Well, I don't think Luke did considering he immediately dropped her when he thought she was bitten by a walker, and you have the option to say "Look at it!" and Luke says something about her sinking her teeth into Pete's neck. Either they made Luke act really stupid there, or he just doesn't understand the terms of a walker bite.
They had GUNS. If it came down to that, they could've killed Clem easily, she's just a little girl after all, not very strong. Nothing like … morezombie Larry, for example. Now, Carlos's plan was to wait and see if she was alive the next day, but when she proved she wasn't bitten by a walker the very same day, after being asked by Luke if it wasn't a lurker's bite Carlos replies"If it was, the fever would've already set in and her temperature would be trough the roof" which tells you make her wait in such conditions was completely unnecesary and I think the whole group was well aware of that, including Luke.
Luke getting caught didn't have anything to do with the plan. He even states "I was hungry, and I got reckless trying to steal some food, and I got caught." He was just hungry, tired and thirsty. Everyone would have done the same thing for food. So tell me, where did Luke state that his plan was to steal food in order to save the group? No where? Then don't bring up bullshit points.
" don't think anyone would've died in Luke's plan" Such a good plan with a sneaky leader!, that's why Carver captured him!. Ahaha, if it wasn't for Kenny's quick action I bet Carver would've killed Luke in front of everyone.
I would save Sarah, seeing as Kenny can defend himself. (as he did in the alleyway in Season 1) Sarah is only a little girl who watched her father get shot in the neck and get eaten alive.
Forgot the part where I said "Sneaky leader"? When you consider a plan, you also have to take into account the person who's behind it and the one doing the execution of it. Luke isn't fit to lead. He's not THAT tough! I can tell you right now, any person with basic survival skills would've not done what Luke did, get reckless and try to steal some food when the situation is so dire and complicated. Luke should've known better but then again, it seems things have been pretty easy on him resource wise, and he's not used to pass day or two without a bite. Anyways, his plan was bound to fail! what? wait for an opening? with Carver still around and tons of armed people guarding every corner? and then what? how would they get out of here? there wasn't any strategy behind! pppf don't make me laugh,it was a terrible plan.
Luke getting caught didn't have anything to do with the plan. He even states "I was hungry, and I got reckless trying to steal some food, an… mored I got caught." He was just hungry, tired and thirsty. Everyone would have done the same thing for food. So tell me, where did Luke state that his plan was to steal food in order to save the group? No where? Then don't bring up bullshit points.
I like Kenny a lot and I understand why many people hate Luke because of what he did in episode 3 but, don't be like that. He starved and didn't slept to save Clementine and the others and he made a mistake.He didn't abandon them. Kenny made mistakes too, so....
I'm going with Luke.
I like Kenny a lot and I understand why many people hate Luke because of what he did in episode 3 but, don't be like that. He starved and di… moredn't slept to save Clementine and the others and he made a mistake.He didn't abandon them. Kenny made mistakes too, so....
I'm going with Luke.
I think a lot of people are giving Luke more shit than he actually deserves. He did say that it wasn't right to kill Carver, despite what he's done, which shows that he is a good person. I think he's just hellbent on surviving the apocalypse.
I agree with that. Everything is her father's fault. He was too protective, and now she's not even capable of doing simple chores, let alone fight walkers. She always had her father, or someone else looking after her.
I was so irritated when she started talking while Bill was giving instructions and all that. Try to read the situation, girl!!
Kenny, without a doubt.
I have nothing against Sarah - but the girl is more of a liability and is absolutely incapable of taking care o… moref herself. I'd rather have someone who's got my back in a battle; not someone who increases my chances of getting killed in said battle.
I love both Kenny and Luke. But honestly, Kenny's plan was terrible. Walk through a crowd of 2-3 thousand zombies, without any protection what so ever isn't smart. Luke's plan was decent. Wait maybe a few nights then escape. But, I think the whole "walk through thousands of zombies wearing their blood" plan was okay, other then Sarita getting bitten and Carlos dying. But, what's done is done and all we can do is move forward.
