Saving her Hat, or a group member?
Hey guys,
So I was just thinking of how I would do whatever to make sure Clementine never loses her hat. But what if the group is surrounded by walkers,mor in the middle of a herd, and Clementines hat falls off and she finds it? But the same time another character is grabbed by a walker. Do you forget the hat and run to save the group member, or do you go for the hat instead and let the group member be killed?
I would save the member depending on who it is. If it's someone I don't like I would go for the hat instead and let them be eaten. What about you guys?
Would you let someone be killed just to keep the hat? And in the end Clementine will have to face the consequences...
Luke: "YOU LET BONNIE GET EATEN JUST FOR THAT STUPID HAT?! You could have saved her!!"
Thoughts?
Comments
Group member.
Anybody who saves a hat over someone's life deserves to be chewed out afterwards.
...really? No offense, but this is a human life being compared with a hat. I'd easily save the group member every time.
Group member. I'd be very concerned if there was actually a percentage of people that took the hat, even with its emotional value...
Group member of course. Yeah the hat has sentimental value, but a human life is something you cant replace.
Luke: You could've saved Nick!? Why'd you just let him die for a stupid hat?
Clementine: He knocked my hat off.
Depends. Mostly it'll be the hat, Except if Jane or kenny were the ones on stake.
Word to the wise right there.
You can always come back later and get the hat then. The walkers will probalby just leave it lying around there
same goes for the mutilated remains of the group member. either way it's win-win!
Most defiantly save the group member, however i may change my mind if its Jane, shes a lone wolf who will most likely betray the group and leave us for dead to save her own skin, now not saying I would leave every lone wolf, i mean its just Jane's character, i mean Molly was a lone wolf but despite us trying to kill her she still saved our lives, she EASILY could have left and through the balcony she jumped on and decided to forget about us, but she had a heart and saved us, Jane on the other hand has only shown she cares about saving her own hide, the only reason she helped us is because she saw a way for her to save her own ass
Like Gunab said, I would save the group member then get the hat.
It's an interesting scenario, but i'd obviously choose the group member... that's if it was Bonnie... I wonder if there could be a choice between a hated character or the hat? Hmm...
Dpeends which group member.
Anyway, if Clem does lose her hat, she'd better get a new one.
A bobblehat or something.
If Rebeca, Sarah, Kenny or Luke was being grabbed, then yeah I would pick group member
But if it was Mike or Jane then I'd rather choose the hat
It depends on the group member. I'd drop all my shit just to save Nick, Mike, or someone else who I care about.
Jane...?
lolno
He's... Y'know... Urban?
Why Mike? I understand Jane but whats wrong with Mike?
Group member. Even if that group member is an asshole, I won't leave him/her behind. It's a tough choice if you look at Clementine's perspective. It's more than just hat for her and for US! But I don't need some items that reminds me of the people in my life. Their good or bad memories I had with them what makes them unforgettable for me. Is leaving that hat behind will make me feel hurt? I'm gonna earn tons of downvotes but... NO!! Because I will be happy knowing that I left that hat behind for saving someone. Giving him/her chance to see the tomorrow.
It depends i rank it like this
Group Member.
I would save the group member. I mean its just a hat. Walkers wouldnt even care for it.
Most people already said what I woulda said.
Group member.
Now if it was a choice between Clementine's hat, Nick's hat or Kenny's hat, then we'd have a real debate going on.
Nick doesn't have a hatless model, so one would assume his hat is actually a growth on his head, so thus, losing Nick's hat would be extremely painful for him, perhaps even resulting in brain damage and death.
Any person with morals would save Nick's hat. He'd die without it.
if it was Rebecca i might have to think twice
I'd probably save the group member but that would make them determinant so their gonna die eventually anyway. So would you rather save the person who's just gonna die next episode or your super cool looking hat?
Clem looks badass without her hat so I would choose the group option
Depends on the group member. If it's somebody I don't care about, then the hat is more valuable to me.
Um...if she lost her hat in the horde, she could just save the group member, get out of the horde, wait a while, then go back and grab the hat once the walkers cleared out. It's not like the hat's going to turn or something.
And anyone who wants to save everyone is a blind idealistic.
You prefer a hat over every single human being except for Clem and Ken? Oh dear, now I feel even more ashamed of being a fan of Kenny.
You're clearly given a choice between saving someone's life and.. a hat.
Yes, the hat has emotional value but it's not alive. It's not someone who cares for you or would be willing to save your life if you were in danger. It's not a bad thing to want to save someones life. A hat would do absolutely nothing for you in the long run, sorry.
Wait, so someone who would rather save a human life than an inanimate object is a blind idealistic? Sounds logical.
Lmao that's like asking if you'd save Kenny's stache or Kenny himself. XD Of course I'd save the group member.
Obviously you're not a true Kenny fan if you're ashamed of being a fan of the best character of TWD. Come back when you've grown a godly mustache and beard then we'll talk.
Wouldn't the hat be determinant too?
I know this is dumb..HAT
Group member always.
Saving her hat or a group member? Psh... group member easily. Want a much harder question? Saving juice box or a group member?
Now that's a tough one.
IamJuicebox