What do you think would have happened?
Let's say Clementine had put the radio in her other pocket. Maybe she tripped and it fell out, and she put it in the other pocket hastily as she went to look for Luke, and then the gets caught by Troy. He drags her back to their pen and Carver asks for the other radio and Kenny goes to grab it, but since it's in Clem's other pocket, he can't. Instead of Kenny giving Carver the radio, Clem does. What do you think would happen afterwards?
I'm gonna try to keep mine as brief as I can (since this entire thing happened in a dream a couple of days ago, and I'm curious to hear your thoughts), but I'm sorry if it gets a little long-winded. I also can't remember the majority of the dialogue that happened.
Clementine walks up and hands Carver the radio, Kenny and Luke both trying to stop her but held back by Troy pointing his gun at them. Clem has the option to say something (I don't remember what was said though, or what the choices were) and Carver looks down and raises an eyebrow before saying "three". He smacks her with the radio and Clem falls to the floor, losing her hat in the process. He starts spewing a speech and continuously asks Clem questions, with options for you to reply. Not long after, there's a quick event to try to run away, but Carver still manages to grab her and throws her back to the ground and kicks her in the ribs.
The rest of the group is yelling and screaming at him, and Troy's yelling at all of them to shut the fuck up or he'll shoot, and now Carver's demanding for Clem to stand up and look him in the eye. There's another event to get Clem standing, and then you get some more options to say to him (unfortunately, I don't remember what three were).
The "chosen" dialogue was: Fuck you.
Which really pissed Carver off because he grabbed Clem and threw her again, but she smacked her head on the side of one of the beds and fell unconscious. Bonnie runs in and yells that there's been a breach, so Carver and Troy leave and everyone rushes over to Clementine. Carlos does what he can, but Clem's in a coma for a couple of days. The group, even Kenny, does their best not to cause any fuss while doing work because both Carver and Troy reiterated many times that if there were anymore fuck-ups, they'd go right in and blow Clem's brains out. Maybe Sarah's too (since they let her stay and keep watch on Clem for whatever reason. It was really cute though, Sarah was recapping all the stories she's read to Clem.)
One night while discussing plans, Clementine walks over and pulls on Kenny's sleeve. She asks where Duck went because he took her walkie-talkie. She notices Mike and thinks he's Lee for a second before she goes wide-eyed and collapses.
And that's where my dream ended. Don't know if it'd actually happen, but that's what my brain said would. What do you guys think? What would have happened if the radio had been in Clem's other pocket?
Comments
I think Carver only beat up Kenny because of the "Heh. Fucker." comment. Kenny just HAD to get the last word in.
Wow that was such an awesome dream :O I would think Carver woulda just slapped Clementine and taught her a lesson some other way
He's an authoritarian. He demands respect, and I think he beat up Kenny to show how much it means to him. That comment was the last straw with all Kenny has done to anger Carver.
I don't believe so; Carver was going to beat up Kenny regardless. Kenny said "Heh, fucker." because he knew what was coming after Carver said "three".
Carver probably would have hit Clementine like he made Carlos hit Sarah. He certainly wouldn't have beaten her like he did Kenny. Even he probably isn't that disgusting a human being.
I've had many dreams of alternate Walking Dead scenarios, but I'm afraid I've lost em all to my mind. Cept this one. 8P
But yeah, looking past it, I can sure see Carver just slapping Clementine, possibly keeping her on a tighter watch and always being the one to keep an eye on her while she works.
Yeah, looking past the dream, I can really only see him slapping her or hitting her once with the radio then putting a very watchful eye on her.
Kenny is too stupid to know when to shut his mouth. He was already in deep trouble over the radio. This guy is a obvious nut job and Kenny goes out of his way to piss him off.
Well i do remember Carver saying this at the start of the episode "Well if you try to take my radio, I'll hurt you myself"
So i think he would have beat up Clem, just not as bad as he beat Kenny.
Kenny calls him that because Carver purposely says "three" the second before Kenny dropped the walkie-talkie in his hand, so he'd have an excuse to beat him senseless. When he says three, Kenny looks at Carver with this "oh come on!" expression on his face, and calls him a fucker for being so petty..
That's a cool dream, tbh. But yeah, Carver would have hurt Clem (HE SLAPPED MY CLEM AT THE BEGINNING OF THE EP AND I WAS FURIOUS) but not as badly as he hurt Kenny, both because he respects Clementine and because she's a little girl.
I will say that after watching the episode 4 preview (I chose to hide the radio, so Clem was like "if I had told Carver about the radio, he might not have been as vicious to-" and kenny was like "there's no telling what he would have done to you"), I thought that if you told about the radio, Clementine was the one to get beat up and so I immediately checked the forums. :O
Actually, Kenny drops the radio in the Carver's hands before he said three.
Click here
See. The radio was in Carver's hand before he counted to three.
I think Carver was going to beat Kenny regardless of the "heh, fucker" comment Kenny made. He needed to show the group that trying to escape and defying him would not go unpunished.