If these 2 groups ran into each other....
What do you think would most likely happen?
Group 1
Leader: Lee
Group 2
Leader: Carver
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
What do you think would most likely happen?
Group 1
Leader: Lee
Group 2
Leader: Carver
Comments
Group 5. Maybelle gonna kick some ass.
Maybelle should be the leader of group 5 >:(
Agreed.
I don't know if roman and Andy St. John can exist in the same photo, what with the reused model.
The groups are pretty unbalanced - each one has more or less a 'type'
Group one has the protagonist-leader types and would be strongest.
Group two has all the antagonists(ish, I see Roman at least as being pretty grey) - it's hard to imagine them getting along with each other.
Group three has 'middle tier' characters - important supporting roles but not the main.
Group four is admittedly uncharacterizable
Group five is all third wheels who either are dead or probably will die soon. (Though Ben, Doug, and probably Sarah are more fleshed out and are arguably 'middle tier.)
Close one. I'd have to say it's a draw between 2 and 3
Still number 2, they got all kinds of characters that are more than willing to murder/rape someone.
The first 3 groups are OP compared to the rest =P
Group 1 has Lee Kenny Luke and Clementine, can't get any better than that, it's like a dream team ! Besides, Christa and Omid are actually pretty awesome as far as survival go but who knows how they'd fare against anything other than Walkers.
Group 2 is a concentration of rather tough guys, some of them barely being shy of the "psycopath" category. They'd probably win an all-out war. It depends if Nate goes mad and betrays them for shits and giggles (you know he could do that ^^)
Group 3 is well-balanced and versatile with members like Molly who is TTG's very own Assassin's Creed protag, Carley who has a pretty good aim and generally tough guys like Eddie and Vince. A close second in my opinion.
Group 4 errr, Rebecca's pregnant so useless, that girl who killed you know who in the toilets is useless as well, Larry's gonna get pissed that you didn't put his daughter in his team and get a heart attack. This group's screwed from the beginning.
Group 5 had Ben. That in itself means they'll lose. Maybelle and Doug are gonna do the carrying but eventually they'll lose pretty badly too.
Pretty funny =P
First of all: Love this post. Looks very fun especially with the visuals, thanks :P
Second:
Group-
Love this group, I wish I was in this group, that's how amazing it is.
Scary as hell, would definitely win and possibly survive the longest.
I think this one would try and be a strong team but might collapse on itself.
They probably wouldn't survive for too too long but they might have a chance.
BEST GROUPING EVER THIS GROUP WINS A PRIZE.
Tie between 1 and 3
For the group with longer survival, I'll bet Lee's could make it.
And for a fight between all of them, I think Lilly's group is more capable of that.
As much as I like Eddie Vince Molly and Carley they still have no chance against group 1.
Hell if the guys in group 2 were all fully loaded with m16 rifles they'd take over twd world!!
I still think Group 2 has the advantage, but Group 1 and 3 are tied for strength
Yeah group 3 does have some good shooters though they could be erratic.
Yeah, I know what you mean. Lilly and Molly have some history of abandoning their groups and Nick is a bit suicidal.
The last two groups I'm not even going to take seriously because they're very clearly "spares" tbh but...
In terms of survival:
Group 1 has a lot of powerful and clever people, and while it might run into some conflict, the only real stubborn ones are Luke and Kenny. They'd probably butt heads a lot, because Kenny gets riled up really easily and Luke is unflinching when he makes a decision. But I think the cool-headedness of Lee and Omid, and the no-nonsense authority of Christa and Clem could balance that out. Dream team, they would definitely las the longest.
Group 2 would think they're the dream team but tear each other apart the moment there's any disagreement. Too many angry men looking to dominate. They'll barely last a week.
I like Group 3 because it has a lot of interesting personalities, but it's unstable. Lilly is a good leader when Kenny's not there to rile her up, but Carley would challenge her authority a lot. Molly and Nick are wild cards, although Molly more so. Nick can take orders but Molly never would. Molly would eventually leave the group. Eddie and Vince would be good with teamwork and carrying out plans, but they'd be torn when Carley and Lilly argue. Ultimately, I see Vince siding with Lilly and Eddie favoring Carley. Lilly would get exasperated with Nick, so he'd probably side with Carley, but considering the fact he's suicidal and has no one in the group to lean on, I don't think he'd last long either, cutting the group down to four people split down the middle. Eventually they'd separate, Lilly and Vince going their way, and Eddie and Carley going theirs. They'd last a long time, though.
