›

Flaws in the Scenario kills the game !

XaiNedXaiNed
in The Wolf Among Us
I like evolutive games, and like the choice-making you can do
.. but ..
What if the story completely IGNORES the choice you made? .. or the consequences from your choices? > in my opinion it spoils the game completely !
- I choose to kill Dee (or was it Dum?) .. next episode, he's just back, like nothing happens..
- I choose to let the tree of aunty greenleaf be, not destroing it .. further in the story it appears I did burn it ..

Sorry but these things makes a story VERY weak imo!

Walking dead, was clearly more refined, and prepared with more care .. the 'wolf among us' could have been good, but it's just disappointing because of scenario-inconsistencies.
Why give the choice when you don't do anything with it afterwards ?? .. instead, you should keep the players choice restricted, don't try to pretend to be choice-bounded story .. specially with such BIG decisions you're asked to make in a jiffy (time rolls out) ..

You should give this game away for free, it's simply too inconstant .. these could have been avoided, but you clearly choose to close the eyes, and 'forget' the mistakes instead .. where does that leave telltale, I wonder ..

(sorry for all the time you guys put in there, nice graphics, nice ambiance .. bad management of possibilities ! )

.. I'm a bit disgusted really ..

Comments

  • dojo32161dojo32161 Moderator
    That didn't happen to me. I chose not to burn it and it stayed that way. And most people I've seen who killed Dum, he stayed dead. So I'm not sure how that happened to you.
  • ChuckTheLizardChuckTheLizard
    Your game is fuckin busted then.
  • GoltharGolthar
    It's probably a bug, did you watched the whole credits at the end of the episode?
  • KCohereKCohere
    If you killed Dee, he doesnt come back. Are you sure you used the right save?
  • TelltaleTakesForeverTelltaleTakesForever
    Either your making shit up or your getting your save files confused.
  • ArthurMatrixArthurMatrix
    Vegeta knows his shit.
    TelltaleTakesForever posted: »

    Either your making shit up or your getting your save files confused.

  • DragonButterDragonButter
    edited July 2014
    Man, you make it sound like that they intended to do this sort of thing to their own game. Haven't you heard of save issues in video games before?

    There must be an error on your part.
  • papai46papai46
    It's a troll post, he's not even answering people, he did this just to annoy us.
    DragonButter posted: »

    Man, you make it sound like that they intended to do this sort of thing to their own game. Haven't you heard of save issues in video games before? There must be an error on your part.

  • TelltaleTakesForeverTelltaleTakesForever
    "You're god damn right"
    ArthurMatrix posted: »

    Vegeta knows his shit.

  • DragonButterDragonButter
    edited July 2014
    Good point, we seriously need real life witches to turn these people into frogs. Something to torture them for the rest of their lives, muahaha.
    papai46 posted: »

    It's a troll post, he's not even answering people, he did this just to annoy us.

  • ChuckTheLizardChuckTheLizard
    What about that Crooked torture device?
    DragonButter posted: »

    Good point, we seriously need real life witches to turn these people into frogs. Something to torture them for the rest of their lives, muahaha.

  • lukefsjelukefsje
    We could always just send Bigby after him.
    ChuckTheLizard posted: »

    What about that Crooked torture device?

  • DragonButterDragonButter
    edited July 2014
    Great idea! I would've never thought of that. I'll make sure to order a backup from the Homelands, I hear they have a 50 percent discount on them.
    ChuckTheLizard posted: »

    What about that Crooked torture device?

  • ralo229ralo229
    Your save probably messed up. It happens all the time.
  • diaindiain

    The tree burning thing happened with me too. I had rewound the game to the part where you can kill Dum so that I could let him live and see what changed, but then when I got to Crooky's trial the game decided I had burned the tree even though I actually hadn't.
    Guess it's just problems with the saves. No biggy.

  • AhmedAli1AhmedAli1

    *Dum

    KCohere posted: »

    If you killed Dee, he doesnt come back. Are you sure you used the right save?

  • lin3756lin3756

    I didn't burn the tree and Greenleaf confessed it,clearly they are save data problem

    diain posted: »

    The tree burning thing happened with me too. I had rewound the game to the part where you can kill Dum so that I could let him live and see

  • popleepoplee

    I don't want to be rude but people like you kills the mood and life.

  • RobSoloRobSolo

    I did both of the choices you made and had no problems.

Sign in to comment in this discussion.