Problems with the whole Story
Sooo we found out georgie killed lily and faith (if it's faith, i don't really get that). But in the open arms there's a friggin' room full of blood. Why would georgie kill her there? And don't give me that "he was framing crane" shit, cause if he really wanted to frame crane he wouldn't have let you smash up his whole club before givin you the book with the appointments. He'd just say: "go to the fuckin open arms, there are these bitches and their clients"
And why is there so much blood in the room? When vivian killed herself there was just a small puddle of blood. And i suppose crane knew about it, cause he was hanging with crooked man so he must've noticed him wanting them dead. So why didn't he run to the open arms and took away the evidence of him fucking lily? And if georgie killed her in that room, why was the key by cranes desk at the business office? And if they were working together we're back at the question why crane didn't take away the evidence.
This all doesn't add up for me..
Leave your thoughts in the comments i'm curious how you think about it.
And i'm german so don't kill me 'cause of my bad english please.
Comments
(((But in the open arms there's a friggin' room full of blood)))
if nerrisa was the one putting the heads on bigby's doorstep wouldn't she also but the one who put the blood all over that room
since she had access to both faith and Lillys bodies
think about it she was the one who gave you that key and made sure your found room 207 plus why would crane or georgie be stupid enough to leave that "picture" in a room full of blood as evidence lol
nerrisa wanted to motivate bigby to stop the crooked man so staging a fake crime scene and then planting the picture of crane and Lilly would have pointed bigby at crane and eventually the crooked man
How often did Crane get a massage? Its quite possible Lily stayed in room 207 after Crane left one night and it was staged. The lock was adulterated so the key won't work. Crane was probably such a regular he kept the key with him always? Georgie was in such a denial about the deaths, I'm not even sure he did do it. It was almost like Vivian knew Georgie was taking the fall erroneously. We don't know Lily's personality. Nerissa was portrayed timidly. So we don't know.
At my current level of understanding of the story there are still many elements that just don’t make any sense to me.
I can take great liberties with the story and put together these incongruent facts and create my own interpretation of events (which I have done so) I just have no faith in my ultimate conclusion which is disheartening.
That is why I would have liked events better spelled out (hopeful they will do this in a DLC).
(((To have Nerissa acquire and then deliver a head to the Woodland without stirring suspicion seems improbable to me)))
it's not improbable at all she has a big bag at the end of the game she could use that to transport the head without stirring suspicion
(((Why just leave the photos lying on the floor, burn them and be done with them)))
Nerissa wants to set up crane that's why she left the photos lying on the floor
(((We also have the issue of all these covert photos being taken))
blood mary could have taken them since see seems to be very good at being invisible lol
plus there tons of photos are located in the place that you find her
I appreciate your response.
Georgie just kills Faith, presumably right in front of Nerrisa. I presume Georgie would dispose of or secure the body until which time you can dispose of it. How does Nerrisa get the head, and why doesn’t Georgie seem to ever notice that it is missing. Repeat this for whoever (likely Nerrisa) stole Lily’s head.
Nerrisa recreated the conditions of the crime scene with a gallon of blood and the photos? The door also had a unique lock how does Nerrisa get inside does she have a copy of this key (she could have given it to Bigby). No matter what had happened it is obvious that Bigby is on to them and Nerrisa has helped him.
Bloody Mary is a very good possibility. Although I don’t think it plays into her interests it is a very solid possibility (It would also explain how she acquired the axe).
presume Georgie would dispose of or secure the body until which time you can dispose of it. How does Nerrisa get the head, and why doesn’t Georgie seem to ever notice that it is missing
This is probably the easiest question to answer lol
Georgie is an idiot who has proven himself to be pretty incompetent and he probably did misinterpret what the crooked man told him
to do. I have no trouble at all believing he would have done a terrible job trying to hide those bodies or getting rid of evidence lol
and even if he was worried about the missing heads he would have never let bigby know that
There are too many uncertainities to know for sure. It would be hard for me to believe Bigby can smell gunpowder/gunfire and deduce that the weapon was not fired recently yet he could not tell if it was real blood or a timetable of how long it was exposed. There were two opportunities for Snow or Bigby to ask Swiney about the head but they did not, yet Bigby asked Snow if Swiney got back with the results. If Georgie copped to the murders, why not ask about Faith's body and where he dumped it? If the donkeyskin lets Faith hide, why leave it at Woody's? What was Faith looking for on Woody (I don't know if the picture would make sense)? What really happened with Lawrence?