Forgot the part where I said "Sneaky leader"? When you consider a plan, you also have to take into account the person who's behind it and th… moree one doing the execution of it. Luke isn't fit to lead. He's not THAT tough! I can tell you right now, any person with basic survival skills would've not done what Luke did, get reckless and try to steal some food when the situation is so dire and complicated. Luke should've known better but then again, it seems things have been pretty easy on him resource wise, and he's not used to pass day or two without a bite. Anyways, his plan was bound to fail! what? wait for an opening? with Carver still around and tons of armed people guarding every corner? and then what? how would they get out of here? there wasn't any strategy behind! pppf don't make me laugh,it was a terrible plan.
If you think about what happened in season 1, Kenny would know a thing or two about running from a horde of zombies and living to tell about it. Anyways, I already explained why I believe Luke's plan was bound to fail, so I won't repeat myself. Regarding the "walk through thousands of zombies wearing their blood" accident, it was Sarah's fault for calling the zombies's attention. I understand though, Sarah's condition is not the best, but she did it regardless. Her screamings is what made the zombies attack everyone, Sarita did her best to protect them and so did Bonnie. I believe if it wasn't for Sarah, they could've been succesful in their scape.
I love both Kenny and Luke. But honestly, Kenny's plan was terrible. Walk through a crowd of 2-3 thousand zombies, without any protection wh… moreat so ever isn't smart. Luke's plan was decent. Wait maybe a few nights then escape. But, I think the whole "walk through thousands of zombies wearing their blood" plan was okay, other then Sarita getting bitten and Carlos dying. But, what's done is done and all we can do is move forward.
They should've told us what happened to her child. It's obvious that she/he is dead, but it's still nice to know whenether it died at birth or a walker had her/him.
Honestly in s1 I didn't always agree with Kenny so throughout my play through he left me hanging a couple times and I really disliked him because of it. That's said when he went off to save Ben and he was assumed to be dead i was sad to have lost him and Ben, sort of felt some regret and guilt I suppose.
We jump to season 2 and we see Kenny again, tearing up slightly I went on to ask him if this was real...
Being with Kenny is an amazing thing to have when there is no shred of ZA family left, whether we agreed or not he was there from day one.
As for Luke I personally don't see what all the fuss is about, I feel disconnected with him and don't feel like I care enough to save him unfortunately.
I would choose Luke, he had a perfect choise to: leave Clem when dog bit her, not to invite her to his group, not side with her when carver visited them, run away and forget about his group when carver caught them.
Also he doesnt get his temper up when clem is mean to the group, he has also a good heart that he didnt want to shoot carver even thoug he hates him, and he would rather die then kill a dog. And at the end he acts like a big brother to Clem. Kenny screams at her all the time when she doesnt side with him.
Wait, what?! Carver's group shot Carlos, and he screamed out as he died, then Sarah screamed, which is a perfectly rational reaction TO SEEING YOUR FUCKING SINGLE FATHER BEING EATEN ALIVE! Plus the fact that she seems to have some sort of anxiety problem and you can easily see that it's not her fault that she reacted that way! People blaming Sarah are morons because she doesn't know what else to do! She couldn't think straight because she was so shocked and couldn't believe what was happening! Carlos screamed and died, Sarah screamed, the walkers came towards her and Clementine and THEN the others in the group started shooting, which drew the walkers towards them.
If you think about what happened in season 1, Kenny would know a thing or two about running from a horde of zombies and living to tell about… more it. Anyways, I already explained why I believe Luke's plan was bound to fail, so I won't repeat myself. Regarding the "walk through thousands of zombies wearing their blood" accident, it was Sarah's fault for calling the zombies's attention. I understand though, Sarah's condition is not the best, but she did it regardless. Her screamings is what made the zombies attack everyone, Sarita did her best to protect them and so did Bonnie. I believe if it wasn't for Sarah, they could've been succesful in their scape.
Maybe too good of a heart? Too feeble minded to kill a dog or the dude that's been killing off your friends... Kenny might yell but he isn't afraid to get the job done. To each their own but Luke would get you killed, and without putting up a fight may I add.
I would choose Luke, he had a perfect choise to: leave Clem when dog bit her, not to invite her to his group, not side with her when carver … morevisited them, run away and forget about his group when carver caught them.
Also he doesnt get his temper up when clem is mean to the group, he has also a good heart that he didnt want to shoot carver even thoug he hates him, and he would rather die then kill a dog. And at the end he acts like a big brother to Clem. Kenny screams at her all the time when she doesnt side with him.
