Interesting point. yet i had to support Kenny on both situation and let me do it in order to gain his loyalty. And he makes mention on it in season 2. I tried to keep everyone loyal to me.
Believe it or not, for me the Most difficult decision of the game was choosing who should be the one to shot the boy in the attic.
I did … morealready make Kenny shot his own son, because in my opinion it was the right thing to do. Kenny needs to be strong and be able to leave his past behind. But then, only 1episode later,Telltale brings this heart breaking scene. I decided that Kenny should also be the one that shots the boy in the attic. But please believe me, it wasn't an easy decision for me.
Well...i also supported Kenny on both situations and he also mentioned on it, in Season2. Kenny was always my loyal Bro, hell he even gave me the Bro speech. None of these decisions (Shoting Duck/the boy in the attic, or making Kenny do it) is the wrong decision. Everyone has his/her own view, what's the right one to do.
Interesting point. yet i had to support Kenny on both situation and let me do it in order to gain his loyalty. And he makes mention on it in season 2. I tried to keep everyone loyal to me.
Well...i also supported Kenny on both situations and he also mentioned on it, in Season2. Kenny was always my loyal Bro, hell he even gave m… moree the Bro speech. None of these decisions (Shoting Duck/the boy in the attic, or making Kenny do it) is the wrong decision. Everyone has his/her own view, what's the right one to do.
Helping Kenny kill Larry at the meatlocker, saving Duck at hershels farm and the Pharmacy and killing Ben at the Belltower. This are the most important " Bro " decisions in the game!
Helping Kenny kill Larry at the meatlocker, saving Duck at hershels farm and the Pharmacy and killing Ben at the Belltower. This are the most important " Bro " decisions in the game!
For me it was also whether to save or kill Larry. I think the most stressed and anxious I've ever been on TWDG was during that decision. I ended up helping Kenny, in the heat of the moment it seemed as the right choice. I was so sure he was dead and about to reanimate. But then, looking back now I can't help but wonder if he could have been saved had Kenny not crushed the salt lick on him...
I found the decision on whether to cut Lee's arm off to be quite stressful as there was a huge possibility of that having a bearing on his fate. I chose to kill the boy in the attic, but I found actually carrying about the task more difficult than making the decision. Just looking at the young child in such a state was absolutely heartbreaking.
For me it was also whether to save or kill Larry. I think the most stressed and anxious I've ever been on TWDG was during that decision. I e… morended up helping Kenny, in the heat of the moment it seemed as the right choice. I was so sure he was dead and about to reanimate. But then, looking back now I can't help but wonder if he could have been saved had Kenny not crushed the salt lick on him...
I found the decision on whether to cut Lee's arm off to be quite stressful as there was a huge possibility of that having a bearing on his fate. I chose to kill the boy in the attic, but I found actually carrying about the task more difficult than making the decision. Just looking at the young child in such a state was absolutely heartbreaking.
Cause I can't choose the hardest between the two seasons and DLC...
Season 1: To shoot or not to shoot Beatrice (the girl at the beginni… moreng of Episode 3, "Long Road Ahead")
400 days: Lie or be honest with Leland (Bonnie's story)
Season 2: Which table to sit at (Episode 2, "A House Divided")
I meant more along the lines of if he could actually have been saved, had Kenny not intervened, although we'll never find that out. I've heard that if you do CPR enough times you can hear him gasp right before he gets salt licked, but I'm not sure if that's true.
I meant more along the lines of if he could actually have been saved, had Kenny not intervened, although we'll never find that out. I've hea… morerd that if you do CPR enough times you can hear him gasp right before he gets salt licked, but I'm not sure if that's true.
Well, I score 2 out of 3. Didn't kill Ben. But Kenny still refused to come along to save Clem.
UPDATE: Sorry, Miscalculation. I actually score 1 out of 3.
You need to score 2/3 out of this 3/4 options for Kenny to give you the Bro speech. (I did count saving Duck and defending Duck at the drugs… moretore as 1)
But even if Kenny doesn't give you his mighty Bro speech, he will still help you finding Clementine if you tell him that Clem is your family now.
You need to score 2/3 out of this 3/4 options for Kenny to give you the Bro speech. (I did count saving Duck and defending Duck at the drugs… moretore as 1)
But even if Kenny doesn't give you his mighty Bro speech, he will still help you finding Clementine if you tell him that Clem is your family now.
The Larry situation was probably the most difficult to me. and i agreed with Kenny.
I would not have made that decision if circumstances were different. but the fact is that we were stuck in that room, and there was real danger of having a giant walker there with us in a matter of minutes. I had to leave behind my morals and act for survival. protect Clem was a top priority!
You know some choices have 12% people doing it? Well, I feel like that's me sometimes... I didn't cut of Sarita's arm, I was close to Lily before her breakdown...
I feel like a lot of the decisions should have been harder for me but weren't. Apparently I'm a cold-hearted bastard... Maybe I'd say Pete or Nick, but I saw Pete bit and just thought "that sucks - goner."
