Most difficult decision

124

Comments

  • what about the stache stuff?

    BenUseful has slowly become BeardUseful.

  • edited June 2014

    Season 1: Whether to kill Larry or Not. I eventually did kill Larry but I regretted it immediately afterwards and I've disliked Kenny ever since.

    400 days: Shoot Justin or Danny's ankle. Justin was a nasty piece of work who back-stabbed many people and didn't regret any of it. Danny was a rapist and that, in my mind at least, is the worst crime you can commit. Although he came across as a decent man with morals who clearly had some regret for what he'd done. I eventually chose to shoot Danny's ankle.

    Season 2: In all honesty, I've not found any of the decisions to be that difficult this season.

  • Wat about duck?

    Alt text

    I fed Clem/Lilly/Ben/Mark. Carley refused to take food.

  • i took the monkey wrench

    hihitwd posted: »

    Took the spanner bro.

  • The ONLY reason I didn't drop him even though he got Duck, Katjea, and Carley killed and almost getting Clementine killed was cause Clem said Ben was her friend so I pulled the idiot up

    Markd4547 posted: »

    Save Ben There was conflict in my head from cold perceptive this guy ruined everything and is ticking time bomb to finish off the rest of

  • Killing Danny or not

    Cause he is pissing me off

  • Having Clementine shoot Lee.
    Even though it was a hard decision, I knew it was the right decision.

    I gave, what I felt to be the right example regarding Duck, not just euthanizing him, but also sparing my pal Kenny that heartache of having to it himself.
    And showing her what it means to be a good friend.

  • I've always found it hard whether to kill Larry or not. I mean, we don't even know if he was really dead or not.

    Also, cutting Lee's arm off.

  • Whether to drop or pull up Ben, I hated him after I found out he was the one giving supplies to the bandits and it only got worse when he decided to leave clem for the walkers that instantly made me want him dead. When I saw how he pulled the axe out of the door I thought ben couldn't piss me off more than he already has, I voted for him to get out of the group, But when it finally came down to it I couldn't let him fall it wasn't one of the decisions where I waited for the timer to go out it was just an instant reaction not matter how much I hated him I wanted him to be able to redeem himself too bad he wasn't exactly able to do that :/

  • I pretty much knew it was too late for it to do anything but in the moment indeed there was much desperation for more time to get clem back

    An act of desperation indeed.

  • That is honestly one of the scariest yet funny photos I've seen in my life

    Markd4547 posted: »

    Damn right

  • StacheUseful. There you go. :D

    BenUseful posted: »

    what about the stache stuff?

  • Well, I had to make a choice. Duck needed to be sacrificed.

    Bygler posted: »

    Wat about duck?

  • I've been getting the Larry situation quite a lot.

    MrHazer posted: »

    Season 1: Whether to kill Larry or Not. I eventually did kill Larry but I regretted it immediately afterwards and I've disliked Kenny ever s

  • Haven't played 400 Days tbh. But soon will do.

    Gayman111 posted: »

    Killing Danny or not Cause he is pissing me off

  • edited June 2014

    But he just wanted to help. And i agree that Ben's death was ridiculous.

  • Most of you guys have these two choices + S2's Launch table. xD

    I've always found it hard whether to kill Larry or not. I mean, we don't even know if he was really dead or not. Also, cutting Lee's arm off.

  • I grabbed the sickle. Which makes me wonder how did Kenny and Carley/Doug come up with two aditional sickles.

    Sickle, hay hook, and taser. That was even harder

  • I found this really hard to answer too. I felt like Nick was an idiot but I should keep my promise to uncle Pete.

    Answering if Nick was a good guy or not. Now to most of you, the answer was probably easy. He's a good guy. But I was so caught up in the moment, only thinking about the bad things that he'd done, that I answered differently. Yes. I am the 16%.

  • edited June 2014

    Clem/Duck/Mark/Kenny is usually my combination.

    Bygler posted: »

    At the time?

  • Yeah, I thought Ben leaving Clementine to the walkers like that was pretty cold.
    There was no excuse for that jackass behavior!

    But in spite of all his shit, I pulled him up, when it would've been so easy to drop him.
    I just couldn't justify dropping him, especially after the remorse he showed.
    I just couldn't do it!

  • edited June 2014

    The Larry decision: Chose to help Kenny at the last moment, since Kenny had made it a matter of loyalty by that point and I remembered how much of a dick Larry was to me.
    Girl in the streets: Once again, a decision Kenny strongly influenced me towards. I probably would have shot her if Lee were alone, but Kenny made the point about letting her be so we could get the supplies. My guilt was made so much worse due to the fact I could hear her being eaten alive.
    Who to sit with: Sat there for a very long time until a light-bulb went off in my head and I went, "What am I thinking?? Its KENNY."
    Surrender or find help: Chose to find Kenny and Luke at the last moment, because I figured that resistance was at least better than submission.

