›

Season 1 vs. Season 2

ralo229ralo229
in The Walking Dead

Which one these elements did each season do better than the other.

Story: Tie

Characters: Season 1

Graphics: Tie

Writing: Season 1

Gameplay: Season 1

Protagonist: Season 2

Antagonist: Season 1

Music: Season 2

Action: Season 2

What do you think?

Comments

  • DoubleJumpDoubleJump

    I agree with everything except for the graphics and animation in season two seem to look way cleaner, crisp, and more fluid compared to season one. The gameplay is better in season 2 due to the most amazing hold the "slightly walk faster" button.

  • BourbonTeacupBourbonTeacup

    Antagonist is a tough one, because Carver would be better than the stranger if there was more build up and he was the proper villain, but the season hasn't ended yet so I think it's harder to judge, althouh IMO Ep 3 of S1 blew out S2's EP3 by fudging miles.

  • BubadooBubadoo

    Story: Tie

    Characters: S1

    Graphics: S2

    Writing: S1

    Gameplay: S1

    Protagonist: Tie

    Antagonist: S1

    Music: S2

    Action: S2

  • ralo229ralo229

    Yeah Carver had the potential to be the best antagonist of the franchise, but he was killed off too early and he wasn't developed quite enough.

    BourbonTeacup posted: »

    Antagonist is a tough one, because Carver would be better than the stranger if there was more build up and he was the proper villain, but th

  • ShubbalubbadingdongShubbalubbadingdong
    edited June 2014

    I feel like S1 didn't have one antagonist. There were the St. John brothers, the bandits, and the stranger. S2 seems to be heading in this direction also because they killed Carver off so early. But on the topic of which have been more dangerous, I have to say Carver because he had an "army" behind him, whether when it came down to just Lee v. St John brothers or Lee v. the stranger it was just the two of them.

    ralo229 posted: »

    Yeah Carver had the potential to be the best antagonist of the franchise, but he was killed off too early and he wasn't developed quite enough.

  • Blind SniperBlind Sniper Moderator
    edited June 2014

    Story: Season 1

    Characters: Tie

    Graphics: Season 2

    Writing: Season 1

    Gameplay: Season 1

    Protagonist: Season 1

    Antagonist: Season 2

    Music: Season 2

    Action: Season 2

  • deleted46083694deleted46083694

    Story: Season 1.

    Atmosphere: Season 2.

    Characters: Season 1.

    Graphics: Season 2.

    Writing: Season 2.

    Gameplay: Season 1.

    Protagonist: Season 2.

    Antagonist: Tie.

    Music: Season 2.

    Action: Season 2.

  • NamelessAceNamelessAce
    edited June 2014

    Story: 1

    Atmosphere: 2

    Characters: 1

    Graphics: 2

    Writing: 1

    Gameplay: 2

    Protagonist: 1 (by a slight margin)

    Antagonist: 1 (multiple antagonists)

    Music: 2

    Action: 2

  • BenUsefulBenUseful

    Season 1 wins in everything but cosmetics(graphics/music) and (arguably) action.

Sign in to comment in this discussion.