Do they know?
Does the cabin group even know that people who aren't bit and die still come back?
I mean, they probably do 2+ years in. But I'm not sure they are aware of that. Maybe I just missed that part.
And also...why did neither Kenny nor Sarita ever mention Matthew again so far? I mean, what the hell? That seems like a giant plot hole to me. After Episode 2, he wasn't even mentioned anymore. Kenny and Sarita have no way of knowing he died, but still don't care about it at all?
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
just more plot holes in telltale's what it seems rushed writing
It definitley seems a little rushed. Not bad, but could have been way better.
Season 1 >>>> Season 2 (so far)
It has become headcanon for me that Kenny was the one that found Matthew's knife and showed it to Walter. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fbsSPLLm30o Listen to the way Kenny says "Clem, go on inside and get to bed. Walt and I gotta talk for a second." Go to 1:17:55
So I think Kenny knows, but not Sarita.
Interesting find...
I always assumed Kenny just wanted to give Walt shit for giving away those supplies, but who knows?
Only problem I see here is when Kenny would have looked through Clem's stuff to find Walt's knife. I don't think he had time for that. And his line sounded more like surpressed anger/annoyance than sadness.
And if you told Walter that Nick's like everybody else and he gets killed, Luke (nor Reggie) doesn't say a thing related to him. And with Reggie, he doesn't even ask about Pete's faith. So rushed, yeah
No, Reggie asked about both Pete and Nick.
Probably one of the worst plot holes is when Carver mentions someone named George to Alvin and that he killed him in the past.
Too bad the only ones who possibly know anything about this George are dead.
I looked up George on the wiki, he was one of Carver's guards that Alvin killed to escape the camp.
George was a guard Alvin killed while escaping.
It really isn't that hard to work out.
Did you get this off of a wiki?
Its okay. Everyone gets on the same page about Walt during one of the scene breaks
No, I used my brain.
Like I said it isn't hard to work out.
I double checked it, he's right.
That's not a plot hole. That's just Carver mentioning an event we never saw, like Lee killing the senator. We don't need any clarification on this, it's up to our interpretation if Alvin was defending himself or if it was murder.
I'd prefer to think the cabin group was just unbelievably incompetent, and leave it at that.
Don't get me wrong here: I'm a fan of some of the new cast (Luke and Sarah in particular), but as a functioning unit, they're sort of screwed.
If Telltale went into every little tiny detail, the game would be incredibly slow paced. People are bored with the dialogue scenes as it is and you want MORE just to explain a character who had a 2 minute part? It's no different than a movie. Editors cut it down and often remove slower parts of the story so it's not incredibly boring to watch. Sometimes this means cutting a plot line, but if it means a 2 hour movie that has a good pace and isn't so boring you fall asleep versus a 4 hour one with every detail explained and might cause half the audience to take a nap, the cuts are needed. Books go through the same edits.
There's also plenty of breaks. How do we know Kenny and Sarita didn't bring up their old group? They could have, but it wasn't needed in the story.
Being a bit more obvious, but it's the zombie apocalypse. If someone isn't with a group when they were before, chances are they're dead. After so long, do people really feel the need to say that X didn't make it? They're not there when the group returns so you'd think it's pretty obvious. I imagine the same thing happened during the Black Death in Europe a few hundred years ago. People just stopped saying someone died because so many died every day. Why keep reminding yourself that you just lost someone else you were close to? If someone just took off (such as what Luke seems to be doing), then saying he just took off makes sense because then you know the person's likely still alive. But when the person dies, why say what people already know? They're not there and you didn't say they took off.
Oh sorry, my bad :c
Does any of the episodes hint at George being a guard?
Bonnie mentions something to Clem about George being a guard if Alvin is killed in Episode 2.
Okay, Gotcha.