I still would, yeah, but I wouldn't feel as strongly about it being the "right" choice for Lee to make, more just a personal choice because I myself liked her and wanted to give her another chance. You know?
Also why did you put the word "cheating" in quotes?"
Just to point out that Lee had a decent reason. It's not the choice I'd have made, But still, He had his reasons. Lilly was jsut going batshit crazy after her father got killed.
Unfortunately, I gave her a second chance, First, i threw her off in the street, But then i had to exit the game and rage on twitter, CARLEY IS FUCKING DEAD! xD And then replayed the whole area and decided to keep her around. But She's proven me wrong by stealing the RV.
I still would, yeah, but I wouldn't feel as strongly about it being the "right" choice for Lee to make, more just a personal choice because … moreI myself liked her and wanted to give her another chance. You know?
Also why did you put the word "cheating" in quotes?"
I shot Danny's foot off and escaped with Justin. No regrets. Maybe Justin's a liar, but I'll take the guy who stole money from old rich people over the guy who raped a minor. Besides, Danny was a liar, too. He said he didn't do it, but if you point the gun at him long enough he admits that he did indeed rape her.
I shot Danny's foot off and escaped with Justin. No regrets. Maybe Justin's a liar, but I'll take the guy who stole money from old rich peop… morele over the guy who raped a minor. Besides, Danny was a liar, too. He said he didn't do it, but if you point the gun at him long enough he admits that he did indeed rape her.
I mean, neither of them really have excuses when it comes to murder. Murder is murder, there really isn't a "good" reason unless the person is directly attacking you and you're defending yourself (i.e. Bonnie killing Dee). But like I said, I feel bad for Lilly because of the pressure she was under and I can't bring myself to hate on her.
And as for the RV thing, idk, it pissed me off at first but when I read up on the other scenes, it didn't bother me as much. Honestly, either you leave the RV and get on the train, or the RV gets stolen and you get on the train. Either way, by that point you have no use for it anymore.
Just to point out that Lee had a decent reason. It's not the choice I'd have made, But still, He had his reasons. Lilly was jsut going batsh… moreit crazy after her father got killed.
Unfortunately, I gave her a second chance, First, i threw her off in the street, But then i had to exit the game and rage on twitter, CARLEY IS FUCKING DEAD! xD And then replayed the whole area and decided to keep her around. But She's proven me wrong by stealing the RV.
Yeah, and if you went with Danny, at the end of the game Russell mentions how he was a huge creep and he's glad that Danny died before Shel and Becca joined the group. So it's pretty much confirmed that Danny was a rapist.
I don't know about blind idealism I know I didn't help save Larry and I avec Ben because that was inhuman and the way chuck described him as a child I felt that would have been a serious jerk move
Example of what this was is the bully getting picked on as much as you may hate him/her you either help defend them or let the anger consume you and become glaring clem
I don't know about blind idealism I know I didn't help save Larry and I avec Ben because that was inhuman and the way chuck described him as… more a child I felt that would have been a serious jerk move
Example of what this was is the bully getting picked on as much as you may hate him/her you either help defend them or let the anger consume you and become glaring clem
I mean, neither of them really have excuses when it comes to murder. Murder is murder, there really isn't a "good" reason unless the person … moreis directly attacking you and you're defending yourself (i.e. Bonnie killing Dee). But like I said, I feel bad for Lilly because of the pressure she was under and I can't bring myself to hate on her.
And as for the RV thing, idk, it pissed me off at first but when I read up on the other scenes, it didn't bother me as much. Honestly, either you leave the RV and get on the train, or the RV gets stolen and you get on the train. Either way, by that point you have no use for it anymore.
Yes, You have a point. Still most of the people around here can't make the hard choices the apocalypse needs them to do in order to survive. Morally weak.
Again I would like to disagree *respectfully of course
I would say those who said how the characters are awful yet still helped aren't weak of moral bit rather kept their human nature I may hate you but I won't kill you I kind of like that there are good people out there though they try to hide it they do care and like most humans they can be cruel but the people who played tried to look out for everyone still (they just probably didn't get along to we'll with kenny x3 )
Yes, You have a point. Still most of the people around here can't make the hard choices the apocalypse needs them to do in order to survive. Morally weak.
Those aren't the common ground here. While i disagree with those people, I respect them. However, I'm more of Jane-like kind of person. If you earn my respect, You'll be saved and helped. If not, Then I don't give a damn about you. But i can offer help from time to time to see if that character has potential or not. Done it with Sarah, Ended up disappointed.
