›

What do YOU think happened to....

GoneButLivedOnGoneButLivedOn
edited May 2014 in The Walking Dead

LUKE. I really didn't like him at the start, but I was really starting to warm up to him and then he's gone. What do you think Kenny and Luke were discussing that resulted in Luke 'taking a hike'?

I, for one, am stumped!

EDIT A few of you were talking about who made the right decision. From what a lot of you have put together, it seems Luke stayed out to help and Kenny wanted to get involved... So, who made the right choice?

Personally, I think Luke did the right thing, if he abandoned them to help. He had spent time with Carver before, he knows the man's tips and tricks. I just hope he comes back to help them!!

Comments

  • True_ScumTrue_Scum
    Why the dislike already? I think they were discussing if Clem stayed in the lodge or going further with the Cabin group.
  • GoneButLivedOnGoneButLivedOn
    I was thinking that too, but why did Luke just storm off over that? From what we know, I find that unlike Luke.

    Although I definitely do think they were discussing Clem staying or going for sure!!
    True_Scum posted: »

    Why the dislike already? I think they were discussing if Clem stayed in the lodge or going further with the Cabin group.

  • RyleeRylee
    I doubt luke just stormed off.
  • Rock114Rock114
    I believe it was a debate over whether to go back and help the group once Carver showed up, or to hightail it in the opposite direction. Luke didn't want to help because he believed they wouldn't be able to do anything, while Kenny wanted to go back for Sarita and Clem, odds be damned. At that point, he told Luke to "take a hike" and proceeded to return on his own.
  • SergeantSnookieSergeantSnookie
    He might have seen Carver and his people and decided to stay back rather than storm in like Kenny did. He probably figured Carver didn't intend to kill anyone and knew it'd be stupid to rush in for a rescue at that point. He might be trailing behind now.

    Of course there could also be something more shady, but that's what I'll think until then.
  • WhatTheDuckWhatTheDuck
    Personally i hope it's a walker,guess i'll just wait and see.But it could be anybody in the game that wears a hat but that's not narrowing the search down to an extensive degree.
  • Mr_EeussMr_Eeuss
    Here's what I think that happened:

    Kenny and Luke saw the group being ambushed by Carver. Luke tried to convince Kenny to go and hide so they won't be captured and figure out a way to help the group later. Kenny being the impulsive hotheaded guy he is obviously disagreed and chose to abandon Luke and attack Carver instead which didn't go very well.

    So Luke basically avoided capture so he can help the group from outside.
  • GoneButLivedOnGoneButLivedOn
    Yeah, this is what I really want to believe!!
    SergeantSnookie posted: »

    He might have seen Carver and his people and decided to stay back rather than storm in like Kenny did. He probably figured Carver didn't int

  • GoneButLivedOnGoneButLivedOn
    This really makes sense to me, but Kenny could have relayed that to Clem if snuck outside. If Luke did run off to help from the outside, Kenny could have said that to Clem...
    Mr_Eeuss posted: »

    Here's what I think that happened: Kenny and Luke saw the group being ambushed by Carver. Luke tried to convince Kenny to go and hide s

  • AbstractWolfAbstractWolf
    I hope he's alright. My Clementine was starting to grow a friendship with him, along with Nick. He's a good guy but I'm a bit concerned how people like Nick and Carver keep mentioning negative things about Luke. Maybe he's not as good as he's saying he is..... but ya never know
  • Order 66Order 66
    Luke made a smart decision by staying undetected as he would be more use on the outside than inside Carvers compound
  • The Walking MustacheThe Walking Mustache
    edited May 2014
    I think this is exactly what happened, great theory! (Even though i believe Kenny made the right decision, but that's not part of this discussion!)
    Mr_Eeuss posted: »

    Here's what I think that happened: Kenny and Luke saw the group being ambushed by Carver. Luke tried to convince Kenny to go and hide s

  • Mr_EeussMr_Eeuss
    edited May 2014
    I can think of 2 reasons why he didn't:

    In-game reason: he wanted Clem on his side so he chose not to tell her about Luke's plans in case she agreed with him.

    irl reason: telltale wanted to keep the fans in suspense.
    GoneButLivedOn posted: »

    This really makes sense to me, but Kenny could have relayed that to Clem if snuck outside. If Luke did run off to help from the outside, Kenny could have said that to Clem...

  • GoneButLivedOnGoneButLivedOn
    Yeaaaaah that sounds very Kenny, actually, you may have got it!

    Ah, Trolltale is still at it :/
    Mr_Eeuss posted: »

    I can think of 2 reasons why he didn't: In-game reason: he wanted Clem on his side so he chose not to tell her about Luke's plans in case she agreed with him. irl reason: telltale wanted to keep the fans in suspense.

  • GoneButLivedOnGoneButLivedOn
    I found him hilarious myself, and he is the only one we reveal the Lee story to, I feel like that may come back later, he better come back!
    AbstractWolf posted: »

    I hope he's alright. My Clementine was starting to grow a friendship with him, along with Nick. He's a good guy but I'm a bit concerned how

  • CornPopperCornPopper Banned
    Kenny probably mentioned something about bonnie spying on them and Luke wanted to retreat and play it strategically while Kenny rushed in guns blazin
  • AhmedAli1AhmedAli1
    That could be true.
    Mr_Eeuss posted: »

    I can think of 2 reasons why he didn't: In-game reason: he wanted Clem on his side so he chose not to tell her about Luke's plans in case she agreed with him. irl reason: telltale wanted to keep the fans in suspense.

  • iHeartTWDiHeartTWD
    He will probably come back later with a plan or so
  • GoneButLivedOnGoneButLivedOn
    Bonnie did give her real name so if Kenny mentioned that to Luke before the ambush, Luke would have had time to prepare..
    CornPopper posted: »

    Kenny probably mentioned something about bonnie spying on them and Luke wanted to retreat and play it strategically while Kenny rushed in guns blazin

  • Cart_hero_2010Cart_hero_2010
    Scott Porter confirmed he was still voicing Luke, therefore, he is alive. I think he told Kenny they needed to run away and Kenny, being well Kenny, decided to tell Luke to take a hike. Luke will then come up with a plan.

    I think he goes to Matthew's shack and fixes the radio and talks to Clem. After they bring in the horde, he helps them escape.
  • Legendary12Legendary12
    For all we know they could of had an argument and then they heard the gunfire.. Kenny could of started to run to where it was coming from and Luke tries to stop him saying they should get out of there, then Kenny knocks him out.. When Luke wakes up everyones gone.
  • GoneButLivedOnGoneButLivedOn
    OH THANK GOD! Yess, that actually makes sense with the achievements we have!!
    Cart_hero_2010 posted: »

    Scott Porter confirmed he was still voicing Luke, therefore, he is alive. I think he told Kenny they needed to run away and Kenny, being wel

Sign in to comment in this discussion.