Just a quick thing I wanted to point out. Back in "All That Remains," Sarah mentioned that her dad was trying to restock on their medical supplies. Do you think that the group might have stolen some of the Howe's Communities supplies before leaving? It would add another reason why Carver said tensions might be high at the camp and why Bonnie said there are no saints in all of it.
It's a possibility, we just have no idea what Carlos exactly had to stitch Clementine's arm. When she went looking for supplies to stich her arm in "All That Remains", Sarah was the one who had access to it and gave a bottle of disinfectant to her.
When they left Carver's community, it wouldn't surprise me if he actually did steal some medical supplies along the way. He was the only doctor after all, he probably had easy access to it and made off with some of it.
Now that he's dead, we'll probably never know for sure. The other possibility is that Sarah was talking about her dad scavenging for medical supplies around the area. Which would be understandable as they are survivors after all.
Just a quick thing I wanted to point out. Back in "All That Remains," Sarah mentioned that her dad was trying to restock on their medical s… moreupplies. Do you think that the group might have stolen some of the Howe's Communities supplies before leaving? It would add another reason why Carver said tensions might be high at the camp and why Bonnie said there are no saints in all of it.
Didn't Bonnie or Rebecca say something about George in determinant dialogue choices? Like, they implied that Alvin only killed him because George was in Alvin's way when he was escaping?
Well to be completely honest, I'm not surprised that Kenny survived (too much at least). They did the same thing for Tyreese in the comic book. He was surrounded by tens of walkers in a rather small room armed only with his hammer, everyone thought he died but he appeared unharmed.
The problem is that that's what people have been saying and hoping for over and over again and it just never happens. Kenny's unrealistic su… morervival being completely unexplained, just as one example, was also passed over with the excuse that they wouldn't just leave that thread in the air. "You all say it's bad writing, but they're obviously going to explain it in the next episode! They're not just going to leave it like that!" And lo and behold, they just left it like that.
Personally, I highly doubt they're going to explain all the backstory people are asking for, given the time limit and all the stuff they're already going to be working on for that episode, but I actually don't really mind. As critical as I've been in the past, I don't feel like there's any real unanswered questions regarding Carver. There seemed to be during episode 2, but since Carver turned out to be a one-note bad guy, there's no longer any ambiguity about things like… [view original content]
Actually, unused audio implies that Rebecca was raped, but might have also been having an affair (maybe she didn't want it to go that far, but Carver did not listen.) I think the audio went something like "No matter what you say I know you wanted it as much as I did" or something?? Which sounds awfully bad, and sounds like an implication of rape to me. It was in the final scene of his I think, or was meant to be. But, it being cut out could mean it's 'noncanon'?? Who really knows.
Actually, unused audio implies that Rebecca was raped, but might have also been having an affair (maybe she didn't want it to go that far, b… moreut Carver did not listen.) I think the audio went something like "No matter what you say I know you wanted it as much as I did" or something?? Which sounds awfully bad, and sounds like an implication of rape to me. It was in the final scene of his I think, or was meant to be. But, it being cut out could mean it's 'noncanon'?? Who really knows.
To me it doesn't imply rape...It just means that she wasn't completely sure of it at the time but ended up cheating on Alvin anyway. Carver's just implying that she's lying when she's saying that she didn't enjoy it or regretted it.
Actually, unused audio implies that Rebecca was raped, but might have also been having an affair (maybe she didn't want it to go that far, b… moreut Carver did not listen.) I think the audio went something like "No matter what you say I know you wanted it as much as I did" or something?? Which sounds awfully bad, and sounds like an implication of rape to me. It was in the final scene of his I think, or was meant to be. But, it being cut out could mean it's 'noncanon'?? Who really knows.
Once again, I doubt that Rebecca got raped, her attitude towards Carver is hostile, but not enough for a woman who got raped, most likely they had an affair and she regrets the whole ordeal. Carver changed along the way, that's a fact, he probably wasn't like this at first, but the control of a community and safety of his own group twisted his point of view of the new world the apocalypse created.