Again I would like to disagree *respectfully of course
I would say those who said how the characters are awful yet still helped aren't wea… morek of moral bit rather kept their human nature I may hate you but I won't kill you I kind of like that there are good people out there though they try to hide it they do care and like most humans they can be cruel but the people who played tried to look out for everyone still (they just probably didn't get along to we'll with kenny x3 )
Yes!! When I played that episode for the first time, I made up my mind almost immediately. I was surprised when the stats over whom people saved was in his favor.
I shot Danny's foot off and escaped with Justin. No regrets. Maybe Justin's a liar, but I'll take the guy who stole money from old rich peop… morele over the guy who raped a minor. Besides, Danny was a liar, too. He said he didn't do it, but if you point the gun at him long enough he admits that he did indeed rape her.
ok dad, i am done arguing over Nate. It is pointless, i might as well beat that dead horse until it is a bloody stump. I listed all my reasons in other threads, if he would like he could go ahead and find one of those and read through them, but seriously there is no point in getting over a argument over a opinion. I just don't have it in me right now.
Look, George, I understand your opinion and I'm totally okay with it, But Everyone is welcome here, Despite our arguments, Even you are welcome. So don't start dictating others.
Huh. What do you know. I didn't hold the trigger long enough to hear that. I shot Danny too. But only because it was his idea! Which in hindsight kinda seems like a bad reason. But, eh. Justin still seemed cool.
I shot Danny's foot off and escaped with Justin. No regrets. Maybe Justin's a liar, but I'll take the guy who stole money from old rich peop… morele over the guy who raped a minor. Besides, Danny was a liar, too. He said he didn't do it, but if you point the gun at him long enough he admits that he did indeed rape her.
3 full episodes yes.
But Clem has known them a week and we knew the rest a lot longer than that.
So there is going to be more character development in the first season because it was over a longer period of time,
How much do you want to know these people? We are still strangers and still in the weird stage of not trusting each other.
No one is a close character by your logic. And we had 3 episodes to actually know them. 3 full episodes that featured them. For a story based game it sure isn't doing a whole lot to get me to care about the cast.
I have a habit of going into lost of detail but I was too lazy to do so this time. I don't understand how people can judge the current situation when the season isn't over. Go ahead and judge it when the season is finished, but its half a project, you can't criticize it yet!
I dome think people are grasping the difference of playing an adult and a child yet.
Things are going to be different, plus, we've know the cabin people just over a week, people can't really expect to know these people fully within a week, especially when its one thing after another, they haven't really had time yet and still don't trust each other enough yet.
Its still a pretty amazing game. Why don't we look at what they've achieved instead of what they haven't?
Still, it summed up how i feel about many things. I get into too much little details and fail to deliver the big picture. You've succeeded where i failed.
* I strongly dislike Kenny for various reasons. (I'm guaranteed to get tonnes of dislikes for that one.)
* I didn't put Sam out of his mi… moresery.
* I feel they ruined Carvers character from E2 to E3. He came across as cold, calculating and intelligent in episode 2. In episode 3 he was just made out to be some sadistic psychopath.
I agree. I preferred Shawn but I saved Duck because he was a child and when I had played it (when the game first came out), most people had done that too. I still stick to my choice, regardless of what the popular opinion is. In real life most would have saved the kid and anyway, as if you would choose not not save the child, but everyone is entitled to their own opinions and choices.
Not trusting Bonnie was not a popular opinion. I understand why completely, but for me, Clementine's perspective, she had not seen how Bonnie was before it all (400 days). I chose not to confide in her because even though she apologized, she knew exactly what she was doing when she came to the lodge in episode 2. How do people know that it's not the first time she has done this anyway? Carver clearly has found plenty of stray people and either convinced or forced them to join his camp. I accepted Bonny's apology, but she was still not someone to confide in imo.
Not trying to defend Danny's actions, but I took him with me because he clearly had Vince's back. Justin just seemed really slimey, and the fact that he didn't want to intervene to save the other prisoner's life made me question how useful he would be in a tough situation. Danny is, most likely, a rapist, and that's obviously horrible. But he at least seemed to regret his crime, while Justin blatantly states that he has no regrets. So, from a survivalist's perspective, I felt like I had a better shot if I took Danny (btw Justin will abandon you if you choose him, which kind of proves my point about him having no loyalty).
