to hide behind a Large generator against a wall or behind an old desk
( Choose generator)
The figure appears with a flashlight after you've hidden. Its Carver
He proceeds to the generator to turn it back on
Turns it on and walks away
Clementine moves out of the spot and grabs the tool
*Carver realizes he forgot something and walks back and shines the light on Clementine"
Carver: "Oh hoho Now this is a surprise"
Carver continues to be condescending while you are given the option to RUN!!! or silence
(Choose the run option)
Clementine Dashes for the nearest stack of wooden palettes
Carver grabs her throws her down, she bumps her head on the table where she grabbed the tool and passes out
AT THIS POINT you can start up where Dark_Stars Interrogation begins or listen tot he rest of mine.
Clementine wakes up,groggy
They are in a dark room
Carver: Well, you finally went and did it?"
Clementine: Silence
Carver: " You ended up abusing our hospitality, breaking our communities strict orders."
Carver: "Anything to say for yourself?"
Clementine: .....
Carver: "Well i know you didn't just conjure this plan up alone"
Carver: "Tell me sweetie, who put you up to this?"
Clementine: ......
Carver: "Hm... Well then not in the mood to talk?"
Carver: "......... Listen here sweet heart, i don't like to be rough with little kids, especially with young ladies like yourself. I wouldn't want to do to you what i did to Alvin. Its not necessary. All you have to do is tell me who told you to do this."
Clementine Choice: "It was Kenny" or "......"
If you choose Kenny he will go get Kenny and beat him in front of you
If you choose silence you choose to take the beating yourself, which will give her a black eye,a broken finger, and undone brutally ripped
stitches where her dog bite was mended
(The reasoning behind the broken finger is because how Telltale made Clementine focus on Carlos fingers when he asked Clementine to untie him at the end of episode 2. Epic foreshadowing)
After the beating of Kenny or Clementine, she is returned to the group where they are waiting in the cafeteria
After trying to escape from the camp, Carver finally manages to catch Clementine and cabin group. With two men follows him, he drags her to … morea dark room has nothing but two chairs, one long black desk and a little light on the top.
Carver: ''Tie her to the chair. We can't take any chances at this point.''
This two man ties Clementine to the chair.
Carver: ''Leave us alone. Now!''
Two man leaves the room.
Carver: ''You have no idea what you've done sweetheart.''
Clementine glares at him.
Clementine: ''What are you gonna do my friends?''
Carver: ''The same thing we do everytime. We will do what we do to those who betray us. That includes you too. You see sweetie, you and your friends just made a HUGE mistake. And in our community, nothing goes unpunished. So we're gonna make sure you and your so called ''Friends'' here will regret what you've done.
Carver puts a bag in front of table… [view original content]
I actually kind of want that to happen... I mean I don't want to make Clementine chose between the two but I think it could be very powerful and a bit intense and emotional.
After trying to escape from the camp, Carver finally manages to catch Clementine and cabin group. With two men follows him, he drags her to … morea dark room has nothing but two chairs, one long black desk and a little light on the top.
Carver: ''Tie her to the chair. We can't take any chances at this point.''
This two man ties Clementine to the chair.
Carver: ''Leave us alone. Now!''
Two man leaves the room.
Carver: ''You have no idea what you've done sweetheart.''
Clementine glares at him.
Clementine: ''What are you gonna do my friends?''
Carver: ''The same thing we do everytime. We will do what we do to those who betray us. That includes you too. You see sweetie, you and your friends just made a HUGE mistake. And in our community, nothing goes unpunished. So we're gonna make sure you and your so called ''Friends'' here will regret what you've done.
Carver puts a bag in front of table… [view original content]
Tool Area shown in the Preview of episode 3.