"cold-hearted bastard". The kind of people i like. :P xD
Seriously though, I didn't really feel decisions were hard as well but i have a principle, I don't doublecross the people i care about. And those are very few. However, I need to gain others' loyalties in order to survive, That's why i choose to help some people that i don't care about like cutting off Sarita's arm to gain Kenny's loyalty, Saving Duck, Didn't kill Larry... Etc. I'm more of a cold and calculated person rather than a cold-hearted person.
As for the percentage, It wasn't always stable. Sometimes i agreed with the majority and sometimes with the minority and sometimes, It's 45 or 55 percent.
You know some choices have 12% people doing it? Well, I feel like that's me sometimes... I didn't cut of Sarita's arm, I was close to Lily b… moreefore her breakdown...
I feel like a lot of the decisions should have been harder for me but weren't. Apparently I'm a cold-hearted bastard... Maybe I'd say Pete or Nick, but I saw Pete bit and just thought "that sucks - goner."
The Larry situation was probably the most difficult to me. and i agreed with Kenny.
I would not have made that decision if circumstance… mores were different. but the fact is that we were stuck in that room, and there was real danger of having a giant walker there with us in a matter of minutes. I had to leave behind my morals and act for survival. protect Clem was a top priority!
in episode 2 of season 2 when carver had alvin at gunpoint and i couldnt decide if kenny should shoot or not, i just locked up and the timer ran out and next thing i know is alvins dead.
I agree with your way of thinking. but for me the moral concepts are essential. they are like a compass, is what keeps you in line with yourself. without it you can easily get lost mentally. or become someone you don't like to be. I'm not saying it has to be your only way of seeing life. and you can go over it in favor of a greater benefit. as I did with Larry. but to me it is very important.
To me It's not throwing yourself away, I'm personally a self-proclaimed Chaotic-neutral. Which means i don't have regard to morality. My reg… moreard is to the people i deem worthy. Clementine has earned a high priority in my S1's walkthrough because she can stand for herself. Every situation that happens to every character is considered throw their actions and the circumstances before taking action. Not throw morality to me.
Verdict: I create my own morality. That's what i wanted to teach Clem.
Answering if Nick was a good guy or not.
Now to most of you, the answer was probably easy. He's a good guy. But I was so caught up in the moment, only thinking about the bad things that he'd done, that I answered differently.
Yes. I am the 16%.
Well i think i am a Chaotic Good person then.
I agree with your way of thinking. but for me the moral concepts are essential. they are li… moreke a compass, is what keeps you in line with yourself. without it you can easily get lost mentally. or become someone you don't like to be. I'm not saying it has to be your only way of seeing life. and you can go over it in favor of a greater benefit. as I did with Larry. but to me it is very important.
Choosing which table to sit at...it was like middle school coming back to haunt me.
Seriously though, the decision of whether or not to mercy kill the screaming girl in episode 3 was a serious moral dilemma. Blind idealism versus (extremely) cold pragmatism.
Choosing which table to sit at...it was like middle school coming back to haunt me.
Seriously though, the decision of whether or not to m… moreercy kill the screaming girl in episode 3 was a serious moral dilemma. Blind idealism versus (extremely) cold pragmatism.
I didn't steal from the stranger's car, and i was surprised that almost everyone did at the time when i was playing the first season. I haven't really had any tough choices in Season 2. With Sarita's arm, i figured what the heck, if there is a chance you may as well cut it off, to me it was a no brainer.
Pete i didn't even know he was bit until he pointed it out in Season 2 ^_^,
You know some choices have 12% people doing it? Well, I feel like that's me sometimes... I didn't cut of Sarita's arm, I was close to Lily b… moreefore her breakdown...
I feel like a lot of the decisions should have been harder for me but weren't. Apparently I'm a cold-hearted bastard... Maybe I'd say Pete or Nick, but I saw Pete bit and just thought "that sucks - goner."
I didn't steal from the stranger's car, and i was surprised that almost everyone did at the time when i was playing the first season. I hav… moreen't really had any tough choices in Season 2. With Sarita's arm, i figured what the heck, if there is a chance you may as well cut it off, to me it was a no brainer.
Pete i didn't even know he was bit until he pointed it out in Season 2 ^_^,
Comments
Interesting point. yet i had to support Kenny on both situation and let me do it in order to gain his loyalty. And he makes mention on it in season 2. I tried to keep everyone loyal to me.
It was a harsh one indeed.
It wasn't that hard for me, like Lee said, "there's no happy ending to this".
Playing the game again or not, still haven't figured it out yet.
Actually, I re-liked him ever since i met him again in S2. No idea why.
Well...i also supported Kenny on both situations and he also mentioned on it, in Season2. Kenny was always my loyal Bro, hell he even gave me the Bro speech. None of these decisions (Shoting Duck/the boy in the attic, or making Kenny do it) is the wrong decision. Everyone has his/her own view, what's the right one to do.
Well, I guess it's the meatlocker that really matters.
Helping Kenny kill Larry at the meatlocker, saving Duck at hershels farm and the Pharmacy and killing Ben at the Belltower. This are the most important " Bro " decisions in the game!
