Luke Or Kenny

2

Comments

  • edited July 2014

    I choose both...I can't possibly choose just one of them. Luke is sweet, and I think he really cares for Clem in a brotherly way which is nice to see. But Kenny has cared for Clem since day 1 with Lee, and he seems to do whatever it takes to protect her. It's not always a good thing that Kenny does whatever it takes, but every time he protects her I just find it harder to choose...the way he kept telling Clem that it wasn't her fault in episode 3, and trying to make her feel better just made the choice impossible. I don't see Luke killing someone since he refused to even kill Carver, but Kenny would go to serious measures if anyone messed with Clem. You can tell they both care deeply for Clementine though, and I don't want to pick one over another, ever.

  • But Luke is weak willed (lily livered). He doesn't have as much passion for the things he does like Kenny. He's too afraid to seal the deal like when he couldn't kill Carver. But then again Kenny isn't perfect either as he is rash and his plans often involve a lot of risks. I would just go neutral and say Lee or Chuck would be the best IF they were still alive :,(

    Kennysucks posted: »

    but to be honest i have mixed feeling with Kenny, hes passionate about protecting his family/children, but he doesn't think things through,

  • edited July 2014

    Exactly. You transform the killing from that of justice bringing and necessity to one of anger and vengeance. That is something my Clem doesn't need. She needs a level headed "think before you act" personality to be her guardian (guardian used very loosely).

    Shooting, not even worth the bullet. Smashing his face out is much more satisfying and sends a stronger message. All the suffering he gave o

  • I choose Pete. With Christa as backup.

  • I choose not to choose.

    They're both great fellas, even though Luke has some running away issues.

  • Kenny all day err day. The same Kenny that was essentially a martyr at the end of season 1.

  • Well my Clem needs someone who can make the hard choices and show her how to survive in a world like this and how it works now. Vengeance is justice, I don't want someone who did all that shit to have a quick death, like I said, the situation would of been much, much worse for Carver if I was Kenny. You can't just give people like that a merciful death and be done with it, you need to make them feel the pain and suffering they caused to others. Sparing him or shooting him in the head is just too 'white knight'. Sometimes you need to let the monster inside of you loose to kill another monster.

    Viva-La-Lee posted: »

    Exactly. You transform the killing from that of justice bringing and necessity to one of anger and vengeance. That is something my Clem doe

  • Well my Clem needs someone who can make the hard choices and show her how to survive in a world like this and how it works now.

    My Clem had this figured out long ago.

    Vengeance is justice, I don't want someone who did all that shit to have a quick death, like I said, the situation would of been much, much worse for Carver if I was Kenny.

    Those are not the same. One is for the overall good. The other is for the appeasement of the sole. Killing him is justice, the way it was done was vengeful. Don't confuse the two. You may have done worse to him, it's understandable that you would want to. But that doesn't make it "right," and far from just a just act.

    You can't just give people like that a merciful death and be done with it

    Says you. Which is why I would prefer Luke over Kenny and apparently (no offense intended, honestly) you.

    you need to make them feel the pain and suffering they caused to others.

    Why? Does it help them? Does it make them feel better? (Thrm being the "others.") No. It helps you feel better. It helps you cope and it helps your anger. It is much harder to do the just thing rather than the vengeful thing.

    Sparing him or shooting him in the head is just too 'white knight'. Sometimes you need to let the monster inside of you loose to kill another monster.

    I'll just rebuttal to the end of that. "You need to let the monster inside of you loose to kill another monster." No. Shooting him in the head would have the same outcome as viciously smashing his face in. He dies. The only difference is the manner of his demise.

    Well my Clem needs someone who can make the hard choices and show her how to survive in a world like this and how it works now. Vengeance is

  • Ok, well as always I appreciate your thought on the matter and I can kinda see where you are coming from but what would you of done? In all honesty. You can say "I'll be the bigger man and walk away or mercy kill him" but c'mon. That guy NEEDS to feel all the shit that he did to other people. By doing that to him you are not just satisfying your own needs of vengeance, you are bringing justice and avenging all those that have fallen by Carver's hand. In all honesty me and Kenny know what we are doing, killing a tyrant, showing Clem how the world works and that vengeance is just human emotion and nothing to be ashamed of.

    Viva-La-Lee posted: »

    Well my Clem needs someone who can make the hard choices and show her how to survive in a world like this and how it works now. My Cle

  • I guess it depends on the relationship you build with Kenny since the very beginning of S1. If you built a good relationship with Kenny while playing as Lee, you feel more attached to him and will probably chose him over Luke. But if you never got along with Kenny in S1, you will probably already feel more attached to Luke in only 3 episodes.