I shot Danny's foot off and escaped with Justin. No regrets. Maybe Justin's a liar, but I'll take the guy who stole money from old rich peop… morele over the guy who raped a minor. Besides, Danny was a liar, too. He said he didn't do it, but if you point the gun at him long enough he admits that he did indeed rape her.
ok dad, i am done arguing over Nate. It is pointless, i might as well beat that dead horse until it is a bloody stump. I listed all my reas… moreons in other threads, if he would like he could go ahead and find one of those and read through them, but seriously there is no point in getting over a argument over a opinion. I just don't have it in me right now.
Not trying to defend Danny's actions, but I took him with me because he clearly had Vince's back. Justin just seemed really slimey, and the… more fact that he didn't want to intervene to save the other prisoner's life made me question how useful he would be in a tough situation. Danny is, most likely, a rapist, and that's obviously horrible. But he at least seemed to regret his crime, while Justin blatantly states that he has no regrets. So, from a survivalist's perspective, I felt like I had a better shot if I took Danny (btw Justin will abandon you if you choose him, which kind of proves my point about him having no loyalty).
Not trusting Bonnie was not a popular opinion. I understand why completely, but for me, Clementine's perspective, she had not seen how Bonni… moree was before it all (400 days). I chose not to confide in her because even though she apologized, she knew exactly what she was doing when she came to the lodge in episode 2. How do people know that it's not the first time she has done this anyway? Carver clearly has found plenty of stray people and either convinced or forced them to join his camp. I accepted Bonny's apology, but she was still not someone to confide in imo.
3 full episodes yes.
But Clem has known them a week and we knew the rest a lot longer than that.
So there is going to be more character … moredevelopment in the first season because it was over a longer period of time,
How much do you want to know these people? We are still strangers and still in the weird stage of not trusting each other.
Carley strikes me as a Mary Sue and while she does have her share of good lines/moments, her character doesn't really get fleshed out as much as Doug. Taking Doug along also changes the way you view Lily, because she accidentally kills him in an attempt to execute Ben, whereas gunning down Carley can only be chalked up cold-blooded murder.
Nope. I've never seen her in that way. Maybe Because I always prefer badass female characters. I liked Doug, He's a tech geek, So am I. But I liked Carley more because she could handle herself.
Carley strikes me as a Mary Sue and while she does have her share of good lines/moments, her character doesn't really get fleshed out as muc… moreh as Doug. Taking Doug along also changes the way you view Lily, because she accidentally kills him in an attempt to execute Ben, whereas gunning down Carley can only be chalked up cold-blooded murder.
No, I don't find it bad or I would have said. I have agreed there has been times they COULD have added extra character development. But you have to realise this isn't season 1, you are not a 6ft hard arse fully grown adult anymore, who can take care of himself. You are a child, things are going to be different. If you reed my comment below they have given you reasons to respect or care about the cabin group..
This is not season 1. This is season 2. They are different, you are now playing as a child, they are trying to show how hard it has been and still is to survive in a world that's gone to hell. Its one string of events after another.
Separated from Christa and attacked, bitten by a dog, met new people, locked in a shed, fixed your own arm, attacked at the stream, Carvers arrival, on the run from Carver, attacked by walkers on the bridge, went to the lodge, met Kenny, then realise you killed Walters friend, then the wind turbines go mental, then attacked by walkers, then Carver shows up, holds everyone hostage, takes them back to the camp, then your put onto a prison, and are on the look out for an escape plan, see Sarah get slapped by her dad, see Reggie being pushed off a roof, forced in to work, Luke shows up, you steal a walkie talkie, try to get it to Luke, then Carver finds your plan, beats the crap out of Kenny, then you escape through the heard.
I would be really interested in all of that, where you see fit to walk around and get to know people, especially since everyone now has a wall up that's sky high. Like in season 1. But remember this isn't season 1, its season 2. Things are different considering its been going on for about 3 years now. People wont act the same way to new people after 3 years like they did in the first couple go days onto the put break.
As I said before, read my other comment below, I listed reasons that I think are there to respect and care for the characters. They've done it subtle, between the lines. You have to read in between the lines, you can't expect everything to be there for you. Considering the circumstances.
Wait until the season is over then make your judgement,
But I was more connected to the S1 cast by the end of Ep 1. That's 2 days compared to the ''week'' and 3 eps we knew the S2 cast.
Dont try to justify that shit, you know thats bad but you dont wanna be wrong.
No, I don't find it bad or I would have said. I have agreed there has been times they COULD have added extra character development. But you … morehave to realise this isn't season 1, you are not a 6ft hard arse fully grown adult anymore, who can take care of himself. You are a child, things are going to be different. If you reed my comment below they have given you reasons to respect or care about the cabin group..
