Where Was The OTHER Walkie Talkie ?!
Well as you can see when clem got the radio someone had the other walkie talkie but Luke didnt have them because we didnt give it to them
I SAY THERE IS A TRAITOR
And Why the hell does this choice appears when you interact with kenny "Did you know about this" ? WTF
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
the other walkie talkie was probably hidden?
No, we didn't give Luke the radio. We never had a chance to.
because.... why?
You're asking Kenny if he knew they captured Luke the other night.
It was probably like this: they found Luke, and then Luke had to say the plan, then they gave Carver the walkie-talkie, and then Carver called everybody and then asked for the other walkie-talkie.
But Luke never got a walkie-talkie, unless he stole another himself. Clem took two, and after that only one was ever referenced. She took two, only showed one to Kenny, and then that one was on the table the next morning. We have no idea what happened to the other one.
Somebody was probably given the other one to communicate with Luke (ex. Carlos (idk though)) but one of the guards or Carver discovered that walkie-talkie and took it away, and found Luke around the same time.
The only walkie-talkie that was really important to the storyline and Clem was the one that they had to take to Luke and later be taken by Carver
Because we didn't give Luke a radio, but when Carver caught Luke and call everyone, he's already hold a walkie-talkie in his hand
I assume they kept the first radio hidden somewhere in the camp, maybe under a blanket or pillow, or in that fish statue thing. They didn't have much need to have it on-hand until they gave the other radio to Luke.
I was thinking about this, too.
Clementine got two walkie talkies, so where did the other one go? Who had it? Did they hide it somewhere, and when the guards found Luke trying to steal food, he had to tell them the plan?
Idk... probably the walkie talkie was hidden somewhere.
When Carver's men caught Luke, they searched the place and probably found the poorly hidden walkie talkie. No need for a traitor to explain how this walkie talkie was ended up in Carver's hands. Also, wouldn't they have discussed a traitor that night if they had any reason to believe there was one?
THEN WHO WAS THE PHONE!?
Yea that makes sense, like they probably hid it somewhere around their little camp but after the guards caught Luke, they searched the camp area to find any evidence that they were trying to escape (or something).
heh heh.
my guess is that they would have had to have hidden the one they were planning to keep. given the way sarah's reacted to lying in the past (with the photo) i'd be inclined to blame her.
No, I highly doubt Sarah would tell Carver the plan.
I SAY Sarah When Riggie Died you can see Carver Was talking to her Maybe Because her Weakness He got to her and made her talk
unless you want to blame jane, that just leaves the cabin group. alvin had no idea so we can rule him out. nick was dead for half the people, so it wouldn't have been him. so we're down to luke, carlos, rebecca, or sarah. in the right circumstances, any could have. carlos to keep sarah from being hurt, sarah with her honesty issue (the photo and with sarah tellin reggie you dont trust him), rebecca may have tried to placate carver after he showed up with luke in the hopes of "sparing" them, or luke may have had second thoughts about the plan itself after capture and the only reason he didn't say anything about the second one was that clem might have had the counterpart. jane seemed rather eager to get the hell out, so i doubt she would have ruined things.
i still say sarah is the weak link.
Didn't that happen before Clementine even saw Luke yet? They had no plan or radio then, so Sarah had nothing to tell.
Do You remmeber The Sence When Kenny Asks Clem " So Did You Get it " if u wait a bit You can See Sarah Say " Come on clem dont make us Waiting " <<< Something like that
I don't think it was Rebecca, she's the first person to vote for the plan.
I'm pretty sure Sarah is scared shitless of Carver, so she'd want to get out of there.
Carlos wouldn't have done it since he wanted to get out of there too, and for the protection of his daughter
I think Luke did by force, and Carver found the walkie talkie somewhere.
That happened after Carver killed Reggie and talked to Sarah on the roof, though. Afterwards Clementine goes downstairs and is sent to give nails to Kenny and Mike, and after she's done in there, Luke drags her into the comic store and asks for the radio. Sarah had no knowledge of the plan until later that night.