If Kenny doesn't take the blame.. Carver gives Clem the Stone Cold Stunner and then Troy finishes her off with the Hulk Hogan legdrop. So its a good thing that Kenny took the blame.
I think that Carver would of slapped Clementine knocking her to the ground and then he would of held the others at gun point and called Troy… more over to teach Clem a lesson, Troy would then rape her and Carver would make the others watch and he'd laugh evilly.
Carver definitely wouldn't have beat her up with the walky talky. Actually, he would've done one of two things actually.
He would've either slapped the hell out of her and screamed at her, as most of you already said.
Or, something that might've actually done, is beat the living hell out of someone he thought/guessed was close to clementine, as a way of indirectly punishing her in way that Clem would've considered worse than getting beat up herself. Maybe Kenny would've gotten beaten up anyway, or he would've chosen to take Luke's eye out instead. As a message of "Leave these treacherous dogshit group of crippled fucks and join my damn side"
I imagine Carver would've hurt Clem like he hurt Kenny. But I imagine less walkie talkies to the face and more kicks to the gut (this was the worst case scenario I could think of when I heard about the "got beat up" achievement).
Anyone who thinks Carver would've let that slide is naive IMHO. Carver tells Clem at the start of the episode 'if you take this one (talking about the walkie talkie) i'll hurt you myself!' Then What do you think he is gonna do to a grown ass man like Kenny? Kenny said 'fucker' cuz he knew he was in for a beatdown.
No, because Carver still said "Three" even though he should have stopped counting, so Kenny said "heh, fucker" because he knew Carver wasn't going to let that slide.
PLOT TWIST!
carver: *takes walkie talkie from her.
carver: *grabs luke and Kenny and puts them next to each other*
carver: *… moretakes out gun"
carver: in 5 seconds im going to kill one of there men. you tell me which on to shot and i kill that person, if you don't tell me who to shot in 5 seconds, I kill them both.
carver: 1... 2..
clem (gets choice to tell him to kill Kenny or luke)
"lets say clem says "shot luke"
carver: *looks at luke *looks at Kenny*
carver: walks over to Kenny and kills Kenny.
he did the opposite of what you said, now luke lives wit the fact that she picked for him to die instead of Kenny.
And if you choose the opposite, he does the same thing. he does what you didn't pick.
He definitely didn't care about gender or age. He respected Clem, because she has a strong personality, just like him (she looks into the ey… moree). That doesn't mean that Carver wouldn't have beaten her to death, if he found out that she stole the radios. Clementine would have in fact, probaply died from the beating Kenny got, or atleast have fatal injuries.
As strange as it sounds, I think Carver respected Clem too much to give her the same beating Kenny got. I think he might slap her but we know he believes in an eye for an eye so he'd most likely "steal" something from Clem (Kenny or Luke's life most likely)
Carver would have probably lost his temper and starting chopping fingers off until someone came clean. My Clementine was about to confess, though I did consider having her step back in the shadows. I didn't replay the scene so what would have happened is Clementine would have confessed had Kenny kept quiet and Carver would have probably punished her with no supper and other petty punishments.
I just really liked the 104 group decision thing where you finally see what page you're on with everyone!!
I actually thought Carlos was meant to be in your comment but you're welcome XD
Just me thinking here, I wish it was if Clem got slapped then Luke/Kenny, depending on who you sat with or something, stood up for you. Then Carver beats them up instead. This would have given her relationships with these guys more development.
Of course we didn't see him beat a child that bad, just because Kenny sacrificed himself for Clem. Carver did slap Clem in this episode (if you choose the right answers) and he did order Carlos, to beat up his own daughter! What makes you possible believe,that he isn't capable of beating a girl blind?
Slaps, not beatings. His most vicious behavior, throwing a man off the roomfbeating a man half to death, have been to adults. What would he gain by beating a small child blind? We only saw him slap Clementine for being mouthy and he made Carlos hit his own child. It was Carlos to that chose to hit Sarah that hard. Everyone has their lines they wont cross unless they are uncontrollable psychopaths of the highest order and from what we have seen of Carver, he seems to be vicious and cruel but controlled. If anyone was capable of that, I would say Troy considering how much he was slapping Clementine around.
Of course we didn't see him beat a child that bad, just because Kenny sacrificed himself for Clem. Carver did slap Clem in this episode (if … moreyou choose the right answers) and he did order Carlos, to beat up his own daughter! What makes you possible believe,that he isn't capable of beating a girl blind?
I think that Carver would of slapped Clementine knocking her to the ground and then he would of held the others at gun point and called Troy… more over to teach Clem a lesson, Troy would then rape her and Carver would make the others watch and he'd laugh evilly.
First of all, I think if Carver were to beat Clementine up like he did to Kenny, he probably wouldn't use the walkie talkie, just his fists. (He respects her in an odd way, though we've seen he isn't afraid to hit her either. But I think he wouldn't want her dead, like he clearly intended to kill Kenny.)
If Carver tried to give Clem a similar beating to what he did to Kenny, even if Kenny / Luke / etc were being held back, eventually either Kenny or Luke would break free and stop him before he could severely wound / kill her. (Because she would die before Bonnie showed up, as being younger and smaller I doubt her body could hold out through such a beating for as long as Kenny did.)
Probably Kenny would, and he would end up getting beat to shit anyway.
Clem might be pretty badly hurt though. I think it would be interesting if she had been the one to lose an eye instead, though I doubt it would have happened if she had been the one punished. I kind of want to draw it now, though.
I think he would've shot someone, you all know what happened in episode. I think if no one owned up he would've started popping people; starting with any characters that were determined such as Nick. And then he might have gone on to shot someone else; so all In all I'm gad someone showed up, because Carver would've started shooting people.