This is not season 1. This is season 2. They are different, you are now playing as a child, they are trying to show how hard it has been and still is to survive in a world that's gone to hell. Its one string of events after another.
Separated from Christa and attacked, bitten by a dog, met new people, locked in a shed, fixed your own arm, attacked at the stream, Carvers arrival, on the run from Carver, attacked by walkers on the bridge, went to the lodge, met Kenny, then realise you killed Walters friend, then the wind turbines go … [view original content]
Comments
I still would, yeah, but I wouldn't feel as strongly about it being the "right" choice for Lee to make, more just a personal choice because I myself liked her and wanted to give her another chance. You know?
Also why did you put the word "cheating" in quotes?"
Just to point out that Lee had a decent reason. It's not the choice I'd have made, But still, He had his reasons. Lilly was jsut going batshit crazy after her father got killed.
Unfortunately, I gave her a second chance, First, i threw her off in the street, But then i had to exit the game and rage on twitter, CARLEY IS FUCKING DEAD! xD And then replayed the whole area and decided to keep her around. But She's proven me wrong by stealing the RV.
I shot Danny's foot off and escaped with Justin. No regrets. Maybe Justin's a liar, but I'll take the guy who stole money from old rich people over the guy who raped a minor. Besides, Danny was a liar, too. He said he didn't do it, but if you point the gun at him long enough he admits that he did indeed rape her.
I KNEW IT! I escaped with Justin as well for the exact same reasons.
I mean, neither of them really have excuses when it comes to murder. Murder is murder, there really isn't a "good" reason unless the person is directly attacking you and you're defending yourself (i.e. Bonnie killing Dee). But like I said, I feel bad for Lilly because of the pressure she was under and I can't bring myself to hate on her.
And as for the RV thing, idk, it pissed me off at first but when I read up on the other scenes, it didn't bother me as much. Honestly, either you leave the RV and get on the train, or the RV gets stolen and you get on the train. Either way, by that point you have no use for it anymore.
Yeah, and if you went with Danny, at the end of the game Russell mentions how he was a huge creep and he's glad that Danny died before Shel and Becca joined the group. So it's pretty much confirmed that Danny was a rapist.
I don't know about blind idealism I know I didn't help save Larry and I avec Ben because that was inhuman and the way chuck described him as a child I felt that would have been a serious jerk move
Example of what this was is the bully getting picked on as much as you may hate him/her you either help defend them or let the anger consume you and become glaring clem
You got it all wrong. Blind idealism is saving everyone, Much like a 100% goody two-shoes.
I don't see Murder as you see it, But I helped Lilly whenever possible but she's just a lady-jerk in my opinion.
But wouldn't a good two shoes also still be nice to them rather than admit there hatred for the character or find a reason to defend them?
Yes, You have a point. Still most of the people around here can't make the hard choices the apocalypse needs them to do in order to survive. Morally weak.
Like I said. In most cases.
Again I would like to disagree *respectfully of course
I would say those who said how the characters are awful yet still helped aren't weak of moral bit rather kept their human nature I may hate you but I won't kill you I kind of like that there are good people out there though they try to hide it they do care and like most humans they can be cruel but the people who played tried to look out for everyone still (they just probably didn't get along to we'll with kenny x3 )
Those aren't the common ground here. While i disagree with those people, I respect them. However, I'm more of Jane-like kind of person. If you earn my respect, You'll be saved and helped. If not, Then I don't give a damn about you. But i can offer help from time to time to see if that character has potential or not. Done it with Sarah, Ended up disappointed.
Yes!! When I played that episode for the first time, I made up my mind almost immediately. I was surprised when the stats over whom people saved was in his favor.
ok dad, i am done arguing over Nate. It is pointless, i might as well beat that dead horse until it is a bloody stump. I listed all my reasons in other threads, if he would like he could go ahead and find one of those and read through them, but seriously there is no point in getting over a argument over a opinion. I just don't have it in me right now.
Huh. What do you know. I didn't hold the trigger long enough to hear that. I shot Danny too. But only because it was his idea! Which in hindsight kinda seems like a bad reason. But, eh. Justin still seemed cool.
3 full episodes yes.
But Clem has known them a week and we knew the rest a lot longer than that.
So there is going to be more character development in the first season because it was over a longer period of time,
How much do you want to know these people? We are still strangers and still in the weird stage of not trusting each other.
