Miniority Rules
In the face of the dictating Majority, I thought of making a thread to speak about unpopular opinions. Whatever it is.
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
In the face of the dictating Majority, I thought of making a thread to speak about unpopular opinions. Whatever it is.
Comments
Trying to save Duck at Hershel's farm.
I mean, when you first played, you obviously like Shawn more. But I was still shocked when I replayed Season 1 Episode 1 just under a month ago. It was something like:
"You and 30% of others saved Duck."
Me confuse
I didn't hate Troy. At least not in the way most people did.
Also, I didn't find Nate that much of an interesting character.
I have to admit I liked Shawn more, But I saved Duck to gain Kenny's loyalty.
I'm just confused because so many people currently like Duck.
Nate's just a good antagonist, and that's why everybody likes him. I guess.
For me, Smashing Carver's head and Shooting Troy's dick were two of the my favorite moments ever.
Nate is crazy, I went along with his craziness on my 400 Days walkthrough, But i don't like him.
Maybe it's more like The Sarah situation, Strong minority that's overshadowing a weak majority making it seem like everyone hates her.
I'm...not following you.
You say that Duck is popular around here. But maybe That isn't really the truth. You see, For example, There're many Sarah hatred threads and barely any support threads. It does make it seem like the majority hates Sarah, While infact, The majority likes Sarah. All I'm saying that Duck could be in a similar situation.
I don't like Kenny
I wasn't a big fan either in season 1, But I admired him in Season 2.
Well...maybe the Duck haters have spoken their mind, and now just live in the shadows. Just like Duck.
"I will live in the shadows!"
Hating Larry, Lilly, Ben, and Vernon. Hating anybody who knowingly puts the group in danger
Larry's hatred is quite popular, So is Ben's. I believe the community is split on Vernon and Lilly.
Lol. But seriously, Do you like Duck?
I thought everyone would save him because...well...he's a kid? I mean, that's why I saved him.
Some people aren't idealistic. Such as me.
Of course.
I actually really liked Ben as a character.
Yeah, he screwed up a lot (and indirectly caused the death of Kenny's family), but I still thought that because he was so awkward, he was hilarious. It was a good addition to the game to add a cowardice, nervous teenager who acted the complete opposite from how Lee, Kenny, Christa, etc. handled everything. He was insecure and struggling with the fact that, yes, he knows he's considered deadweight.
I just felt really bad for him.
I liked him, But for different reasons.
I feel so bad for him because either way, his death is painful and gruesome.
Anybody who didn't owe up to having the walkie talkie in episode 3 is a pussy.
Plain and simple. Carver isn't a dumbass, he knew somebody took two.
This is a thread about unpopular opinions, Not insulting an unpopular opinion.
I didn't have Lee's arm cut off. I was just picturing myself in his situation and I wouldn't have the guts to have my arm sawed off.
I don't like Lilly, I didn't tell Bonnie about Luke, and I surrender when Carver was beating Carlos.
i thought about it, But I was desperate to get Lee out of it alive.
I didn't tell Bonnie either. I liked Lilly and I surrendered for one reason, I was curious to see what happens. Besides, I knew already I'd end up in Carver's camp anyway.
I think Season 2 episode 3 had shit character development, consistency, and characters in-general.
I could explain if anyone wants.
EDIT: I thought people would assume I was talking about Ep 3 of S2. I thought Ep 3 of S1 was amazing.
which season?
If you're speaking about 203, Many people hated it.
But If you're speaking about 103, I'm pretty sure a lot of people hated it as well. :P
Seriously though, 103 wasn't hated, Some people just complained about killing Carley/Doug.
But I'd like to see you talking about why do you think it was underdeveloped.
Doesn't matter how much you like or dislike a kid. You save the children before you save the adults.
I think that's kind of a western perspective on things, but its thoroughly ingrained in me. The choice was obvious for me the moment it presented itself, regardless of whether Duck was annoying.
Carver becomes a generic sadistic crazy antagonist from the interesting, darker, smart and threatening character from Ep 2.
Troy becomes a generic crazy loyal talkative lackie from the silent henchman in ep 2.
Tavia becomes a bitch from the nice woman she was in 400 days.
Vince became a mindless henchman from the leader and untrusting person he was in 400 days.
Russel hated the type of people Carver was and ran away from them just to get roped into and be okay with Carver.
Nick & Alvin had maybe 8 lines.
Sarita hasn't done anything but be sad for Kenny after he got beat and be there for Kenny to go crazy when he finds out what happens to her in ep 4.
Rebecca barely reacts over Alvin's death.
Luke doesn't react over Nick's death.
Reggie existed solely to show how bad Carver is.
I could go on further too.
It's not about being annoying, It's about watching over my priorities instead of the moral ones. And no, For me kids don't come before adults.
How'd you develop the characters if you were the one in charge?
Totally agree. The episode wasn't horrendous, but the character development was rushed.
Keep them going on in the direction they were going in the 1st two eps and 400 days.
Make Carver more morally gray and less of a sadist nutjob.
Have Troy speak less and be less of an ass.
Give Nick more lines and actual importance.
Make the episode less Kenny centric and give us a reason to fucking care about the Cabin Crew.
Not have Sarita as an object for Kenny to go batshit over but instead have be some sort of Aunt/Mother figure for Clementine who looks out for her and keeps her "humane"
Not have Carver kill Reggie over berries. Instead have him kill Reggie when Carver finds out about the walkie talkie plan.
This character is just like me, i like him...
Don't you think It'd be too Season 1-ish? They have to innovate to give Season 2 an edge, They can't stay the same forever. The characters are still loose because Clementine is still somekind of an intruder to the community. Episode 4 and 5 will lead to choose between Survivalists vs Community and to see both clearly in Amid the ruins and then judge in Ep5. If it was applied in that kind of plot, it'd be too similar to season 1 and the ending won't be any good.
I can understand you not liking him in season one. I didn't really like him then for the reason that he seemed to only really care about Duck and Katjaa, and have no care in the world for Clementine til' the end when it was obviously too late to fix. That's just how it appeared to me, but he's proven himself useful in season two...
Agreed.