  • It was terrible how it would have happened I hated the kid so much but just wanted him to be able to redeem himself

    Kenny/Lee posted: »

    Yeah, I thought Ben leaving Clementine to the walkers like that was pretty cold. There was no excuse for that jackass behavior! But in s

  • Resistance is better than submission. You keep earning my respect even more. Much respect.

    However, I surrendered because i knew Carver wouldn't die anyway. If it mattered, I'd have gone with Kenny.

    The Larry decision: Chose to help Kenny at the last moment, since Kenny had made it a matter of loyalty by that point and I remembered how

  • Yes. Me too.

    It was terrible how it would have happened I hated the kid so much but just wanted him to be able to redeem himself

  • I agree if you're good to Kenny he's good to you

    The Larry decision: Chose to help Kenny at the last moment, since Kenny had made it a matter of loyalty by that point and I remembered how

  • edited June 2014

    No he didn't.
    If kids are in a group, than they get the primary concern.
    That's what a responsible adult does.

    I'll tell you who could, and deserved to miss a meal, was Larry.
    Since the guy acted like a bitter jerk all the time, I far as I was concerned, he was on his own.

    I fed Clementine, Duck, Kenny, and Mark, especially when I saw how weak he was getting.
    I offered to Carly, but she refused.

    Well, I had to make a choice. Duck needed to be sacrificed.

  • I have another way of looking at it.

    Kenny/Lee posted: »

    No he didn't. If kids are in a group, than they get the primary concern. That's what a responsible adult does. I'll tell you who could

  • Too bad he didn't get too

    Yes. Me too.

  • I was pissed off when he died.

    Too bad he didn't get too

  • I was too but it goes to show not everyone can get a happy ending especially if you're the last one jumping off a balcony, I felt it was stupid of him to just stand there with big eyes when he heard it give, but I guess in a moment I would be pretty damn scared too.

    I was pissed off when he died.

  • edited June 2014

    And how would that be exactly?
    not trying to sound antagonistic.
    Just curious really.

    I have another way of looking at it.

  • I don't have a certain rule to follow. I saw that Kenny was putting unnecessary pressure on Lilly, So i gave Ben the food instead of Duck.

    Kenny/Lee posted: »

    And how would that be exactly? not trying to sound antagonistic. Just curious really.

  • edited June 2014

    I hear that, about the Larry deal.
    I had been there for Kenny, all the way back to Herschel's farm, and he repaid that by saving Lee back at the drugstore, after Larry knocked Lee flat.
    And, thinking back to how quickly Ben's dead classmate turned, it didn't seem like there was a lot of choice.

    I did however disagree with Kenny, over the girl in the streets at the drugstore.
    No matter if it bought us enough time, and no matter how badly Kenny wanted me to, I couldn't in good conscious leave her as bait.
    That was just to cruel, I couldn't do that.

    And when it came to Carver at the lodge, I told Kenny to pick what's his name off.
    After Carver murdered Walt, I quickly realized that Carver was keep up his murderous rampage until either Kenny ran out of bullets, or Carver ran out of people to shoot.
    After Carver grabbed Alvin, that's when I grabbed the gun away from Kenny.

    Though admire Kenny's tenacity, and even though I have a lot of the same tenacity myself, I knew that at that point it was smarter to give up before someone else got hurt.
    Though in the truck, I was with Kenny when he was making up an escape attempt.
    Even though it was a half-ass scheme, to me it was better than nothing.
    I'd rather go out fighting than die penned up like cattle.

    Ideally though I'd prefer not to die at all.
    But if push comes to shove, I'm going down swinging!

    The Larry decision: Chose to help Kenny at the last moment, since Kenny had made it a matter of loyalty by that point and I remembered how

  • Yeah it was a pretty tough decision morally, I hated how Lilly didn't care what happened to us even though we had just risked our life getting supplies for the group.

    Kenny/Lee posted: »

    I hear that, about the Larry deal. I had been there for Kenny, all the way back to Herschel's farm, and he repaid that by saving Lee back a

  • Couldn't have said it better myself.
    And, that's one of the cardinal rules of friendship.

    I agree if you're good to Kenny he's good to you

  • Yeah if you wanna be good friends with people you have to work together and agree on things and if you have a few rifts in the friendship than that's what happens but no matter what you take care of your own

    Kenny/Lee posted: »

    Couldn't have said it better myself. And, that's one of the cardinal rules of friendship.

  • Yeah that pissed me off too.
    And after she murdered poor Carly, that was it!
    I left her on the side of the road, with no regrets.

    Yeah it was a pretty tough decision morally, I hated how Lilly didn't care what happened to us even though we had just risked our life getting supplies for the group.

  • Exactly this is when she had crossed the lineAlt text

    Kenny/Lee posted: »

    Yeah that pissed me off too. And after she murdered poor Carly, that was it! I left her on the side of the road, with no regrets.

  • I can agree on what you're saying about Lilly. But i can't possibly agree about Kenny.

    Exactly this is when she had crossed the line

Sign in to comment in this discussion.