I have a habit of going into lost of detail but I was too lazy to do so this time. I don't understand how people can judge the current situation when the season isn't over. Go ahead and judge it when the season is finished, but its half a project, you can't criticize it yet!
I dome think people are grasping the difference of playing an adult and a child yet.
Things are going to be different, plus, we've know the cabin people just over a week, people can't really expect to know these people fully within a week, especially when its one thing after another, they haven't really had time yet and still don't trust each other enough yet.
Its still a pretty amazing game. Why don't we look at what they've achieved instead of what they haven't?
Out of curiosity, what are your reasons for disliking Kenny?
Iv not heard many bad opinions of him yet.
I agree. I preferred Shawn but I saved Duck because he was a child and when I had played it (when the game first came out), most people had done that too. I still stick to my choice, regardless of what the popular opinion is. In real life most would have saved the kid and anyway, as if you would choose not not save the child, but everyone is entitled to their own opinions and choices.
Not trusting Bonnie was not a popular opinion. I understand why completely, but for me, Clementine's perspective, she had not seen how Bonnie was before it all (400 days). I chose not to confide in her because even though she apologized, she knew exactly what she was doing when she came to the lodge in episode 2. How do people know that it's not the first time she has done this anyway? Carver clearly has found plenty of stray people and either convinced or forced them to join his camp. I accepted Bonny's apology, but she was still not someone to confide in imo.
By unpopular opininon I meant my sympathy for him.
The really depressing this is that I started liking him after he "died"
Not trying to defend Danny's actions, but I took him with me because he clearly had Vince's back. Justin just seemed really slimey, and the fact that he didn't want to intervene to save the other prisoner's life made me question how useful he would be in a tough situation. Danny is, most likely, a rapist, and that's obviously horrible. But he at least seemed to regret his crime, while Justin blatantly states that he has no regrets. So, from a survivalist's perspective, I felt like I had a better shot if I took Danny (btw Justin will abandon you if you choose him, which kind of proves my point about him having no loyalty).
Alright, As you wish. Though I'd like to hear why you like him.
I see. My apologizes.
You have a point, But that Choice was like choosing between Carver or Crawford. I'd certainly go with Carver.
I didn't trust her either. She could have been working undercover for Carver.
Prepare your anus...
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
I didn't cry once while playing TWDG.
Me Neither. I raged fiercely after Carley's death on twitter though.
But I was more connected to the S1 cast by the end of Ep 1. That's 2 days compared to the ''week'' and 3 eps we knew the S2 cast.
Dont try to justify that shit, you know thats bad but you dont wanna be wrong.
I cried twice. This game brings too many feels.
I better jump out that window too. I didn't cry either.
Carley strikes me as a Mary Sue and while she does have her share of good lines/moments, her character doesn't really get fleshed out as much as Doug. Taking Doug along also changes the way you view Lily, because she accidentally kills him in an attempt to execute Ben, whereas gunning down Carley can only be chalked up cold-blooded murder.
Nope. I've never seen her in that way. Maybe Because I always prefer badass female characters. I liked Doug, He's a tech geek, So am I. But I liked Carley more because she could handle herself.
This is not season 1. This is season 2. They are different, you are now playing as a child, they are trying to show how hard it has been and still is to survive in a world that's gone to hell. Its one string of events after another.
Separated from Christa and attacked, bitten by a dog, met new people, locked in a shed, fixed your own arm, attacked at the stream, Carvers arrival, on the run from Carver, attacked by walkers on the bridge, went to the lodge, met Kenny, then realise you killed Walters friend, then the wind turbines go mental, then attacked by walkers, then Carver shows up, holds everyone hostage, takes them back to the camp, then your put onto a prison, and are on the look out for an escape plan, see Sarah get slapped by her dad, see Reggie being pushed off a roof, forced in to work, Luke shows up, you steal a walkie talkie, try to get it to Luke, then Carver finds your plan, beats the crap out of Kenny, then you escape through the heard.
I would be really interested in all of that, where you see fit to walk around and get to know people, especially since everyone now has a wall up that's sky high. Like in season 1. But remember this isn't season 1, its season 2. Things are different considering its been going on for about 3 years now. People wont act the same way to new people after 3 years like they did in the first couple go days onto the put break.
As I said before, read my other comment below, I listed reasons that I think are there to respect and care for the characters. They've done it subtle, between the lines. You have to read in between the lines, you can't expect everything to be there for you. Considering the circumstances.
Wait until the season is over then make your judgement,
Okay.... why is the first paragraph like that?
WAIT FOR ME.
Exactly! I was amazed how many told her about Luke.