After navigating around the tool department at carvers camp Clem finally comes upon what she… more was looking for for Kenny
Picks up the tool'
Clementine: "Yes" (Whisper)
Movement occurs somewhere behind her
Choice to hide behind a Large generator against a wall or behind an old desk
( Choose generator)
The figure appears with a flashlight after you've hidden. Its Carver
He proceeds to the generator to turn it back on
Turns it on and walks away
Clementine moves out of the spot and grabs the tool
*Carver realizes he forgot something and walks back and shines the light on Clementine"
Carver: "Oh hoho Now this is a surprise"
Carver continues to be condescending while you are given the option to RUN!!! or silence
(Choose the run option)
Clementine Dashes for the nearest stack of wooden palettes
Carver grabs her throws her down, she bumps her head on the table … [view original content]
I dont know how it would work but you have the opportunity to kill Carver while he is distracted fighting off walkers or save Crista from walkers. Maybe have a tied up Kenny yell "kill Carver!" so that you know if you select Carver you decide to kill him rather then save Crista.
Hmm.....I'll make up a one, with explanation, and answer the main 5 everyone is answering. Here: Luke returns, to help everyone in a prison … morebreak. He was aware Carver's group was getting close to the ski lodge, so he hid, and followed them back to the camp, so he could kill Carver, and escape again. The plan is put into action, as Clementine, Kenny, Sarita, Carlos, and Sarah, all go to take out Carver himself, while Nick (determinant) Alvin (determinant), Rebecca, and Luke, all go to take out the guards, leaving a clear path. By the time you reach the area near Carver's office, you hear Troy (the other guy from Carver's group who went to the ski lodge) was killed by Luke, when the group who was clearing the way was arrested by other guards. Sarita ends up causing a distraction, leading the guards far away, and Carlos stays outside, making sure nobody gets in. you take Carver on, as you hear Carlos firing his rifle. Kenny manages to beat Carve… [view original content]
Say Clem's getting a bit hungry and she's trapped,eat your leg or your arm,either way it sucks but you know I would certainly hope Clem would never get in a situation like this,or anyone for that matter.
Because I suck at making up choices, I will just state what I'd do:
1) Christa. We know her for far longer, and I don't trust Luke at all… more.
2) No. Never. Even if I could empathize with her a little, shooting Carley/Doug was too much.
3) Wyatt, because I think he's funnier than Russell
4) I can't remember any name of the name list in Episode 1 anymore.
5) No. Vernon and the Stranger are the reason for the group falling apart/Lee's Death. Stole the boat like a real scumbag. Asswipe. I hope I get to kill him if he isn't dead yet.
Comments
CHOICE:
1. Take stuff, leave folks
2. Kill folks, leave stuff.
There is not enough time for both.
Take stuff, leave folks
Regarding the choices other people suggested, I would save Christa over Luke, would forgive Lilly (but never forget), I CANT CHOOSE BETWEEN RUSSELL OR WYATT, name Rebecca's baby either Christa/Diana or Lee/Omid, and show mercy to Vernon (but never fucking forget).
Save entire group
Kenny ;D
Save Juice Box / Kill Carver
Can't get tougher IMO
Scumbag Vernon.
Save Wyatt or Eddie.
I'd have to save Carlos, just for Sarah. That whole pinky promise is pretty damn contract binding.
I was thinking something similar, but instead of a bomb we would have the chance to burn the place down (with her little lighter lol)
For a boy, I'd pick Omid, maybe Ed.
For a girl, I think I'd go with Carley.
Why is it that, whenever I see Sarita, I read it as Santa? Heck yes I'll save Santa!
Kill these folks, and take their stuff?
What about Christa, or her baby? Like either save the baby's life, but have to kill Christa, or have Christa somehow not have the baby? I dunno. Or maybe saving Lilly, or someone else like someone new, that we don't really like... I'll leave you guys to decide who that is....lol
Don't detonate the bomb is what I'd do. If Carver's injured and heaps of walkers are coming then I'd just go. Either way, Carver would be dead.
http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/71m2UQ4gjAL.SL1500.jpg
Not a spam bot I swear!
Reply to ReignofClementine
1) Save Luke or Christa
Luke easily, Christa has always annoyed me
2) Forgive Lilly or not
Sure, why not.
3) Save Russell or Wyatt
Wyatt definitely, Russell is even worse than Christa XD
4) What to name Rebecca's baby
Idk, I'm expecting it to die before we are even given that chance
5) Show mercy to Vernon or not
I'll let Kenny do all the work =D
Kill stuff, take folks.