  • You and Kenny are showing Clem that being violent is the proper way to deal with problems. He doesn't NEED to do anything but die so that he is no longer and threat. So I'm not sure you saying that you and Kenny know what you're doing (implying you know the correct way to handle the situstion) is at all correct. I can honestly say I would have killed him. I would have ended his tyrannical reign. Not shown Clem how to prolong a bloody death.

    In fact I might refer you back to Sam. Perhaps Sam's death onscreen (or lack thereof) is prelude to this event. Killing the person/thing that hurt you, or killing it through prolonged, painful experience.

    Ok, well as always I appreciate your thought on the matter and I can kinda see where you are coming from but what would you of done? In all

  • PS- My Clem chose the just thing to do and put Sam down, not the revenge driven choice of leaving Sam to die. I apply this sensibility to Carver.

    Viva-La-Lee posted: »

    You and Kenny are showing Clem that being violent is the proper way to deal with problems. He doesn't NEED to do anything but die so that he

  • You're soft, so is Luke. You can't express anger or any emotion in this world. You need to satisfy yourself and your anger sometimes. It CAN and WILL benefit yourself and the group as a whole. Its for the best, and Carver deserved every last shred of it. It ain't easy in this world anyway, you think Carver would give you a easy death? Fuck no. The guy would of prolonged it as much as possible, you should think about doing the same to that bastard. Just because its inhumane, doesn't make it wrong. In fact, killing Carver was morally right, drawing out his death is right, everything about making Carver suffer is right.

    Viva-La-Lee posted: »

    You and Kenny are showing Clem that being violent is the proper way to deal with problems. He doesn't NEED to do anything but die so that he

  • My Lee was pretty much Luke in a nutshell, I didn't kill anyone if it wasn't required and i wouldn't let anyone die, in fact i showed Kenny up by being a bigger man, Kenny had left me to die more than one time and at the start of S1E4 when he got grabbed by a walker i didn't hesitate to save him

    I guess it depends on the relationship you build with Kenny since the very beginning of S1. If you built a good relationship with Kenny whil

  • edited July 2014

    I'm soft because I have the wherewithal to not confuse justice/necessity and anger/vengeance?

    Due to the nature of the last part of your post (increased aggressiveness and directive coupled with dogmatic statements) I'm going to end it here with a final few words. My Clem isn't looking for someone to show her how to kill and how the world is brutal now. She gets that. She's seen that. She's lived that. She needs someone to help her maintain her individuality, compassion, and peace. Something Kenny just isn't doing by making people "suffer" and calling it "right."

    You're soft, so is Luke. You can't express anger or any emotion in this world. You need to satisfy yourself and your anger sometimes. It CAN

  • Well ok then, you keep believing that. I'll believe my philosophy. Mine is right in my eyes, yours is right in your eyes. All I'll say is some people cloud justice with morals. At some point you just have to let go of them and move on, the world is in a shit state, you need to just deal with it. You can't adapt if you hold on to the past, hold on to humanity.

    Viva-La-Lee posted: »

    I'm soft because I have the wherewithal to not confuse justice/necessity and anger/vengeance? Due to the nature of the last part of your

  • By that logic, isn't Carver completely in the right? Anyeays. Been fun :)

    Well ok then, you keep believing that. I'll believe my philosophy. Mine is right in my eyes, yours is right in your eyes. All I'll say is so

  • edited July 2014

    But some people. Some people are just wrong all together. Like Carver ;3

    And of course, been fun :D

    Viva-La-Lee posted: »

    By that logic, isn't Carver completely in the right? Anyeays. Been fun

  • That sounds like a fun mini-game.

    Fizzdar posted: »

    Any determinant will die, as well as children, except Clem. The protagonist won't di- oh wait... Anyway, you and I are going to catch som

  • I don't get how Clementine has a bigger relationship with Kenny when in Season 1 they hardly ever spoke. The reason being he wants to protect her so much is because Clementine reminds him of Duck. And since he found his own little Katjaa replacement, he feels as if he has a family again.

    The whole putting her in the shed thing was Carlos' idea. Luke didn't want to go along with it, but he had to since he didn't want to risk the safety of the group.

    When Lee was bit Kenny never rejected Lee and helped him get Clementine back

    Uhm, no. Kenny has the option to go with you or not, depending on LEE'S actions. If Lee wasn't agreeing with Kenny, Kenny would let Clementine possibly die just because he didn't like how Lee disagreed with him.

