Do we have to stay mad on Lilly?
WAIT BEFORE YOU THROW A SALTLICK AT ME AND PLEASE! PLEASE! UNDERSTAND
- Season 1 started two years ago.
- Lilly is not a monster for killing Carley/Doug there are people out there that are much worser.
I know it isn't much but I see still hate comments and wanted to talk about that downvote me all you want.
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
I'm really sorry bro but uhhh...:
Lilly killed Carley I can never forgive her.
Am I the only one who doesn't want her to return? I feel that her story arc is finished and just because you don't know someone died doesn't mean they'll definitely come back. I just think its a bit too unrealistic to have her come back.
I'm not mad a her, but I don't feel the need to see her again.
Hell yea I am sure still mad about her killing Carly, if Doug I won't be that mad since Doug saved Ben, still I am mad either way, I would forgive her if she realized what she did was wrong
Edit: Forget it. This forum obviously can't take a joke. I was just trying to make something funny out of this thread.
Yeah that is true... Lets leave the thread and make fun with the other users
You dare!
You can give this a ton of dislikes. But I'm not that mad at her anymore. I would be happy to see anyone from the old group, hell, even LARRY.
Me to
If she returned I'd still be mad at her but I'd give her a chance. She could be a useful group member
It's like 5 sentences, man...
People forget that Kenny was no hero either, he got mad because i dont just kill people, i try to save them and Larry was alive a second before kenny murdered him, when at the st johns, we had a plan to jump danny and when kenny saw me about to get shot he just watched and Lilly saved me, Kenny was also willing to let a girl suffer for his gain, well i guess he groups gain but even after a shot her and we had to leave faster, he agreed we still got lots of stuff
If she looks like she changed and is sorry about what she done. Otherwise.. Hell no..
This guy is an unsuccessful and annoying T R O L L
lets not forget Glenn , maybe he and Lilly found each other.. maybe not
Maybe Lilly is not a complete monster by ZA standards, but come on! Carley and Doug were well liked characters and valuable group members. Maybe if she had killed some random guy we didn't even know, then we could forgive her. And, to make matters worse, Carley's death is cold-blooded murder. Sure, it was an impulse and she was in a bad place, but it's still murder. At least Doug's death was an accident...
I don't know... Guess I could take her being back into the group at the very best, but I'll never forgive her. Regardless of the person she's become or what she does for Clem, I'll always remember what she did. That's a stain that's never coming out.
Glenn is in the comics and no sorry
yea about that.... he isn't coming back
I checked his account and that's not the feeling I got. Being a Lilly fan is not trolling. Or did he do or say something I don't know of?
Personally, I think it's better if we judge Lilly and Kenny separately. I know you had to pick sides in S1, but that's over. I noticed your post is almost entirely about Kenny (you mention Lilly once), but what do you think about Lilly's actions?
Personal choice i guess. I don't live with grudges, life is too short. I forgave her a long time ago.
Lilly's a good person in my books
She only killed Carley out of anger and in thinking she endangered the group (thought wrong) and she didn't mean to kill Doug
Between the end of Episode 1 and beginning of Episode 2 (3 months later) she managed to keep the group alive and safe within the Moter Inn by keeping her strict rationing and on a regular watch.
I kept her on the RV because I know she had lost everything and she was almost in tears after doing it, realizing what mistake she'd done. Yeah she reveals Lee's secret to the group, but it doesn't matter if you tell people anyway, she did no harm. And she even tells Lee at one point in Episode 2 "I'll keep Clementine safe" so I'm assuming that if you had a good relationship with her in Season 1, she will look out for Clementine in Season 2.
Kenny also states in Episode 3 of Season 1 that he doesn't distrust Lilly, so they would get along fine (Lilly also says "I forgave Lee, I can forgive you" about him smashing in her dad's head)
YES!
I'd assume that, if she is alive after 2 years in the ZA, Lilly has had time to seriously regret her actions, so maybe I'd hear her out. But I don't think I could ever trust her again, not after she killed Carley in cold blood (or tried to murder Ben in the other scenario).
While I sympathize with all that she went through (especially since I helped Kenny in the meat locker), it doesn't excuse what she did. And besides, the new group already has trouble getting along--no need to throw Lilly and her bitchy attitude into that.
I didn't feel right about abandoning Lilly, especially after what Kenny did to her father.
Tell you the truth, I feel more sorry for Lilly than anything. She clearly lost her mind. I don't want to see her back necessarily though. I'd much rather find out what happened to Christa.
Yeah
worse*
Her getting shot in the face for absolutely no reason under the guise of "protection" would be a fitting end to her though.
Who, me?
I ain't even mad tbh
Carley talks shit Carley gets hit dawg
She didn't have bad intentions but she is (or ends up being) a bad person IMO. Murder based on no evidence is never the actions of a good person regardless of what they've been through.
Its a sympathetic tale with what happens to her father, but she is dangerous by the time of episode 3 (and proves so by threatening you and stealing the RV if you take her with you)
She had a point Lee and Kenny killed and they were forgiven (Lily said to Kenny "I'll probably forgive you"). It's time to let go of the past.
Wait is this about saying that Lilly should be forgiven or they everyone should forget about it since it was so long ago? Not everyone would have played it the day it came out.
She hasn't appeared since, so i don't see how time somehow redeems her. The fact other characters are worse doesn't maker her better either.
oke so what is the chinese pizza delivery guy's name then?
he was in the game and went to find his friends he didn't die in the game...
I just finished the game but...are we supposed to be mad at Lilly? It was a crime of passion and I let her back on the RV.
I hope she shows back up.
Lilly killed Carley/Doug but EVERYONE was going through a bunch of PTSD at the time. They also just lost their home and everything they owned.
Yeah, it's horrible but my Lee was sympathetic since he ALSO committed a crime of passion.
Keep the save file for TWD 1 so if you get Season 2 you can import the Season 1 save file to Season 2 and play with your choices from Season 1 so they don't have to be randomly generated.
She may not be the worst out there, but she's a cold killer that didn't think before taking someone's life, fuck her and she deserved to be left on the road.