1) Save Luke or Christa: Luke, but it would be close. I can tell TTG is going for an older brother/younger sister vibe with Luke and Clem, and I respect that.
2) Forgive Lilly or not: In all fairness, my Lee has dropped Ben in several playthroughs, so if S2 Clem were to meet her again, I could see her forgiving Lilly.
3) Save Russell or Wyatt: Wyatt. Russell's grown on me a bit, but something about the tough exterior he projects feels forced to me, and that always got on my nerves a bit. Plus yeah, Wyatt gets some good lines.
4) What to name Rebecca's baby: Not sure what would seem meaningful without cheap. I could see Ed, Lee, Omid as choices, but I don't like any of those that much.
5) Show mercy to Vernon or not: have Clem give him the glare and cold shoulder. Worst punishment ever.
I trust noone out of the new group yet
Especially someone TT seems to have 'bigger' plans for
After trying to escape from the camp, Carver finally manages to catch Clementine and cabin group. With two men follows him, he drags her to a dark room has nothing but two chairs, one long black desk and a little light on the top.
This two man ties Clementine to the chair.
Two man leaves the room.
Clementine glares at him.
Carver puts a bag in front of table. Clementine realizes that's her backpack.
Carver shows Clementine a photo.
Carver stands up to his chair and comes close to Clementine. He reaches his hand to her hat.
Carver picks up Clementine's hat.
Carver pulls a lighter out of his pocket.
[Let Carver Burn Photo Of Lee] [Let Carver Burn The Hat]
What are you guys think?
1) I don't know enough about Luke yet to say for certain, but I'd lean toward saving Christa.
2) If she's remorseful and it's clear she has suffered for her crime, forgive, but don't forget.
3) it would be close, probably Wyatt.
4) Name him Lee if it's a boy, or Diana if it's a girl.
5) Of course! I think Lee and the group forced his hand by bringing all those Walkers down on the city when we arrived. No way he and his cancer patient friends would have made it if they didn't take pains to get the fuck outta dodge, ASAP.
I think the worst one would be if they turned this entire series into being completely evil or good, Betraying your group and staying with Carver or Leaving Carver's group. It's really unlikely and it reminds me of a scenario or two from infamous but you never know...
Clementine is sneaking by Carver's quarters, when she hears yelling on the inside. A man is being tortured inside by Carver and his crew. You can cause a distraction, drawing the Carver and his guards out of his quarters, but it runs a higher risk of getting caught by Carver. Or, you can let the man be tortured, and you can escape, nearly unscathed.
Jesus that was depressing. I would let him burn Lee's picture.
Out of the ones I made up:
Save Luke or Christa- Really tough one, I will most likely save Luke.
Forgive Lilly- She killed my favorite character. I will forgive her, if she is sorry.
Names- If it's a boy, Lee. If it's a girl, Carley.
Russell or Wyatt- Horribly tough one, but I'll most likely save Wyatt
Mercy to Vernon- Whatever Kenny wants to do.....
I hope it doesn't boil down to good vs. bad. TWD is build around grey-and-grey morality, after all.
Yeah. I feel like every decision at the moment is completely justified. It would suck if they let you chose between good and evil.
Hmm.....I'll make up a one, with explanation, and answer the main 5 everyone is answering. Here: Luke returns, to help everyone in a prison break. He was aware Carver's group was getting close to the ski lodge, so he hid, and followed them back to the camp, so he could kill Carver, and escape again. The plan is put into action, as Clementine, Kenny, Sarita, Carlos, and Sarah, all go to take out Carver himself, while Nick (determinant) Alvin (determinant), Rebecca, and Luke, all go to take out the guards, leaving a clear path. By the time you reach the area near Carver's office, you hear Troy (the other guy from Carver's group who went to the ski lodge) was killed by Luke, when the group who was clearing the way was arrested by other guards. Sarita ends up causing a distraction, leading the guards far away, and Carlos stays outside, making sure nobody gets in. you take Carver on, as you hear Carlos firing his rifle. Kenny manages to beat Carver up, and Carver is bruised bloody, and barely alive, but alive. Kenny says he gave his gun to Sarita, and that he needs yours, when you hear carver yell that he's out of ammo, and that he needs help. You have 1 bullet left, and Carlos is pinned down by a walker, although you may have enough time to go save him, and Sarah is begging you to go help, but Kenny is demanding you pass him your gun. What do you do?