Well, I score 2 out of 3. Didn't kill Ben. But Kenny still refused to come along to save Clem.
UPDATE: Sorry, Miscalculation. I actually score 1 out of 3.
Cause I can't choose the hardest between the two seasons and DLC...
Season 1: To shoot or not to shoot Beatrice (the girl at the beginning of Episode 3, "Long Road Ahead")
400 days: Lie or be honest with Leland (Bonnie's story)
Season 2: Which table to sit at (Episode 2, "A House Divided")
For me it was also whether to save or kill Larry. I think the most stressed and anxious I've ever been on TWDG was during that decision. I ended up helping Kenny, in the heat of the moment it seemed as the right choice. I was so sure he was dead and about to reanimate. But then, looking back now I can't help but wonder if he could have been saved had Kenny not crushed the salt lick on him...
I found the decision on whether to cut Lee's arm off to be quite stressful as there was a huge possibility of that having a bearing on his fate. I chose to kill the boy in the attic, but I found actually carrying about the task more difficult than making the decision. Just looking at the young child in such a state was absolutely heartbreaking.
THAT's the question indeed! xD
He gets saltlicked regardless of who do you support.
And what did you choose?
I meant more along the lines of if he could actually have been saved, had Kenny not intervened, although we'll never find that out. I've heard that if you do CPR enough times you can hear him gasp right before he gets salt licked, but I'm not sure if that's true.
I heard that too. But i can't hide it that I'm glad he's dead. xD
For me, I sided with neither of them. Done absolutely nothing.
Didn't shoot, be honest, sat with Kenny.
You need to score 2/3 out of this 3/4 options for Kenny to give you the Bro speech. (I did count saving Duck and defending Duck at the drugstore as 1)
But even if Kenny doesn't give you his mighty Bro speech, he will still help you finding Clementine if you tell him that Clem is your family now.
.
I did save duck and defended him. No bro speech, Didn't go with me to find Clem. I can't recall what i said to Kenny on that occasion.
The Larry situation was probably the most difficult to me. and i agreed with Kenny.
I would not have made that decision if circumstances were different. but the fact is that we were stuck in that room, and there was real danger of having a giant walker there with us in a matter of minutes. I had to leave behind my morals and act for survival. protect Clem was a top priority!
You know some choices have 12% people doing it? Well, I feel like that's me sometimes... I didn't cut of Sarita's arm, I was close to Lily before her breakdown...
I feel like a lot of the decisions should have been harder for me but weren't. Apparently I'm a cold-hearted bastard... Maybe I'd say Pete or Nick, but I saw Pete bit and just thought "that sucks - goner."
"cold-hearted bastard". The kind of people i like. :P xD
Seriously though, I didn't really feel decisions were hard as well but i have a principle, I don't doublecross the people i care about. And those are very few. However, I need to gain others' loyalties in order to survive, That's why i choose to help some people that i don't care about like cutting off Sarita's arm to gain Kenny's loyalty, Saving Duck, Didn't kill Larry... Etc. I'm more of a cold and calculated person rather than a cold-hearted person.
As for the percentage, It wasn't always stable. Sometimes i agreed with the majority and sometimes with the minority and sometimes, It's 45 or 55 percent.
We may agree on killing Larry but our motives are different. I explained almost everything regarding this situation earlier on this thread.
me too
in episode 2 of season 2 when carver had alvin at gunpoint and i couldnt decide if kenny should shoot or not, i just locked up and the timer ran out and next thing i know is alvins dead.
don't forget mayebelle.
Well i think i am a Chaotic Good person then.
I agree with your way of thinking. but for me the moral concepts are essential. they are like a compass, is what keeps you in line with yourself. without it you can easily get lost mentally. or become someone you don't like to be. I'm not saying it has to be your only way of seeing life. and you can go over it in favor of a greater benefit. as I did with Larry. but to me it is very important.
This was also a hard decision for me, and ended up choosing to stay silent.
What happened after that? Did Nick Survive?
Yes. And I appreciate variety. To each their own, I guess.
Sickle, hay hook, and taser. That was even harder
Choosing which table to sit at...it was like middle school coming back to haunt me.
Seriously though, the decision of whether or not to mercy kill the screaming girl in episode 3 was a serious moral dilemma. Blind idealism versus (extremely) cold pragmatism.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q99YxDVUNH0
Not really that much. I didn't see it that effective. You escaped either ways.
Damn son, now we just need Omid stache and Travis stache.
I didn't steal from the stranger's car, and i was surprised that almost everyone did at the time when i was playing the first season. I haven't really had any tough choices in Season 2. With Sarita's arm, i figured what the heck, if there is a chance you may as well cut it off, to me it was a no brainer.
Pete i didn't even know he was bit until he pointed it out in Season 2 ^_^,
Excuse me for saying, But no morals can make up for stupidity. You have a shitload of food and supplies, Don't leave them out in the open in the ZA.
Choosing day/night. Giving Vernon Clementine. Just kidding. But seriously, stealing from the car or not.