In terms of an all-out war:
Group 3 has competent fighters but isn't unified--it gets scattered and picked off the easiest. Group 2 endures, but mostly through brute strength. Group 2 also lacks unification and that's a disadvantage. Group 1 might lose a few, but it's the most likely to have the most concise plan and that's what wins in the end.
Group 5. Travis would kick ass.
Really, group 3. It has some great ass kickers.
How did you get the pictures like that.
well it is definitely not group 5 since they won't even last a day with ben as their leader in terms of the strongest group 2 would win
Well, group 1 is obviously the best/strongest group. That goes without saying! (Even though i gonna say it anyway)
unbalanced? noooooo lol
of course it is, group 5 is a joke!
and Group 1 is best of the best for the most part! Group 2 is very very close behind #1.
Group 1 all the way however, as I like them much more then 2. ;-)
Omfg you're right 0_0
I was scrolling down and when I saw Group 4, I thought, "Well, Group Four is f***ed."
Then I scrolled down to Group 5.
Too bad we didn't see her in action.. She let Danny get pitchfork'd by Lee pretty much right before her eyes.
Put KennyMahBro in group 5, I want him to get killed
I think Group 1 is the obvious choice, the others just have loads of butting heads.
Group 1 has good survivalists and all of them work well in a team except for Kenny. Unfortunately, Lee, Clem and Omid's compassion would likely mean they wouldnt abandon Kenny, which I believe would be a mistake and hurt them in the long run.
Group 2, I feel like Roman and Carver would get along well, they seem to have the same, "My group first and everyone else be damned" kind of attitude. Nate would stick around as long as he was given a long leash and Andy I think would be fine with whatever they did. I dont think Danny would stick around, I think hes above murder. Bandit leader, he probably would join if he didnt have a bandit group on his own, hes the type that seems to like roam and steal, while Roman and Carver's plan would be to just try and survive, causing conflict only when they deem it necessary.
Group 3 has great individual survivalists, but I dont think they would get along well. Vince, Lilly and Molly all seem like the loner type, while Eddie would likely be annoyance to the rest of the group. Nick would be begrudgingly accepted by the group, as I think Lilly, Molly and Carley would hate him for his rash decision making, but theyre not likely to kick him out of the group without significantly endangering them. I feel like if Vince were leader, this group might work out if Lilly can accept a marginalized role, but I feel like Molly and Carley's headstrong attitudes would clash with her insecurities as leader. Vince seemed like a strong leader for the 400 days group and seemed rational. I think he could make the group survive, but he would have a lot on his plate with Lilly, Molly and Carley all pulling in different directions and Nick and Eddie being... stupid.
Group 4, Campman would probably end up killing S2 thief lady, while Becca would have the unenviable position of being his new obsession. I doubt he would have the patience for Larry, especially without Lilly around to reel him in, so I think Campman would be callous enough to abandon him. With that, I feel like Campman, Rebecca, Becca and Bonnie wouldnt be able to survive that long, as I think Campman would try to do everything himself and end up getting himself killed.
Group 5, Id actually like to think about this, Doug would try to save one of them from something (something seemingly stupid or benign) and end up getting killed in the process. Then the rest would get picked off one by one.
So surviving the apocalypse? Group 1 overall, but group 3 if theyre able to get along. Group 2 would be able to survive a while, but largely due to strong leadership and fellowship between Carver and Roman
All out war? Toss up between Group 2 and 3, they have all people that would be willing to kill except maybe Eddie and Danny. Group 1 would be down due to Clem, Lee and Omid being soft on the trigger when it comes to killing
I think everyone is underestimating group 5.
Sure it looks stupid on the surface, but everyone in that team has two wonderful qualities.