Now for my answers.
Luke or Christa? Christa is one of my favorite characters, but Luke is up there too, and has more to live for. Sorry Christa, tough call, but I'd go with Luke.
Forgive LIlly? NOPE. She killed my bro! Doug! My favorite character! I ditched her for a reason.
Names? If it's a boy: Doug (see #2) If it's a girl: Diana (I love the name)
Russel or Wyatt? Wyatt. He's my favorite protagonist from 400 days.
Mercy to Vernon? Nah, he's such an ass, I don't think I can forgive him, unless he seems genuinely sorry, like Nick did in episode 1
Kenny or Luke are the last two members of your group alive and are fed up with each other. They refuse to stay together any longer. Which one do you go with? Note, both of them have saved Clementine's life multiple times in this scenario.
Save Juice Box, his mighty powers will save the group from Carver!
Tool Area shown in the Preview of episode 3.
After navigating around the tool department at carvers camp Clem finally comes upon what she was looking for for Kenny
Picks up the tool'
Clementine: "Yes" (Whisper)
Movement occurs somewhere behind her
Choice to hide behind a Large generator against a wall or behind an old desk
( Choose generator)
The figure appears with a flashlight after you've hidden. Its Carver
He proceeds to the generator to turn it back on
Turns it on and walks away
Clementine moves out of the spot and grabs the tool
*Carver realizes he forgot something and walks back and shines the light on Clementine"
Carver: "Oh hoho Now this is a surprise"
Carver continues to be condescending while you are given the option to RUN!!! or silence
(Choose the run option)
Clementine Dashes for the nearest stack of wooden palettes
Carver grabs her throws her down, she bumps her head on the table where she grabbed the tool and passes out
AT THIS POINT you can start up where Dark_Stars Interrogation begins or listen tot he rest of mine.
Clementine wakes up,groggy
They are in a dark room
Carver: Well, you finally went and did it?"
Clementine: Silence
Carver: " You ended up abusing our hospitality, breaking our communities strict orders."
Carver: "Anything to say for yourself?"
Clementine: .....
Carver: "Well i know you didn't just conjure this plan up alone"
Carver: "Tell me sweetie, who put you up to this?"
Clementine: ......
Carver: "Hm... Well then not in the mood to talk?"
Carver: "......... Listen here sweet heart, i don't like to be rough with little kids, especially with young ladies like yourself. I wouldn't want to do to you what i did to Alvin. Its not necessary. All you have to do is tell me who told you to do this."
Clementine Choice: "It was Kenny" or "......"
If you choose Kenny he will go get Kenny and beat him in front of you
If you choose silence you choose to take the beating yourself, which will give her a black eye,a broken finger, and undone brutally ripped
stitches where her dog bite was mended
(The reasoning behind the broken finger is because how Telltale made Clementine focus on Carlos fingers when he asked Clementine to untie him at the end of episode 2. Epic foreshadowing)
After the beating of Kenny or Clementine, she is returned to the group where they are waiting in the cafeteria
Depressing but brilliant! Why did I get 2 dislikes? I'm sorry, but in the end, Clem needs to remember her biological family.
I'd say the hat. It's has sentimental value lying with her real family and Lee. The picture of Lee, obviously just the latter.
I actually kind of want that to happen... I mean I don't want to make Clementine chose between the two but I think it could be very powerful and a bit intense and emotional.
I gotta go with letting Kenny getting beat down. He can handle it better than AN 11 YEAR OLD.
I dont know how it would work but you have the opportunity to kill Carver while he is distracted fighting off walkers or save Crista from walkers. Maybe have a tied up Kenny yell "kill Carver!" so that you know if you select Carver you decide to kill him rather then save Crista.
Easily save Carlos. Kenny and Clem can both lunge at Carver while he's vulnerable and take him out!
Say Clem's getting a bit hungry and she's trapped,eat your leg or your arm,either way it sucks but you know I would certainly hope Clem would never get in a situation like this,or anyone for that matter.
One was Mark :P