Biggest plot hole in the series?
what the fuck did the cabin survivors did to Carver? on episode 1 and 2 anyone wanted to tell anything they acted like it was a huge secret somthing awful i got even more intersted when Carver mentioned how Alvin killed George ,even at the start of episode 3 Carver talks like if what they did affected the whole community but nothing was spoken about that i really expected a great plot twist .
The only way i see it could go now is if they tell what they did on episode 4 and it will make Clem loss trust on the group , but what would be the point if Carver and half of the cabin survivours are already dead?
The only way i see it could go now is if they tell what they did on episode 4 and it will make Clem loss trust on the group , but what would be the point if Carver and half of the cabin survivours are already dead?
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
In the first episode, Clem's cut is WAY too big for it to be a walker bite, and even Carlos, who claims to be a doctor, can't tell.
Also, Carlos' logic to find out if it's a walker bite or not, is to wait and see if she develops a fever. No matter if it's a walker bite or not, she still would have gotten sick, because the cut wasn't cleaned.
I guess they thought Clem would hate and mistrust them if they said "Our leader was a violent sociopath who pushes people off buildings for fun, so we left."
"Do you remember George, Alvin? You see, I do. I remember a guy that was your friend named George."
"I remember when you murdered him in cold blood."
"And why? Because you didn't like me?
"You could have lodged a complaint. You could have--"
"You could have been civil"
Also since Alvin died on my file in ep 2 I hardly heard anything about the baby in episode 3 now Im really confused about Carver's notion to go all those miles chasing down the cabin group for his unborn child. If you care so much that its your baby then why keep the pregnant mom outside in the cold?
Then after he pushes Reggie off the building he goes all Crawford elitist on Clem and Sarah which contradicts keeping little girls and babies in camp.
"oh, there's a guy after you? why? what does he want? is he trying to kill you? what's his name?" "he's a very bad man." "yes, that's great and all, but that doesn't actually answer my questions." finally get a chance to ask sarah who is after you, and she... wait for it... CAN'T REMEMBER! carver tells you more about them than they were willing to say, and yet still doesn't answer your questions. this is understandable as he could tell you were evading his questions the same as he was yours, then walks off like he knows the big secret. they STILL say nothing about him or what's goin on, just that now carver's seen her and she must come with him, because they're safer.
5 days later, they've still told you absolutely nothing about what's goin on, and clem seems to have accepted it. kenny's group is completely uninterested in hearing about it, which is another big flag. "this person is chasin us. i think he may want to kill them." "that's nice clem, go help walt with dinner." soon as you finally get the chance to ask rebecca about the baby, in comes alvin and she clams up again. kenny points out how rebecca calls carver "bill", and it feels like he may be on to sumthin, but then it's back to getting out. the trip took almost an entire day, and kenny didn't think to try lookin for a way out till they're on the final stretch and nearly there? that doesn't sound right at all.
and then once you finally get there, all that gets said about what's happened is "it's all in the past. some of you may not like what happened, but u'll just have to learn to deal with it." and that's pretty much it.
it's almost like they have no idea what they've decided actually happened, and as long as they dont give people a chance to look too deeply at it, this unknown event can continue to morph and be the driving force and the convenient go to answer for why sumthing is happening or has to be done.
maybe the original story had taboo things in it like rape (whose baby is it?), or worse, so it goes along and then management says, "we will get too much flak for this stuff, so either we have to tone it down, or get rid of it." of course the writers realize that this is a zombie apocalypse, and really bad stuff needs to happen in order to make people into real villains, so they decide to go the nebulous route and have people fill in the blanks with their own mind, so that they don't have to say what bad stuff happened, and people will come up with whatever would be bad enough for such to happen without crossing any lines they might have.
so they took the original script and hacked into it to come up with a script that doesn't have any serious evil in it, but still keeps us guessing so that our imaginations are used to fill in the the evil holes in the story. at least that is my guess, after all it seems like sarah is pretty disconnected from everything, and she did live with mr. everyone must pull their own weight. sounds like their was a lot of sacrifice to keep the father happy and comfortable, and then to have him just run off seems like their must have been something pretty bad going on (i would bet it was due to a perceived threat to his daughter).
most rape victims feel shame and a sense of responsibility over what happened, so her feelings aren't out of line with rape in the slightest.
double post.
Untold information is not a plothole.
This isn't a plot hole. There are rarely any substantial plot holes in the entire game (8 episodes.) Just because Telltale neglected to say every single detail regarding every single detail does not make it a pot hole
he was all about a legacy and such, so children are fully in line with his philosophy. and as for leaving his baby mamma in the cold, he is all about toughening up the future children. if we carry this logic on through, little girls can be toughened up, to make tougher children for the future when they come of age, at the very least they can become replacements for those that are killed, once properly conditioned of course. he didn't see clem as competition for his unborn child inspite of his respect for her strength, which speaks of what place women have in his mind and possibly his future society (maybe he was even planning on his son and her making grandkids).
There hasnt been too many in season 2 just like season 1 (most of these are not plotholes, just not expanding on information and leaving some stuff up to peoples opinions: I.E not spoonfeeding)
A plot hole example from season 1 was how lee got back inside the school in crawford the second time, he hops over the fence then say "time to go". How did he get back inside without going through the garage?
I am replaying season 1 again and I'm now at lee's parents convenience store.
What I was thinking was, how they manage to use the back office emergency exit to go syphon some gas and what not but not use it to gain the keys for the pharmacy?
I mean, do they really have to break the combination lock to reach lee's brother? could they not have distracted the walkers with the tv's and snuck out of the back alley? why put yourself at a vulnerable spot by breaking the lock to the the front door?
just my 2 cents