›

Who do you think the most underrated and overrated characters are ?

TGP95TGP95
edited May 2014 in The Walking Dead
Hello ,

Since episode 3's coming , I wanted to ask you about the most underrated / overrated character(s) in your opinion ?

For me the most underrated characters are Molly and Eddie , I feel like they deserve to appear again and stay alive for a while , it would be great to see those two again ..

As for the most overrated character , I think it's Luke , he's good and cool but he's in the spotlight more than he deserves , even if he may not appear in the next 2 episodes , and I think Nick could've better in his position , so what do you all think :) ?
«13

Comments

  • PorkytheWalkerPorkytheWalker
    Most overrated character: Nate

    Most underrated character: Doug
  • TGP95TGP95
    Yeah and I think Kenny's a bit overrated too , I like him , but some fans make him look like superman :D
    PorkytheWalker posted: »

    Most overrated character: Nate Most underrated character: Doug

  • WhatTheDuckWhatTheDuck
    Most Overated Character-Train Most Underated Character-BOAT ALWAYS BOAT.
  • PorkytheWalkerPorkytheWalker
    Exactly and I do praise his beard but never in a serious way but in a joking way lol
    TGP95 posted: »

    Yeah and I think Kenny's a bit overrated too , I like him , but some fans make him look like superman :D

  • SergeantSnookieSergeantSnookie
    Underrated: Duck, Mark and Chuck

    Overrated: I don't know, actually. Most of the characters that get a lot of love I was actually rather fond of too. I wasn't quite as enthused with Carley as many others were, I guess.
  • TGP95TGP95
    Are you sure about Duck :D ?
    SergeantSnookie posted: »

    Underrated: Duck, Mark and Chuck Overrated: I don't know, actually. Most of the characters that get a lot of love I was actually rather fond of too. I wasn't quite as enthused with Carley as many others were, I guess.

  • TGP95TGP95
    Praise The Boat !
    WhatTheDuck posted: »

    Most Overated Character-Train Most Underated Character-BOAT ALWAYS BOAT.

  • WhatTheDuckWhatTheDuck
    ( ? ) Duck thinks your incredibly awesome.
    SergeantSnookie posted: »

    Underrated: Duck, Mark and Chuck Overrated: I don't know, actually. Most of the characters that get a lot of love I was actually rather fond of too. I wasn't quite as enthused with Carley as many others were, I guess.

  • SergeantSnookieSergeantSnookie
    I liked Duck. :S
    TGP95 posted: »

    Are you sure about Duck :D ?

  • PorkytheWalkerPorkytheWalker
    Most Overrated: That building (Ya know THAT building)

    Most underrated: Walker number 459
  • SergeantSnookieSergeantSnookie
    edited May 2014
    I'm sorry I had to kill you, you annoyingly lovable little shit. :S

    :(
    WhatTheDuck posted: »

    ( ? ) Duck thinks your incredibly awesome.

  • PorkytheWalkerPorkytheWalker
    Well honestly Duck is just a goofy kid sure he's moronic but he has charm coming out of his ass!

    You can't help but be amused with him

    PS: Lee will always be Batman
    TGP95 posted: »

    Are you sure about Duck :D ?

  • TGP95TGP95
    Walker number 459 ? I thought 111 was the most underrated , Damn ..
    PorkytheWalker posted: »

    Most Overrated: That building (Ya know THAT building) Most underrated: Walker number 459

  • SergeantSnookieSergeantSnookie
    edited May 2014
    I think a lot of the hate he got simply came from the fact that he was bound to be compared to Clementine - a kid who is much easier to like than he is due to not running her mouth quite as much. :S
    PorkytheWalker posted: »

    Well honestly Duck is just a goofy kid sure he's moronic but he has charm coming out of his ass! You can't help but be amused with him PS: Lee will always be Batman

  • WhatTheDuckWhatTheDuck
    *Throws up high five*
    SergeantSnookie posted: »

    I'm sorry I had to kill you, you annoyingly lovable little shit. :S :(

  • PorkytheWalkerPorkytheWalker
    Walker number 111 is an honourable mention though!
    TGP95 posted: »

    Walker number 459 ? I thought 111 was the most underrated , Damn ..

  • OzzyUKOzzyUK Moderator
    That's exactly what i do. I like Kenny as a character and was happy when i saw him return but he is very overrated at times and his extreme fans never see any faults in his actions even if its a bad choice, that "Kenny confirmed for season 2" gif drove me mad when it was constantly getting spammed everywhere before the release of A House Divided
    PorkytheWalker posted: »

    Exactly and I do praise his beard but never in a serious way but in a joking way lol

  • SergeantSnookieSergeantSnookie
    edited May 2014
    *leaves it hanging for a moment due to mouse not responding*

    *accepts*

    Actually happened the first time. :C
    WhatTheDuck posted: »

    *Throws up high five*

  • PorkytheWalkerPorkytheWalker
    Yeah he is kinda annoying but he's awesome you gotta give him props for acting like this during the ZA!