Dont think that i hate kenny, i just think he is an ok guy, but if it comes to that im picking Luke, but the best thing would be that this choice of saving Luke or Kenny never happens
Maybe too good of a heart? Too feeble minded to kill a dog or the dude that's been killing off your friends... Kenny might yell but he isn't… more afraid to get the job done. To each their own but Luke would get you killed, and without putting up a fight may I add.
Dont think that i hate kenny, i just think he is an ok guy, but if it comes to that im picking Luke, but the best thing would be that this choice of saving Luke or Kenny never happens
That's exactly why I understand Sarah, but that doesn't mean that what happened didn't happen. I hate comparing characters, I really do, but I think this time is neccesary. Let's take a look at Clementine when she was 9, end of episode 5. She saw her dead parents, the ones she was looking for for months and she was shocked, but didn't scream or ran to them, no, she kept her cool and then dragged Lee to a secure place even though she was broken. Sarah, in the other hand, while having problems I don't understand because they've been implied so far ("will cease to function", getting upset at the cabin, "I can't breath!", not working with the berries, etc) but no confirmed. Anyways, she clearly has some sort of impediment, but that's exactly what makes her a nuisance in such a situation. I'm sorry for saying it like that, and I love Sarah to bits,I help her as much as I can and I think she's adorable, but from a realistic point of view considering the situation, that's what she is right now.
Pay attention, Sarah was stiff, gripping her first anxiously and breathing quickly. If you want to scape you must act like one of them, but Sarah did not which called a female zombie attention that kept looking at her. Upon realizing that, Carlos asked for your help while Sarah whimpered in the background and that's when it went downhill. If you think strategically, extremely hard and crude, though. Sarah is not capable of this and it's obvious, it's her dad after all. I wouldn't be able to do it either but...Carlos getting eaten was the perfect chance they had to create a distraction and scape, but her screams of anguish is what made all hell break loose, then the attacks began and the shooting too. I repeat, I'm not blaming Sarah 100%, it was something she couldn't control but she did it regardless and it was because of her that this happened :/ it's a FACT as muh as you and I might hate it.
*sorry for my english urhr
Wait, what?! Carver's group shot Carlos, and he screamed out as he died, then Sarah screamed, which is a perfectly rational reaction TO SEEI… moreNG YOUR FUCKING SINGLE FATHER BEING EATEN ALIVE! Plus the fact that she seems to have some sort of anxiety problem and you can easily see that it's not her fault that she reacted that way! People blaming Sarah are morons because she doesn't know what else to do! She couldn't think straight because she was so shocked and couldn't believe what was happening! Carlos screamed and died, Sarah screamed, the walkers came towards her and Clementine and THEN the others in the group started shooting, which drew the walkers towards them.
Comments
Like I said before, grow up.
Lukenny.
That's right. I will freaking glue those two together if that's what it takes to never have to make that choice.
I'm going with Luke.
I was so irritated when she started talking while Bill was giving instructions and all that. Try to read the situation, girl!!
Luke wasn't in S1, as my bro The Walking Mustache says.
We jump to season 2 and we see Kenny again, tearing up slightly I went on to ask him if this was real...
Being with Kenny is an amazing thing to have when there is no shred of ZA family left, whether we agreed or not he was there from day one.
As for Luke I personally don't see what all the fuss is about, I feel disconnected with him and don't feel like I care enough to save him unfortunately.
So um Kenny, my answer is Kenny.
Also he doesnt get his temper up when clem is mean to the group, he has also a good heart that he didnt want to shoot carver even thoug he hates him, and he would rather die then kill a dog. And at the end he acts like a big brother to Clem. Kenny screams at her all the time when she doesnt side with him.
Pay attention, Sarah was stiff, gripping her first anxiously and breathing quickly. If you want to scape you must act like one of them, but Sarah did not which called a female zombie attention that kept looking at her. Upon realizing that, Carlos asked for your help while Sarah whimpered in the background and that's when it went downhill. If you think strategically, extremely hard and crude, though. Sarah is not capable of this and it's obvious, it's her dad after all. I wouldn't be able to do it either but...Carlos getting eaten was the perfect chance they had to create a distraction and scape, but her screams of anguish is what made all hell break loose, then the attacks began and the shooting too. I repeat, I'm not blaming Sarah 100%, it was something she couldn't control but she did it regardless and it was because of her that this happened :/ it's a FACT as muh as you and I might hate it.
*sorry for my english urhr