Yeah, I'll have to disagree about Ben. The boy could just not be trusted with anything (judging from Kenny's viewpoint, Ben made for a poor lookout, and he was horrible at watching over Clementine in Lee's absence- abandoning her when they were attacked by walkers and forgetting to keep a watchful eye on her when Lee specifically asked him to keep an eye on her while he and Kenny searched for a boat).
From the very first choice he made, he put the lives of others at risk (as a result of his stupidity/cowardess, five people - Carly/Doug, Duck, Katja, Chuck and Bree - had lost their lives). And one woman (Lily) was thrown out of the group she fought so hard to help protect after her justified suspicions over their supplies being stolen by one of their own caused her to become a mental wreck that could no longer be trusted.
With me it's the opposite - I was more inclined to forgive Ben (mainly because it reminded me of my own teenage fuck-up moments). Besides, h… moreis problem was that he didn't think before acting and this could have been easily rectified. With Sarah the problem goes much deeper. With her it's a way she functions and one can't fix that over a few months. That shit takes years. If it even does any good at all.
And I'd say she's more of a liability than Ben as she needs more care, gives nothing to the group and has put it in danger. Ben needed no care, he worked best as a look-out, and he did put the group in danger once (I'm not counting episode 3 as everything was going alright until Lily in her bitchdom fucked it all up). So Ben was OK.
That's true - but then, that would depend on how distracted everyone is (if the preview trailer is accurate, there's a walker attack, and a woman going into labor at the same time. That won't make it easy to keep an eye on Sarah and what she's doing during the chaos).
Oh, my bad, I guess I read too fast. But given how understandable it is, I really wouldn't fault her for that...
It's been a long time si… morence I was 16 (I thought she was 15? Either way, high school was a long time ago...) but she doesn't strike me as being particularly immature (or psychologically underdevelopped - except, perhaps, the friend conversation with Clementine in e1).
Even without being sheltered, two years out there, especially if codled, would stunt development. We don't know how Omid and Christa treated Clementine (obviously well, I just mean as an adult or as a kid) but depending on how they treat you, being only around adults can be heavily stunting or maturing (even to the point of alienating you from peers). Given the 'cease to function' idea, I'd say the former. As somebody with mild anxiety problems, you can break out shaking, I had a friend who would have panic attacks that were much more severe, but my guess is Carl… [view original content]
Comments like this is what caused me to say that in the first place. Do you seriously think she is suddenly going to lose her shit and confuse a walker (Even her dad as a walker) for her somehow alive dad?
By no means am I saying her reaction wasn't justified - but by reacting that way, she did draw the walkers attention to herself and her comp… moreanions- forcing a fight for their very lives as she ran blindly into the forests.
And like Ben from the comics, she knows that walkers exist and that they're dangerous. However, given her mental state (especially after witnessing her beloved father first getting shot, then chomped on by various walkers), she may not recognize the immediate danger if she happens across a zombified Carlos (especially if she recalls Jane's earlier instructions on how to wander amongst walkers without being detected. She could really sink into a complete mental meltdown and confuse a walker for her living, loving father).
If she has a complete mental meltdown, then yes - as similar cases have happened within the comics (benn killing his twin brother with the belief that his brother would return as his brother, not a walker. And Carol, who willingly got close enough to a walker because, in her deranged state, she wanted someone to love her).
Comments like this is what caused me to say that in the first place. Do you seriously think she is suddenly going to lose her shit and confuse a walker (Even her dad as a walker) for her somehow alive dad?
Pretty sure Rebecca is going to die at birth, Nick is determinate, so bye bye Nick, sadly. Luke is hot, he ain't dying. Kenny's got the 'stache, so he ain't dyin' either. Jane is Jane, and Mike, well, I don't really care for Mike. so. Not all of them.
Pretty sure Rebecca is going to die at birth, Nick is determinate, so bye bye Nick, sadly. Luke is hot, he ain't dying. Kenny's got the 'sta… moreche, so he ain't dyin' either. Jane is Jane, and Mike, well, I don't really care for Mike. so. Not all of them.
Rebecca - will die shortly after giving birth due to infection.
Nick - as much as his fans don't want him to die, he's a goner (an alternate route back at the lodge confirms this outcome).
Sarita - provided she can adapt to being left handed (unless she already is) and doesn't die due to an infection, she'll pull through.
Bonnie - provided she doesn;t put her trust into the wrong person a second time, she should be fine.
Sarah - this girl is bound to get herself (and others) killed.
Jane - no question, she'll make it.
Mike - I could see him lasting another season.
Clementine - she'll live. Telltale already broke our heart killing the last protagonist; I don't see them doing that again.
Kenny - he's a ballsy fucker who's quick tempered and has been through Hell numerous times; but still manages to pull through each time. Can be reckless, but he'll live.
Luke - also ballsy, but - according to Nick - most of his plans fall through. As much as I like Luke, I don't see him making it out past this season.
Pretty sure Rebecca is going to die at birth, Nick is determinate, so bye bye Nick, sadly. Luke is hot, he ain't dying. Kenny's got the 'sta… moreche, so he ain't dyin' either. Jane is Jane, and Mike, well, I don't really care for Mike. so. Not all of them.
The only link I've found to Telltale so far Is this:
"I wanted to post a few shots of the last week of work. We had our good friends Erin Ashe and Nick Herman in over the weekend to lend some temporary voices for Henry and Delilah. If you’re a Telltale fan you’ll know Erin from her work as Molly in The Walking Dead and Snow in The Wolf Among Us and Nick, a multi-talented director over there, was the voice of Glenn in The Walking Dead."