He would've hit Clementine, but he would be smart enough to know that Clementine was put up to it (getting the walkie talkies). I think he would have guessed who the ringleader was and would have beaten that person more or shot them. I don't think he would assume she was the mastermind behind getting the walkie talkies.
The only difference between child and adult is age and size, both are still human. Carver probably thought that way, he probably thought that both are equal and age doesn't get in the way. He's probably someone who doesn't understand why Children get special treatment just because they are younger in age.
Slaps, not beatings. His most vicious behavior, throwing a man off the roomfbeating a man half to death, have been to adults. What would he … moregain by beating a small child blind? We only saw him slap Clementine for being mouthy and he made Carlos hit his own child. It was Carlos to that chose to hit Sarah that hard. Everyone has their lines they wont cross unless they are uncontrollable psychopaths of the highest order and from what we have seen of Carver, he seems to be vicious and cruel but controlled. If anyone was capable of that, I would say Troy considering how much he was slapping Clementine around.
If he doesnt understand that, he'd have to be crazy. You cant expect the same things of a child that you can of a full grown adult. He didnt hit Sarah when she was talking during his speech. He understood that it was her parent's job to "correct" her. Thats what I mean. He's not just some crazy man who takes out his rage on anyone on the way. He's a crazy man who thought about his actions and did what he thought was appropriate. But that is my interpretation so we can agree to disagree.
The only difference between child and adult is age and size, both are still human. Carver probably thought that way, he probably thought tha… moret both are equal and age doesn't get in the way. He's probably someone who doesn't understand why Children get special treatment just because they are younger in age.
If he doesnt understand that, he'd have to be crazy. You cant expect the same things of a child that you can of a full grown adult. He didnt… more hit Sarah when she was talking during his speech. He understood that it was her parent's job to "correct" her. Thats what I mean. He's not just some crazy man who takes out his rage on anyone on the way. He's a crazy man who thought about his actions and did what he thought was appropriate. But that is my interpretation so we can agree to disagree.
Comments
He would've either slapped the hell out of her and screamed at her, as most of you already said.
Or, something that might've actually done, is beat the living hell out of someone he thought/guessed was close to clementine, as a way of indirectly punishing her in way that Clem would've considered worse than getting beat up herself. Maybe Kenny would've gotten beaten up anyway, or he would've chosen to take Luke's eye out instead. As a message of "Leave these treacherous dogshit group of crippled fucks and join my damn side"
Clem: "Okay, sir :("
Carver: Good girl ^-^ *pats Clem's head* .....that was awkward. I won't do that again. I'm gonna go to work now."
Luke: "Yeah, well...ugh...since when have you...ever like anyone, Carlos."
*Whack!*
Remember when Andy was holding Duck hostage and Kenny just charged wildly towards him, getting shot in the process?
Something like that would probably happen.
Slaps, not beatings. His most vicious behavior, throwing a man off the roomfbeating a man half to death, have been to adults. What would he gain by beating a small child blind? We only saw him slap Clementine for being mouthy and he made Carlos hit his own child. It was Carlos to that chose to hit Sarah that hard. Everyone has their lines they wont cross unless they are uncontrollable psychopaths of the highest order and from what we have seen of Carver, he seems to be vicious and cruel but controlled. If anyone was capable of that, I would say Troy considering how much he was slapping Clementine around.
I'm pretty sure Bonnie would have gotten miffed enough to gun all of Carver's mooks down right there if that happened.
First of all, I think if Carver were to beat Clementine up like he did to Kenny, he probably wouldn't use the walkie talkie, just his fists. (He respects her in an odd way, though we've seen he isn't afraid to hit her either. But I think he wouldn't want her dead, like he clearly intended to kill Kenny.)
If Carver tried to give Clem a similar beating to what he did to Kenny, even if Kenny / Luke / etc were being held back, eventually either Kenny or Luke would break free and stop him before he could severely wound / kill her. (Because she would die before Bonnie showed up, as being younger and smaller I doubt her body could hold out through such a beating for as long as Kenny did.)
Probably Kenny would, and he would end up getting beat to shit anyway.
Clem might be pretty badly hurt though. I think it would be interesting if she had been the one to lose an eye instead, though I doubt it would have happened if she had been the one punished. I kind of want to draw it now, though.
lol yeah. Luke would've been left behind though. Kenny's just made of tougher stuff.
"There's no tellin' what that asswipe would've done" Kenny to Clementine (Amid The Ruins preview.)
I think he would've shot someone, you all know what happened in episode. I think if no one owned up he would've started popping people; starting with any characters that were determined such as Nick. And then he might have gone on to shot someone else; so all In all I'm gad someone showed up, because Carver would've started shooting people.
He would've hit Clementine, but he would be smart enough to know that Clementine was put up to it (getting the walkie talkies). I think he would have guessed who the ringleader was and would have beaten that person more or shot them. I don't think he would assume she was the mastermind behind getting the walkie talkies.
Oh hell yeah he would have. Kenny's one tough bastard.
He would give her a beating but not as horrible as ken's beating.
I don't think Carver would've beaten her, at least that much
He would give her a million juice boxes for being so honest to him.
The only difference between child and adult is age and size, both are still human. Carver probably thought that way, he probably thought that both are equal and age doesn't get in the way. He's probably someone who doesn't understand why Children get special treatment just because they are younger in age.
If he doesnt understand that, he'd have to be crazy. You cant expect the same things of a child that you can of a full grown adult. He didnt hit Sarah when she was talking during his speech. He understood that it was her parent's job to "correct" her. Thats what I mean. He's not just some crazy man who takes out his rage on anyone on the way. He's a crazy man who thought about his actions and did what he thought was appropriate. But that is my interpretation so we can agree to disagree.
he'll lost all the respect from most his member if he did that
Oh. Okay.