›

About Troy...

Everyone'sClemInTimeEveryone'sClemInTime
edited May 2014 in The Walking Dead
So, everyone wants Troy dead because he hit Clementine in a scene we no nothing about. Seems reasonable. People talk about "I don't want her to lose her innocence", and then chant "death to Troy." Don't be a hypocrite. You're not protecting her by slaying anyone who gives her a dirty look. You're further pushing her into that territory.

Comments

  • ericsp0fericsp0f
    her innocence whus lost a long time ago
  • Saltlick123Saltlick123
    But in a way TROY could be pushing her into that territory too, we don't know yet, #fucktroy
  • RyleeRylee
    I still don't like troy. You don't hit a kid.
  • Saltlick123Saltlick123
    Especially a little girl, with a frickin ak 47
    Rylee posted: »

    I still don't like troy. You don't hit a kid.

  • ClemForPresidentClemForPresident
    There's a difference between defending her and just slaying someone, I wouldn't kill him but I'd beat him shitless, in Clem's defense, not to push her further into anything, but in her defense and in intention to protect her and to not let someone get away with nailing a little child in the face.
  • Everyone'sClemInTimeEveryone'sClemInTime
    There's alot of thing you don't do. Like murder a man who has his gun lowered and is no immediate threat. Or lock a girl in a shed who is obviously bleeding out. Yet the VAST majority of people like Nick and Carlos. So, all I'm saying is don't throw someone under the bus who isn't even on the bus yet.
    Saltlick123 posted: »

    Especially a little girl, with a frickin ak 47

  • PedoLukePedoLuke Banned
    Luke didn't know that Clem lost her "innocence" a long time ago. X_X
    ericsp0f posted: »

    her innocence whus lost a long time ago

  • BenUsefulBenUseful
    I got an idea on how to make Troy a fan favorite. Replace Clementine in that scene with Becca.
  • Kenny_and_ClemKenny_and_Clem
    When people say "death to Troy" I'm pretty sure they mean for someone else to kill him, like Kenny or walkers. So people still don't want Clem to lose her innocence.
  • Everyone'sClemInTimeEveryone'sClemInTime
    It doesn't matter, they want Clem to be protected by assuring everyone who even touches her dies a bitter and painful death. Thats fucked up.
    Kenny_and_Clem posted: »

    When people say "death to Troy" I'm pretty sure they mean for someone else to kill him, like Kenny or walkers. So people still don't want Clem to lose her innocence.

  • _Juice_Box__Juice_Box_
    I never said "I don't want Clem to lose her innocence"... she already lost that... and I don't see how Clem getting hit connects with her losing her innocence and Troy dying and shit. I don't care what Clem did, there were different ways for Troy to stop her, even pushing her would have done something, Troy is a full grown men. Full grown men are assholes if they hit a kid like that.
  • _Juice_Box__Juice_Box_
    Well Nick is an asshole and Carlos did what anyone would do...well, I liked Carlos until I went back and played the kitchen scene where you can spy on all of their dialogue. You learn that Clem could have died without medical attention immediately, and Luke and Pete were the only ones who were trying to think of ways to save her. Fuck Carlos. Fuck Nick. Fuck Alvin. Fuck Rebecca.
    Everyone'sClemInTime posted: »

    There's alot of thing you don't do. Like murder a man who has his gun lowered and is no immediate threat. Or lock a girl in a shed who is ob

  • Everyone'sClemInTimeEveryone'sClemInTime
    Getting hit doesn't make her lose anything is the point. "Full grown men are assholes if they hit a kid like that", this isn't Disneyland, nor season 1. Season 2 already has more morally ambiguous characters than the whole of season 1. Meaning characters are going to do things that seem questionable. And you know something? I don't trust nor like anyone from the cabin group, they have far too many secrets attached to them.
    _Juice_Box_ posted: »

    I never said "I don't want Clem to lose her innocence"... she already lost that... and I don't see how Clem getting hit connects with her lo

  • BenUsefulBenUseful
    edited May 2014
    I wonder if the time between season 1 and season 2 wasn't enough to lose her innocence. Or if the 3 timeskips during Season 2 wasn't enough.
    (more directed to the "She's innocent" crowd)
  • MulderYuffieMulderYuffie
    I am getting bad vibes from some of the post in this thread lmao.
  • Everyone'sClemInTimeEveryone'sClemInTime
    There's still people that cling to notion oddly enough.
    BenUseful posted: »

    I wonder if the time between season 1 and season 2 wasn't enough to lose her innocence. Or if the 3 timeskips during Season 2 wasn't enough. (more directed to the "She's innocent" crowd)

  • Everyone'sClemInTimeEveryone'sClemInTime
    What do you mean?
    MulderYuffie posted: »

    I am getting bad vibes from some of the post in this thread lmao.