I think they may have a couple friends there, but I don't think the company is derived from Telltale.
Jane only cares about herself and seems quick to throw anyone under the bus to let herself live longer. I don't doubt that she's a skilled survivalist, but she's a devious one. I'm just going to hope that Jane doesn't cross the line in the next episode, because I have a feeling there would be no way to stop her from doing whatever fucked up thing she may plan on.
Jane only cares about herself and seems quick to throw anyone under the bus to let herself live longer. I don't doubt that she's a skilled s… moreurvivalist, but she's a devious one. I'm just going to hope that Jane doesn't cross the line in the next episode, because I have a feeling there would be no way to stop her from doing whatever fucked up thing she may plan on.
We've seen people that were devoured by walkers come back (remember Bri from Season one? She was chomped on and had her guts ripped out by f… moreeasting walkers; but she was one of the first walkers to break past the baracade at the house Lee and his troupe was hiding in.
So, it's not unlikely that Carlos could very well have turned and be amongst the walkers attacking the survivors in episode 4.
Is it weird that when it came to Ben in Season 1 (who was the major liability to the group), I was more inclined to want the bastard to die; but when it comes to Sarah, I'd rather she lived - despite the fact she just as much a liability as Ben was?
Comments
Yeah, I'll have to disagree about Ben. The boy could just not be trusted with anything (judging from Kenny's viewpoint, Ben made for a poor lookout, and he was horrible at watching over Clementine in Lee's absence- abandoning her when they were attacked by walkers and forgetting to keep a watchful eye on her when Lee specifically asked him to keep an eye on her while he and Kenny searched for a boat).
From the very first choice he made, he put the lives of others at risk (as a result of his stupidity/cowardess, five people - Carly/Doug, Duck, Katja, Chuck and Bree - had lost their lives). And one woman (Lily) was thrown out of the group she fought so hard to help protect after her justified suspicions over their supplies being stolen by one of their own caused her to become a mental wreck that could no longer be trusted.
That's true - but then, that would depend on how distracted everyone is (if the preview trailer is accurate, there's a walker attack, and a woman going into labor at the same time. That won't make it easy to keep an eye on Sarah and what she's doing during the chaos).
"Seeing another little girl die.. might just do me in."
She is RIGHT,that's why she survived this far,and the people who get mad at her will be served like Chuck's advice to Lee.
That's Chuck, right?
Not the whole group will bring Clementine down. Most of them will, but not all.
Mhm.
Comments like this is what caused me to say that in the first place. Do you seriously think she is suddenly going to lose her shit and confuse a walker (Even her dad as a walker) for her somehow alive dad?
"They're all gonna die, Clem"
Me: Yeah, they probably will.
If she has a complete mental meltdown, then yes - as similar cases have happened within the comics (benn killing his twin brother with the belief that his brother would return as his brother, not a walker. And Carol, who willingly got close enough to a walker because, in her deranged state, she wanted someone to love her).
Pretty sure Rebecca is going to die at birth, Nick is determinate, so bye bye Nick, sadly. Luke is hot, he ain't dying. Kenny's got the 'stache, so he ain't dyin' either. Jane is Jane, and Mike, well, I don't really care for Mike. so. Not all of them.
Let's hope when Nick dies we actually get a reaction from Luke. Like, that's just embarrassing that we didn't hear anything from him the last time.
I don't think he knew.. I don't even think he knew in episode 3 either?!
I know. It's poor writing on TTG's part.
Rebecca - will die shortly after giving birth due to infection.
Nick - as much as his fans don't want him to die, he's a goner (an alternate route back at the lodge confirms this outcome).
Sarita - provided she can adapt to being left handed (unless she already is) and doesn't die due to an infection, she'll pull through.
Bonnie - provided she doesn;t put her trust into the wrong person a second time, she should be fine.
Sarah - this girl is bound to get herself (and others) killed.
Jane - no question, she'll make it.
Mike - I could see him lasting another season.
Clementine - she'll live. Telltale already broke our heart killing the last protagonist; I don't see them doing that again.
Kenny - he's a ballsy fucker who's quick tempered and has been through Hell numerous times; but still manages to pull through each time. Can be reckless, but he'll live.
Luke - also ballsy, but - according to Nick - most of his plans fall through. As much as I like Luke, I don't see him making it out past this season.
Where are the Season One writers? Because I don't see this game being Game of the Year currently.
They left to form some other company or something.
Did someone say saltlick?
Well I guess we should look out for games from them, once we know which company they are.
http://www.camposanto.com/
The only link I've found to Telltale so far Is this:
"I wanted to post a few shots of the last week of work. We had our good friends Erin Ashe and Nick Herman in over the weekend to lend some temporary voices for Henry and Delilah. If you’re a Telltale fan you’ll know Erin from her work as Molly in The Walking Dead and Snow in The Wolf Among Us and Nick, a multi-talented director over there, was the voice of Glenn in The Walking Dead."
I think they may have a couple friends there, but I don't think the company is derived from Telltale.
Jane only cares about herself and seems quick to throw anyone under the bus to let herself live longer. I don't doubt that she's a skilled survivalist, but she's a devious one. I'm just going to hope that Jane doesn't cross the line in the next episode, because I have a feeling there would be no way to stop her from doing whatever fucked up thing she may plan on.
There's no way to tell that she's reckless and that she only cares about herself. It's just implied.
Yes i still find it ridiculous how Brie managed to wander out of the school and all the way back to the mansion lol!
Ben was more likeable than Sarah in my opinion
Maybe he didnt know but he never asked about Nick. Its terrible writing on TTG's part!