Choices - Version 2 (POLL) (SPOILERS for S1/S2)

The answers from my other Choices topic were very interesting, so I made some more.
Please say what you would do out of the choices:

1. You come into a situation with the group that you can only feed a few of them. Say this group has 13 members, but you can only feed THREE.
A. Feed the weaker adults, the children and teens.
B. Hold a lottery.
C. Make someone else do it. Afterall, you feel bad.

2. You are a member of the Crawford community, and you are one of Crawfords top leading officials, and you are right down to the book and follow all rules. Your friend reveals to you that he has cancer. He is a close friend, and he is extremely scared that Crawford will throw him out to die. Crawford throws everyone with a bad sickness or illness out, including cancer. What do you do?
A. Tell the group anyways, at risk of your friends life.
B. Hide it, knowing that if you get caught, you and him both could get thrown out.

3. Your group is low on resources and food. Two teenage boys sneak into your camp and steal this food, but are caught. They are visibly starving, scared and lonely. What do you do?
A. Kill them.
B. Let them live, at risk of them possibly coming back with a dangerous group.

4. Your Boyfriend/Girlfriend is shot in the stomach, and will bleed out if you don't give him/her the right treatment. If you do, you will use ALL the medical supplies, which will then cause the other group members to be at risk. There is also a chance that he/she won't survive the operation. What do you do?
A. Perform the operation, knowing that he/she could still die during the surgery, and the supplies will be wasted if so.
B. Let him/her die, to protect the supplies and keep it for later.

5. You and your group are held hostage. The group holding your group hostage takes you at gunpoint and tells you to kill your brother. If you do, he will let the group go. What do you do?
A. Kill my brother, saving the entire group.
B. Do not kill my brother, risking the entire group.

6. Luke and Sarah are trapped in a burning car which is upside down and leaking gas. You can only save on of them before it explodes and roasts the one left behind. Who do you save?
A. Luke
B. Sarah

7. Say you are part of the cabin group when Clementine arrives. You know absolutely nothing about her. Do you side with Pete and Luke about Clem, or side with Nick and Rebecca?
A. Pete and Luke. She might be telling the truth.
B. Nick and Rebecca. She might be working with carver.

8. You are voted group planner by group. You are planning to move to the group somewhere in NYC. Where do you move to?
A. The world trade center. It is a new, fortified complex, raised off street level, and is easily defended. It is also a symbol of america able to stand any threat and rebuild.
B. The Statue Of Liberty. Its a symbol of freedom, and is on an island.
C. The empire state building. Its old, and is a symbol of america and its money. It is tall and you can live upstairs away from walkers.

BONUS:
9. In Season 1, who did you side with more?
A. Kenny
B. Lilly

10. In Season 2 EP 1, who did you save?
A. Nick
B. Pete

Have fun ;)

Comments

  • My choices:

    1. A. I choose to feed the weak first.
    2. B. I Hide it. I know that we could get thrown out, but he is my friend, and is counting on me.
    3. C. I let them live and see what happens. I cannot just let some weak younglings starve.
    4. B. I let them die. I know its sad, but we need to think about the others too.
    5. A. I kill my brother to protect the group.
    6. B. Sarah. She is young, and Luke would want her to be saved first.
    7. A. I cannot let a little girl die, even if she is working with a maniac.
    8. A. The World Trade Center is a safe place. Lifted off the ground and is easily defended. Live upstairs and keep the tower base clear.
    BONUS:
    9. B. Lilly. Lilly was actually trying to keep the group alive. Kenny was a danger to the group and only cared about his family rather than the others.
    10. B. Nick. I seen Pete get bit. I knew he would die anyways, so I saved Nick, who wasn't bit.
  • edited May 2014
    I'll just take a few random ones.

    2: tell them. Why risk both our lives?

    3: I'd kill them. They made their choice, so they pay for it.

    4: perform the operation. You need family in the apocalypse.