  • _Juice_Box__Juice_Box_
    Getting hit does hurt her. The point that his intentions were to hurt her is what I have a problem with. He needs to be stopped and that's the point. Also, yes, I don't trust the cabin group either except for Luke and I did trust Pete, but we all know what happened to him...
    Everyone'sClemInTime posted: »

    Getting hit doesn't make her lose anything is the point. "Full grown men are assholes if they hit a kid like that", this isn't Disneyland, n

  • BenUsefulBenUseful
    Man, if what happens from Ep 3 to Ep 5 wasn't enough, I dont know what is. How many characters Clem liked died during that span of time? Not to mention the entire stranger incident and her parents.
    Everyone'sClemInTime posted: »

    There's still people that cling to notion oddly enough.

  • Everyone'sClemInTimeEveryone'sClemInTime
    Fair enough. I can't argue with that, he did hurt her. I'm simply recommending we all wait before marking his death before the episode even comes out.
    _Juice_Box_ posted: »

    Getting hit does hurt her. The point that his intentions were to hurt her is what I have a problem with. He needs to be stopped and that's t

  • Alive_ClemAlive_Clem
    I'm just gonna copypast a comment that I did in the other discussion "When they put this type of scenes in the game is to people react to it. If you just keep thinking that the characters have always a good reason for what they did then you won't enjoy the game as much as other people did."
  • _Juice_Box__Juice_Box_
    You do have a good point there. Maybe it just made sense for him to do that, although I doubt it. Either way, it will be a damn powerful scene.
    Everyone'sClemInTime posted: »

    Fair enough. I can't argue with that, he did hurt her. I'm simply recommending we all wait before marking his death before the episode even comes out.

  • BenUsefulBenUseful
    The problem with not having a motive is that the character doing the action may look stupid or look like a sociopath. When someone fucks up or does some crazy shit, they usually have a reason to do so. The reason doesn't need to be good though.
    Alive_Clem posted: »

    I'm just gonna copypast a comment that I did in the other discussion "When they put this type of scenes in the game is to people react to it

  • Everyone'sClemInTimeEveryone'sClemInTime
    On that, we can agree. Can't wait! Is there an official release date?
    _Juice_Box_ posted: »

    You do have a good point there. Maybe it just made sense for him to do that, although I doubt it. Either way, it will be a damn powerful scene.

  • FlamingOblivionFlamingOblivion
    Or Michelle.
    BenUseful posted: »

    I got an idea on how to make Troy a fan favorite. Replace Clementine in that scene with Becca.

  • The Walking MustacheThe Walking Mustache
    edited May 2014
    I couldn't agree more with the creator of this thread. Give me all the dislikes in the world, that won't stop me (and i hope also alot of other persons) from saying their own personal opinions.

    Troy is definitely a shitbird (hell, maybe even a bigger one than Ben, but we don't know that yet) and he did hurt Clementine, which is a terrible thing obviously! But most of the people on this Forum are clearly overreacting!

    But anyway, this community shouldn't worry to much about it. Karma is a funny thing, in the world of The Walking Dead! " Go on! You don't need to see this! "
  • Alive_ClemAlive_Clem
    Yeah but in this scene people want him to have a good reason to hit Clem, if you understand me.
    BenUseful posted: »

    The problem with not having a motive is that the character doing the action may look stupid or look like a sociopath. When someone fucks up or does some crazy shit, they usually have a reason to do so. The reason doesn't need to be good though.

  • _Juice_Box__Juice_Box_
    You didn't hear? May 13th bro :P Or for certain platforms
    Everyone'sClemInTime posted: »

    On that, we can agree. Can't wait! Is there an official release date?

  • BenUsefulBenUseful
    She got shot though so she dead.
    FlamingOblivion posted: »

    Or Michelle.

  • BenUsefulBenUseful
    Guys, Clementine was just breaking an AK-47 with her face.
    Saltlick123 posted: »

    Especially a little girl, with a frickin ak 47

  • Saltlick123Saltlick123
    Was She was trying to audition for that talent show?
    BenUseful posted: »

    Guys, Clementine was just breaking an AK-47 with her face.

  • Clem_EverettClem_Everett
    Totally agree with that. Clem has been through a lot, and saw so much shit. she is no longer innocent but is extremely brave for a young girl!
    BenUseful posted: »

    Man, if what happens from Ep 3 to Ep 5 wasn't enough, I dont know what is. How many characters Clem liked died during that span of time? Not to mention the entire stranger incident and her parents.

  • Everyone'sClemInTimeEveryone'sClemInTime
    Nice.
    _Juice_Box_ posted: »

    You didn't hear? May 13th bro :P Or for certain platforms

  • Everyone'sClemInTimeEveryone'sClemInTime
    That part was super ominous, can't wait to see what will happen.
    The Walking Mustache posted: »

    I couldn't agree more with the creator of this thread. Give me all the dislikes in the world, that won't stop me (and i hope also alot of ot

Sign in to comment in this discussion.