›

A choice like this?

ComingSoonComingSoon Banned
edited May 2014 in The Walking Dead
What if there was a 3-way choice at some point in E4 or E5? Like we have to choose to save Luke, Kenny (if he lives through E3) or Christa? It could be with 3 other characters all together.

Another thing they could do with this type of choice is that whoever you save, only one other person dies and your Season 3 is different. Like different scenes and dialogue.



Well, this is just something I whipped up from a thought I had a few days ago, so it may not be the most plausible.

Comments

  • ComingSoonComingSoon Banned
    Yeah, idk what I would do in a situation like this...
    Saoralba131 posted: »

    That would be good and a hard decision!

  • Saoralba131Saoralba131
    That would be good and a hard decision!
  • MysticMage44MysticMage44
    "and your Season 3 is drastically different. "

    This won't happen. Telltale isn't going to make 3 different versions of the same game. We might see differences in scenes, or maybe even chapters, but never whole seasons.
  • Alive_ClemAlive_Clem
    That's a hard decision. I would like to save Luke and Christa in first place, well, maybe Christa would be the best option... Idk.
  • ComingSoonComingSoon Banned
    That's what I meant by different. Like different scenes and dialogue. Again, I sort of whipped this up.
    MysticMage44 posted: »

    "and your Season 3 is drastically different. " This won't happen. Telltale isn't going to make 3 different versions of the same game. We might see differences in scenes, or maybe even chapters, but never whole seasons.

  • FirewallcanoFirewallcano
    It could easily be done if they incorporate determinant characters into the choice
  • ComingSoonComingSoon Banned
    That's one thing I thought of as well, but never in detail or anything. Like Nick could survive into S3 if he lives in your S2 E2, but if he dies then Luke will run into you. Maybe with another determinant character in the future that we just don't know about yet.
    Firewallcano posted: »

    It could easily be done if they incorporate determinant characters into the choice

  • JackoryKearnsJackoryKearns
    oh gosh, i would love that to happen :O Well done, thats a really hard choice!

    Lukes a new friend that is a symbol of moving on,
    Kenny is an old best friend of Lee's (depending on your decisions)
    and Christa has been with you for over two years just surviving after shit went down
  • ComingSoonComingSoon Banned
    Yes, Christa is definitely a strong character. I might choose her if I were to run into a choice like this. But, then again...if any of the cabin survivors are with you, they'll want to save Luke. And Kenny's just an old friend, but I have a sneaky suspicion that he may be tipping over the edge in the next few episodes.
    JackoryKearns posted: »

    oh gosh, i would love that to happen :O Well done, thats a really hard choice! Lukes a new friend that is a symbol of moving on, Kenn

  • True_ScumTrue_Scum
    I would choose Kenny because we know the most of him, we travelled with him a whole time and going both trough a lot together in Season 1, we've known Luke only for 2 episodes and Christa for 3/4 episodes I would definitely not choose Christa, Know why? because they left Clem a 8 year old child go alone in the bathroom and then get mad at her if things go wrong, it's a child! that was just a selfish action of her and Omid.... and then Luke yeah' Luke what about him? Seems like a nice and smart guy but then Bam! he's away with no information of Kenny where he went, I'd like to know more about Luke he's sure a interesting character, so my choice is still Kenny, don't know why people are saying that Christa is a strong character if you look at her appearance after the 16 months skip she looks weak as hell not only physical but also mental. I do not hate Christa but she does not look well enough to take care of Clem, Kenny seems a bit fast angered in Season 2 but he is still strong enough to take care of a/the group and sure to take care of Clem.
  • ComingSoonComingSoon Banned
    edited May 2014
    Luke disappearing was definitely fishy. I think he will return in Episode 3 though. I can see where you are coming from as far as Kenny goes, but I just have a suspicion that he is still mourning the loss of his son and wife. I know that Christa does look weak mentally and physically, but I'm saying she's strong for sticking through losing her husband and then obviously her baby throughout a year's passing.
    True_Scum posted: »

    I would choose Kenny because we know the most of him, we travelled with him a whole time and going both trough a lot together in Season 1, w

  • Lompi-Clem4everLompi-Clem4ever
    edited May 2014
    This is gonna suck. Hard decision, that's for sure.

    A choice Luke. Yes, i know, this is very unpopular, but he is my favorite character behind Clem (Clem is the number one).

    But i hope this choice thing never happened. All Walking Dead player cry out their eyes.
  • ComingSoonComingSoon Banned
    Yeah, any character that we bond with, we cry when they die. Or at least choke up. ;(
    Lompi-Clem4ever posted: »

    This is gonna suck. Hard decision, that's for sure. A choice Luke. Yes, i know, this is very unpopular, but he is my favorite character

  • DomeWing333DomeWing333
    Definitely Christa. Don't really care that much which of the other two die, but I"m leaning towards Kenny at this point.
Sign in to comment in this discussion.