    7: side with Nick. How could I know she's innocent?
  • edited May 2014
    1. You come into a situation with the group that you can only feed a few of them. Say this group has 13 members, but you can only feed THREE.
    A. Feed the weaker adults, the children and teens.
    -- Just makes sense --

    2. You are a member of the Crawford community, and you are one of Crawfords top leading officials, and you are right down to the book and follow all rules. Your friend reveals to you that he has cancer. He is a close friend, and he is extremely scared that Crawford will throw him out to die. Crawford throws everyone with a bad sickness or illness out, including cancer. What do you do?
    B. Hide it, knowing that if you get caught, you and him both could get thrown out.
    -- It's better to go together if we have to --

    3. Your group is low on resources and food. Two teenage boys sneak into your camp and steal this food, but are caught. They are visibly starving, scared and lonely. What do you do?
    B. Let them live, at risk of them possibly coming back with a dangerous group.
    -- Honestly, if they do become a threat later than it'll just have to be dealt with but there's no justifying murder --

    4. Your Boyfriend/Girlfriend is shot in the stomach, and will bleed out if you don't give him/her the right treatment. If you do, you will use ALL the medical supplies, which will then cause the other group members to be at risk. There is also a chance that he/she won't survive the operation. What do you do?
    A. Perform the operation, knowing that he/she could still die during the surgery, and the supplies will be wasted if so.
    -- Supplies are replaceable but life isn't --

    5. You and your group are held hostage. The group holding your group hostage takes you at gunpoint and tells you to kill your brother. If you do, he will let the group go. What do you do?
    A. Kill my brother, saving the entire group.
    -- Fuck, this one is difficult. I have to say though, keeping my brother alive would be selfish because it'd mean the death of many others --

    6. Luke and Sarah are trapped in a burning car which is upside down and leaking gas. You can only save on of them before it explodes and roasts the one left behind. Who do you save?
    B. Sarah
    -- Sorry Luke, but Sarah's a kid --

    7. Say you are part of the cabin group when Clementine arrives. You know absolutely nothing about her. Do you side with Pete and Luke about Clem, or side with Nick and Rebecca?
    A. Pete and Luke. She might be telling the truth.
    -- I would sort of side with Nick and Rebecca except killing her wouldn't be necessary so I side more with Pete and Luke --

    8. You are voted group planner by group. You are planning to move to the group somewhere in NYC. Where do you move to?
    B. The Statue Of Liberty. Its a symbol of freedom, and is on an island.
    -- I don't really care about the fact that it's symbolic, but it is on an island, which is good --

    9. In Season 1, who did you side with more?
    A. Kenny
    -- Fuck you, Lilly, and i'm not even a Kenny fan --

    10. In Season 2 EP 1, who did you save?
    B. Pete
    -- Even bit, I still preferred Pete --
  • "Damn, that's cold"
    Giraffehat posted: »

    I'll just take a few random ones. 2: tell them. Why risk both our lives? 3: I'd kill them. They made their choice, so they pay fo

  • Sometimes you gotta play a role, even if the people you love hate you for it. I can't risk my group's safety.
    _Juice_Box_ posted: »

    "Damn, that's cold"

  • edited May 2014
    1 B make Lottery
    2) B , besides cancer's symptoms are too late to show way too late I study science kinda hard at early to tell from an untrained doctor
    3) C- leave it up to vote
    4) B- it's the apocalypse no time for that shit no more
    5) B
    6) A- Luke is more useful , Sarah is a heavy weight
    7) A
    8) A
    9) A- because kenny is the guy always outside with me he is ore useful than a girl who sit on her ass all day bitching about stupid shit and broken flashights !!! JESUS !!
    10) A - Nick cause Pete got bit
  • 1.) A, but I would consult the group beforehand.

    2.) A. Sorry bud, if symptoms are showing, it's already just a matter of time.

    3.) Vote or hold them hostage for a while to see if by one comes for them.

    4.) B. Sorry darling, it's too risky.

    5.) B. I don't trust hostage takers to hold up their end of the bargain, especially when the bargain is so pointless and sadistic. I'd take the risk.

    6.) B. I wouldn't be able to forgive myself if I allow a kid to die.

    7.) A. I like to think that I'd use my head and good judgement in this situation.

    8.) D. Fuck symbolism, all three are pretty awful in my book.

    9.) A

    10.) About 50/50, though I saved Pete the first time.
Sign in to comment in this discussion.