A dog eat dog world, a world where only the strong survives and if there's a weakling among them, it might mean the downfall of his society. Like I reiterated, his community was attacked by hordes of walkers before and something happened, in my opinion someone who he would consider a weak member of his community put all of them at risk and Carver had to deal with the consequences.
Which would in turn explain why he doesn't tolerate weakness anymore. He simply went over the egde and became obsessed with his idea of a perfect community made only of strong willed people. The others only jeopardize his plans.
O-O I must unread that
RAPE SARAH AND CARVER WTF!! If S2 did that I wouldn't play another telltale game again thankfully they never used that it's just sick
Comments
Just a quick thing I wanted to point out. Back in "All That Remains," Sarah mentioned that her dad was trying to restock on their medical supplies. Do you think that the group might have stolen some of the Howe's Communities supplies before leaving? It would add another reason why Carver said tensions might be high at the camp and why Bonnie said there are no saints in all of it.
It's a possibility, we just have no idea what Carlos exactly had to stitch Clementine's arm. When she went looking for supplies to stich her arm in "All That Remains", Sarah was the one who had access to it and gave a bottle of disinfectant to her.
When they left Carver's community, it wouldn't surprise me if he actually did steal some medical supplies along the way. He was the only doctor after all, he probably had easy access to it and made off with some of it.
Now that he's dead, we'll probably never know for sure. The other possibility is that Sarah was talking about her dad scavenging for medical supplies around the area. Which would be understandable as they are survivors after all.
This is one of the best thread I ever seen do more just fascinating nice share
Didn't Bonnie or Rebecca say something about George in determinant dialogue choices? Like, they implied that Alvin only killed him because George was in Alvin's way when he was escaping?
Well to be completely honest, I'm not surprised that Kenny survived (too much at least). They did the same thing for Tyreese in the comic book. He was surrounded by tens of walkers in a rather small room armed only with his hammer, everyone thought he died but he appeared unharmed.
Well thank you Markd
And thank you also for reviving this thread who has been buried under all the other nonsense of this forum xD
Actually, unused audio implies that Rebecca was raped, but might have also been having an affair (maybe she didn't want it to go that far, but Carver did not listen.) I think the audio went something like "No matter what you say I know you wanted it as much as I did" or something?? Which sounds awfully bad, and sounds like an implication of rape to me. It was in the final scene of his I think, or was meant to be. But, it being cut out could mean it's 'noncanon'?? Who really knows.
O-O I must unread that
RAPE SARAH AND CARVER WTF!! If S2 did that I wouldn't play another telltale game again thankfully they never used that it's just sick
This thread! I love it when people gather small details to connect the dots, as I like to say small details make things greater.
To me it doesn't imply rape...It just means that she wasn't completely sure of it at the time but ended up cheating on Alvin anyway. Carver's just implying that she's lying when she's saying that she didn't enjoy it or regretted it.
Once again, I doubt that Rebecca got raped, her attitude towards Carver is hostile, but not enough for a woman who got raped, most likely they had an affair and she regrets the whole ordeal. Carver changed along the way, that's a fact, he probably wasn't like this at first, but the control of a community and safety of his own group twisted his point of view of the new world the apocalypse created.
A dog eat dog world, a world where only the strong survives and if there's a weakling among them, it might mean the downfall of his society. Like I reiterated, his community was attacked by hordes of walkers before and something happened, in my opinion someone who he would consider a weak member of his community put all of them at risk and Carver had to deal with the consequences.
Which would in turn explain why he doesn't tolerate weakness anymore. He simply went over the egde and became obsessed with his idea of a perfect community made only of strong willed people. The others only jeopardize his plans.
Why thank you for the kind comment sir or madam :P
Be sure to share your insight on the story if you get the chance or if you wish to do so.
Meh. Meh. Meh. Meh. Meh. MEH! MEH! MEH! MEH! MEH! MEH! MEH! MEH! MEH!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MocwAfCa1RM
ok....I suppose that makes sense...xD wait what ?! >.<