›

The most difficult decisions

GamerGraybayGamerGraybay
edited May 2014 in The Walking Dead
In your opinion, what were some of the most difficult decisions we've ever had to make in the games? (In both S1 and S2.)

Comments

  • BenUsefulBenUseful
    Do I leave at night or day?
  • MayorMilkMayorMilk
    At least we had infinite time to make that choice...
    BenUseful posted: » [view original content]
  • PuhChewyChompPuhChewyChomp
    Meat locker.
  • NoncyFlippledorpNoncyFlippledorp
    Season 2: Episode 2. Which seat do I taaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaake?
  • BoatsNHoesBoatsNHoes
    The night choice was more exciting in my opinion, and it made sense later since at Heschels farm it was pitch dark, but the day choice was the logical one.
    BenUseful posted: » [view original content]
  • PowerfulStachePowerfulStache
    edited May 2014
    The meat locker, because of how much it affected the game. Not only does your choice in there seriously define what kind of person you are 3 months in, it also gives a blatant distinction between whether or not Kenny is an asshole to you the rest of the game, and whether or not Lilly is kind to you.
  • TWD95TWD95
    to kill or try to save larry, save or drop ben and at the motor in choosing who to give food
  • TDMshadowCPTDMshadowCP Banned
    My cousin was having difficulties too.

    www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q99YxDVUNH0
    NoncyFlippledorp posted: »

    Season 2: Episode 2. Which seat do I taaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaake?

  • TDMshadowCPTDMshadowCP Banned
    Let Ben fall to his death

    Or

    Pull him up
  • Its_That_GuyIts_That_Guy
    In Season 1 Episode 2 when you have to try and stop clementine from eating the meat I completely failed lmfaoo it happened so fast.
  • ComingSoonComingSoon Banned
    word
    PowerfulStache posted: » [view original content]
  • roxannaroxanna
    Me too , because i like Kenny but i also love Luke so..... it was hard.
    NoncyFlippledorp posted: »

    Season 2: Episode 2. Which seat do I taaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaake?

  • Dont_Look_BackDont_Look_Back
    Choosing the table to sit at.
  • RigtailRigtail
    Choosing who to sit with in A House Divided.
  • BenUsefulBenUseful
    Do I go gay for this magnificent man or do I stay straight:
    cloud-3.steampowered.com/ugc/3281182770222492628/6055FCC0A8B73FE63EEAEDE8387E507D93CA1D68/
    (I did some changed to him before you ask)
  • MultiRienziMultiRienzi
    Telling Walter what Nick did
  • Dont_Look_BackDont_Look_Back
    something's different... it the facial hair?
    BenUseful posted: »

    Do I go gay for this magnificent man or do I stay straight: cloud-3.steampowered.com/ugc/3281182770222492628/6055FCC0A8B73FE63EEAEDE8387E507D93CA1D68/ (I did some changed to him before you ask)

  • BenUsefulBenUseful
    Yes, I made it better.
    Dont_Look_Back posted: »

    something's different... it the facial hair?

  • lapiswolflapiswolf
    Whether Clementine gets a vote in whether Ben stays. I said "no" quickly at the time because I was just desperate for Ben to GTFO of the group but it's one of the things I feel most guilty about. With mine and Kenny's votes it still would've been 2/3 anyway, so I could've still killed him and not felt bad... besides Clementine's reaction.

    Who to sit with in A House Divided. Made me shout at my screen.

    Who to place the blame on in the greenhouse. I blamed Reggie and felt like crap about it. Whether to take the blame for the walkie talkie. Spent so long in indecision I just let the timer run out. And finally, watching Carver's death. Easy choice to make at the time but made me feel bad for making Clem watch afterwards.
  • MathildaMathilda
    Meat locker !
  • ByglerBygler
    Leave Clem at the house or bring her to Crawford
  • SergeantSnookieSergeantSnookie
    Spike remover? Monkey wrench? Spanner?
  • MathildaMathilda
    lol finally I will choose this one too ;)
    Unknown posted: » [view original content]
  • lapiswolflapiswolf
    Was very grateful for the long timer on this one.
    Bygler posted: »

    Leave Clem at the house or bring her to Crawford

  • ByglerBygler
    I picked moment wrench because it was the only blunt wep you get in the game
    SergeantSnookie posted: »

    Spike remover? Monkey wrench? Spanner?

  • ClemRoxClemRox
    Whether to make Clem watch Carver's death or not.
  • Rock114Rock114
    The meat locker, for Season 1.

    For Season 2, the toughest choice so far was saving either Nick or Pete in Episode 1. Now THAT was difficult for me. I let the timer run almost all the way out before I ended up going with Pete.
  • Conduit42Conduit42
    Season 1: Whether or not I help Kenny kill Larry or not.

    Season 2: Choosing to cut Sarita's arm off or not.
  • BluebirdoBluebirdo
    I found Lee's nighttime lines more humorous (in an awkward sort of way), but daytime was the more logical and safer one.
    BenUseful posted: » [view original content]
  • BluebirdoBluebirdo
    Game: "You have 4 food items for 10 hungry people."
    Me: "You have 3 food items for 9 hungry people. Clem gets the apple." XD
    TWD95 posted: »

    to kill or try to save larry, save or drop ben and at the motor in choosing who to give food

  • BluebirdoBluebirdo
    edited May 2014
    Nice to see a fellow Pete-saver. Nick can whack the zombies away and run fine; he is on the correct side of the river after all. Maybe I can go with Pete and help him amputate in time. That was my reasoning anyway, first playthrough.
    Rock114 posted: »

    The meat locker, for Season 1. For Season 2, the toughest choice so far was saving either Nick or Pete in Episode 1. Now THAT was difficult for me. I let the timer run almost all the way out before I ended up going with Pete.

  • TWD95TWD95
    I never eat anything as Lee I take it everyone got pissed Larry in particular ?
    Bluebirdo posted: »

    Game: "You have 4 food items for 10 hungry people." Me: "You have 3 food items for 9 hungry people. Clem gets the apple." XD

  • CarverHater123CarverHater123
    Season 1: Letting Clementine come with me to crawford or stay at the house.
    Season 2: Back Nick up or not after he shot Matthew.
  • Lee_Clementine_4lifeLee_Clementine_4life
    when kenny said : wanna hear the good news or the bad news in EP4 S1
    daaaamn so so hard
  • kawaiiclemkawaiiclem
    Season 1: Choosing to either let Clem leave Lee or shoot him.
    I got her to shoot him, because I didn't want Clem have her parents AND Lee both walkers.

    Season 2: Chopping of Sarita's arm or killing the walker.
    I chopped of her arm, I don't know why but in the spur of the moment I thought it was a good idea. She's probably going to die either way.
Sign in to comment in this discussion.