I thought he just wanted to keep the food for himself, so I said no. Even if I'd realized he meant it should be for Rebecca, I still would have said no. The entire group should get to decide who gets what, not just Alvin.
I did, simply because I'm not a very confrontational person and I figured one can wasn't going to hurt anyone. Plus I trusted that he really did mean for it to be for Rebecca.
I think I trusted him a lot more knowing that he has the option of helping you out in Episode 1 if you ask him, even though I didn't get that option in my own game.
When he asked, I thought back to Clem telling him that she would do whatever she could to repay him. A deal is a deal, so yeah, I allowed him to take it.
I kept silent. I didn't want to outright deny his request. I just wanted let him know that I wasn't comfortable doing this.
I also didn't see why he felt like he needed to be all surreptitious about it. If he asked, I'm sure the group would have let Rebecca have most of it. Carlos would probably want some for Sarah, but I think the rest would have been okay with prioritizing the pregnant woman's needs ...even if she is a bitch.
I didn't lie no because I didn't think it was right for Alvin to ask a child such a question. The whole group should decide and my Clem is honest. She was honest with Sarah. The only one she's lied to so far is Carver.
That's a really interesting compromise. I never chose that option, even on my mostly silent playthrough (I usually replied when people asked Clem a direct question.)
I kept silent. I didn't want to outright deny his request. I just wanted let him know that I wasn't comfortable doing this.
I also didn… more't see why he felt like he needed to be all surreptitious about it. If he asked, I'm sure the group would have let Rebecca have most of it. Carlos would probably want some for Sarah, but I think the rest would have been okay with prioritizing the pregnant woman's needs ...even if she is a bitch.
I thought the "I won't lie for you" reply would be more of a "if they ask I won't lie, but you can have it" and less of what it was, so I chose it. I felt bad afterwards; I didn't want to be mean for Alvin considering he helped Clem out in EP1.
Actually, we do. If you ask Rebecca who's baby it is in episode 1, she tells you straight up that she KNOWS it's Carver's in episode 2 because her and Alvin had been trying for a very long time then she fucked Carver and OOH IM PREGGERZ.
I said the whole group should decide. I was pretty sure they would say yes, but it would prevent the possible drama that could happen if we didn't tell them. Kind of like the situation where Kenny gets angry at you if he learns that you are a murderer from Lilly, but if you tell him he's ok with it because you didn't hide it from him.
I did. I thought it was a fair trade-off for giving Clem a bandage and the juicebox in EP1. Alvin technically stole from his group for a stranger. And I don't think Alvin is the type of guy to take food for himself, so I trusted him.
I told Alvin I'd remember he helped me, when he gave Clem the juicebox and bandage. The peaches for Rebecca was a great way to repay that kindness, and it didn't turn into a big deal so I don't regret it.
I told Alvin the group should decide, where then they could've decided if to agree with it or given Rebecca a little more than everyone else. At least that's how I thought of it when I made up my mind.
Keeping a whole can though? Nope. There's seven people in their group, two of them young kids/teens. Give extra for the pregnant lady sure, maybe even half a can if she's not feeling well, but not one whole can of the only two cans of food on them. And Clem might be bright for her age but she's still a kid. For Alvin to go and try to convince her to hand over a can instead of asking in front of the adults seemed like trying to take peaches from a baby.
Comments
big boi gotta eat
I don't even think he would have kept it for himself, but it's still totally not right. The whole group should decide.
Also, the ones who needed the food most (other than pregnant Rebecca) were Sarah and Clementine
Fatty Alvin would have survived a little longer without food, but Clem and Sarah are both kids. He shouldn't have been so selfish
I think I trusted him a lot more knowing that he has the option of helping you out in Episode 1 if you ask him, even though I didn't get that option in my own game.
I also didn't see why he felt like he needed to be all surreptitious about it. If he asked, I'm sure the group would have let Rebecca have most of it. Carlos would probably want some for Sarah, but I think the rest would have been okay with prioritizing the pregnant woman's needs ...even if she is a bitch.
Keeping a whole can though? Nope. There's seven people in their group, two of them young kids/teens. Give extra for the pregnant lady sure, maybe even half a can if she's not feeling well, but not one whole can of the only two cans of food on them. And Clem might be bright for her age but she's still a kid. For Alvin to go and try to convince her to hand over a can instead of asking in front of the adults seemed like trying to take peaches from a baby.