    But there was that thing with Shawn....(Shutters)
    SergeantSnookie posted: »

    I think a lot of the hate he got simply came from the fact that he was bound to be compared to Clementine - a kid who is much easier to like than he is due to not running her mouth quite as much. :S

  • WhatTheDuckWhatTheDuck
    *Grabs Lee's Dick*You like leaving me hanging you little shit,you dirty urban. *High fives Clementine*.
    SergeantSnookie posted: »

    *leaves it hanging for a moment due to mouse not responding* *accepts* Actually happened the first time. :C

  • SergeantSnookieSergeantSnookie
    ...
    WhatTheDuck posted: »

    *Grabs Lee's Dick*You like leaving me hanging you little shit,you dirty urban. *High fives Clementine*.

  • PorkytheWalkerPorkytheWalker
    lol leave it to WhatTheDuck to make something awkward!
    SergeantSnookie posted: »

    ...

  • LeeAintDeadFFSLeeAintDeadFFS
    Overrated: Carley

    Underrated: Carlos
  • WhatTheDuckWhatTheDuck
    HAAAAAAHA I'M FUCKIN DYIN!!
    PorkytheWalker posted: »

    lol leave it to WhatTheDuck to make something awkward!

  • PorkytheWalkerPorkytheWalker
    YEAH DAWG MEEEEE TOOOOOO BRAAAAAAAA
    WhatTheDuck posted: »

    HAAAAAAHA I'M FUCKIN DYIN!!

  • BenPaulBenPaul Banned
    Ben deserved more time in the game
  • PorkytheWalkerPorkytheWalker
    Well I think they should have at least gave him a chance to redeem himself...
    BenPaul posted: »

    Ben deserved more time in the game

  • Itchy_TastyItchy_Tasty
    Most Over-Rated: Stuff

    Most Under-Rated: Things
  • OmidShouldHaveLivedOmidShouldHaveLived
    edited May 2014
    Overrated: Nate. I guess he's funny, but he's creepier than he is funny. At least to me.

    Underrated: Carlos. He screwed up in ep1, but he showed a lot of guts with Carver in ep2.

    EDIT: Christa is underrated too. After all she went through, she still has the strength to keep going.
  • sayakamikisayakamiki
    edited May 2014
    Overrated: Kenny, Luke, Carley
    Underrated: Christa, Doug, Katjaa

    Seriously, no one gives Christa enough credit.
  • ArthurMatrixArthurMatrix
    lol Ben.
    BenPaul posted: »

    Ben deserved more time in the game

  • RichWalk23RichWalk23
    A controversial opinion coming right up.

    Overrated: Kenny, Carley, Nick

    Underrated: Doug, Katjaa, Chuck, Christa, Omid, Pete, Alvin
  • PipasPipas
    Overrated: Kenny
    Underrated: Doug, Duck, Chuck and Christa
  • Davidsanden27Davidsanden27
    Underrated: mark

    Overrated: Christa :3
  • Davidsanden27Davidsanden27
    Omid is definitively not underrated he is in the middle and how is Nick overrated? He got a shit ton of hate when ep 2 came out and he still gets some but he doesn't deserve it.
    RichWalk23 posted: »

    A controversial opinion coming right up. Overrated: Kenny, Carley, Nick Underrated: Doug, Katjaa, Chuck, Christa, Omid, Pete, Alvin

  • Geo92Geo92
    edited May 2014
    Overrated: Kenny (a little, even though I like him a lot), Luke


    Underrated: Omid, Chuck, Doug, Mark, Larry
  • BigBlindMaxBigBlindMax Banned
    Overrated: Kenny, Carley

    Underrated: Mark, The Stranger, Lily
  • RubyMoonRubyMoon
    Overrated : Kenny for sure.

    Underrated : Mark !
  • Kathara6Kathara6
    Overrated: Carley
    Underrated: Doug
  • RichWalk23RichWalk23
    edited May 2014
    Omid comes across as underrated to me due to his absence in the majority of Episode 4, his late appearance in Episode 3 along with Christa, and his short-lived appearance in the first episode of Season 2.

    I feel that Nick is overrated because of how much characterisation given to him compared to the other Season 2 characters in a short amount of time. This isn't a bad thing, but it runs the risk of other characters being cast aside in terms of development.
    Davidsanden27 posted: »

    Omid is definitively not underrated he is in the middle and how is Nick overrated? He got a shit ton of hate when ep 2 came out and he still gets some but he doesn't deserve it.

Sign in to comment in this discussion.