    I choose Kenny because even though Luke is nice and he cares about Clementine, she's got a bigger relationship with Kenny and he's a connection to the past.

  • To me, it's like choosing between a good uncle and a good brother.

    Kenny/Lee posted: »

    I'd say Kenny. My Lee and him were pals! And seeing Kenny's fatherly affection for Clementine, I want those two to stay together. Clementine needs that in her life.

  • Nice picture of Kenny.
    I like it.

  • I see what you're saying.
    And I agree, it could be a very tough choice.

    To me, it's like choosing between a good uncle and a good brother.

  • Except the brother isn't really your brother, and he's fairly hot for an animated character.

    what.

    Kenny/Lee posted: »

    I see what you're saying. And I agree, it could be a very tough choice.

  • edited July 2014

    I agree with shubbalubbadingdong, your relationship with kenny in S1 is a big factor...

    My lee got on with kenny a lot and were bro's all the way through, ive often thought about doing a play through with me not liking kenny but I love him now so its to late lol, S1 would feel veeeeerrrrry lonely with him not onside..

    I think i would choose kenny, but the perfect combination would be luke AND kenny, kenny as we know has a hot head at times but has the balls when poo hits the fan, luke is a good thinker but is reluctant to put his neck on the line when it matters....

    Ive just started s2, finished ep2 last night, when I saw kenny I was going nuts lol, great to have him back......

  • I think you described them both very well.
    They're relationship, and personality differences, remind me of Spock and McCoy on Star Trek.

    Craticus posted: »

    I agree with shubbalubbadingdong, your relationship with kenny in S1 is a big factor... My lee got on with kenny a lot and were bro's all

  • Kenny is way too rash with his decisions IMO. I like luke, he's nice.

  • As much as I like Luke, I just can't let Kenny die.

  • I agree luke is a great guy, if I was to choose between kenny or luke for a weeks vacation then luke is your man unless your jnto bar fights, but this isnt a vacation this is a ZA and its all down to survival.

    Im not into raming a pitch fork into a mans chest or allowing someone to smash a mans head in with saltlick, in normal circumstances this is not good stuff, especially infront of a minor, but this isn't a normal situation.

    Kenny is way too rash with his decisions IMO. I like luke, he's nice.

  • well because if TellTale choice to put a scene were you have to save Luke Or Kenny you have to choice one

  • I choose Clementine not having to rely on someone else to keep her safe, thank you very much.

  • I have to choose Kenny, mostly because we don't really know much about Luke right now, my vote may change as the episodes are released, but Kenny was with us in the beginning, he is definitely a major protagonist or antagonist (determinant) of the game

  • edited July 2014

    Fair enough but Kenny was not my friend in any way at all and he still chose to go with me. So you're wrong about that. Maybe, but if you in real life really feel conflicted about being with someone you've known for months and someone you've known for three days, then that's just you.
    I didn't feel conflicted, it's just my opinion. I don't really care how many dislikes I get. I still prefer Kenny.

    I don't get how Clementine has a bigger relationship with Kenny when in Season 1 they hardly ever spoke. The reason being he wants to protec

  • Kenny did scold Clementine for talking about Duck in episode 3 of Season 1...

    I don't get how Clementine has a bigger relationship with Kenny when in Season 1 they hardly ever spoke. The reason being he wants to protec

  • Okay, scolding. Meaning he didn't like what she said. I still don't get how that paints the big picture of them having a 'bigger relationship'.

    prink34320 posted: »

    Kenny did scold Clementine for talking about Duck in episode 3 of Season 1...

  • I agree Luke is smart but Kenny is trustworthy he will sacrifice his life he did it for Ben and he would do it for Clem, Luke I don't know if he will sacrifice himself.

    prink34320 posted: »

    I have to choose Kenny, mostly because we don't really know much about Luke right now, my vote may change as the episodes are released, but

  • I think Kenny was always protective to Clementine yes she reminds him of Duck but he was always protective of Clementine even in season 1 Kenny went to look for her at the end.

    I don't get how Clementine has a bigger relationship with Kenny when in Season 1 they hardly ever spoke. The reason being he wants to protec

  • Kenny and Me!

  • ErykaEryka Banned

    Kenny he's coming to be crazy (if in the 4 episodes he is "normal" looks like the season one I choose her) and Luke is more young and I have to give her a chance to live more years then Ken

Sign in to comment in this discussion.