1. They are all terrified of walkers and want to avoid them
2. they are all terrified of strangers and want to avoid them
This group will go out of their way to avoid as much danger as possible, also some of their members are smart and/or prepared (like Doug and Travis) they also have a cow, and Ben has basic knowledge on how to take care of barn animals (he says he used to work on a farm in the summers) None of them will butt heads over control of the group ether which is the problem with all the other groups. I can see them winning an all out war, just because they hid and let everyone else shoot at each other and then get eaten by all the walkers that were drawn in. As long as Maybel can keep reasonable quiet, I think they will do well.
Sam should be in one of those group.
Group 2 maybe ?
Strictly survival/realistically speaking? Group two will dominate the rest.
It's filled with people who are willing to do what it takes to survive, including murder. They seem to have no remorse or conscience about their actions, and act purely on survival and what is best for them.
Lolz at the last group by the way lmao
I agree, Also, if they surrender to group one, since they are nice, they will keep them alive and win together.
Got them from Walkingdead Wikia.com, copied and pasted them to Microsoft Paint, saved picture then uploaded to photobucket.com then copied the link of the pictures to post on here.
FAULTS
Group 1: Too nice/Forgiving, they are good traits but can get you killed.
Group 2: Will fight and cause chaos amongst each other
Group 3: So many different personalities would clash and it would be hard to get along.
Group 4: Dont see that group lasting long
Group 5: Aw fuck that, maybell is the only one that comes out alive.
Fuck off you sick pedo troll !!!!
Yeah and he's just ruined my thread the sad prick.
I assume group 5 is a joke, even tough Doug was quite useful and Sarah might prove to be more useful than she seems.
Group 2 is full of hardcore badasses, so they would probably be the overall 'strongest' group. Physically, that is.
Group 3 is full of mentally unstable people. Check for your self, none of them are completely cool headed but Carley. But, they're all damn good with weapons.
I think I'd give it to group 1. It has some of the most survivable characters seen so far, so clearly they did something right. 3 or 4(unknown if Christa is alive or dead) of them are still alive and the other two had an impressive run. Plus Lee's in it. He's Lee.
Anyone who says Group 1 is really just staying loyal to the main protagonists, seriously, Group 1 would definitely not stand a chance against Group 2 or Group 3.
I think Group 3 would be the most successful, honestly as they have Molly, Carley (a good shot, smart) Lilly (a decent shot at worst, good leader), Eddie and Vince who we can assume are able to survive, since they have, and Nick is kinda just there getting anxious, maybe shooting a few Matthew's.
Group 1 is what I like to think of as the main protagonists of the game and are a very likeable group, Group 2 is the baddy group full of tough guys who just want to kill and rape people and take all their stuff, Group 3 is an interesting group, it's sort of good and bad.
Group 1 is the best group (even with the fact of having a kid on it), also depending if Christa being pregnant or not, that would be a disadvantage.
and Group 2 would have a lot of internal fights and they would start killing each other at some point.
(Nate and the Bandit are psychos ass fuck, Carver and Roman would fight for the leadership of the group, and Danny is a nice guy even being a criminal, I guess he would not get along with the others.)
Group 2 is stronger in terms of survival and conquest because Carver, the St. John, and the guy with the hat from 400 days all have a stronger killer instinct and Carver and the Hat guy have the intimidation to keep the others in line. With the St. John they'll never starve, because I can see everyone but the prisoner guy going along with the cannibalism thing. With Carver's superior intelligence I can see them getting out of any tough situations, and I can see him just going on to create a governor-esqe society anyway, and the one he has now seems to be doing just fine. So I'm pretty sure that they're a superior group.
Group 3 is the second strongest because Lily has military experience, Vince doesn't seem like he'll take anybody's crap, but he also seems like he won't cause problems by arguing with Lily on a regular basis, that one girl is super bandit-y and ninja like, so they have a scout, and someone to find resources, Carly can handle herself and is capable of contributing to the group, Nick is a good shot and can be a big contributor to the group as long as he doesn't have another bridge incident.
Group 1 is the weakest because this group is way too emotional, argues to often, and is too wrapped up in morality. Kenny is too impulsive, and honestly kinda stupid, Luke and Lee care too much about Clementine's opinion, and Luke strikes me as a little daft. Clementine is a child and too many people care about her, and that's the reason the group feel apart in Season 1, because of Clementine. Christa and Omid are pretty capable, but I'm not very confident in their ability to deal with the living people in the walking dead universe.