Why was what Luke did so wrong?
I totally get where he is coming from. He hasn't got any in ages, of course he would want to do it. Hell, I totally would have done it, a guy has needs, and Jane isn't half bad. Unless I am missing something, why do people now hate him for it?
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
I don't hate him for having sex, I hate that he didn't check the perimeter like he was supposed to do. The group got surrounded by walkers without warning because he wasn't doing his job.
Because he thought it was a good idea to get his dick wet while Rebecca was due to give birth AND he should have been looking out for walkers.
You can only rub one off for so long..
I guess people felt like he didn't help the group when they desperately needed him to, but maybe people didn't like this other side to him? I dunno idc lol
We didn't see anything, but we catch the tail end of their conversation and it definitely implied that they had sex. And Luke more or less confirms it when he says that "Jane offered."
Sex? Oh shit, I thought he was just flirting with her, goddamn it Luke.
Why was Kenny screaming at a kid wrong? He haven't done it in ages, not since Ben.
I mean, he's been good to my Clem so far and this seems to be his first big screw up, so I'm not going to stop liking him. All characters have flaws, and I can see how he was stressed and did what he did. Still, it's a big part in the episode, so people are going to gravitate towards it; Kenny fans especially.
At least Luke didn't get anyone killed, unlike Kenny telling Rebecca she couldn't rest.
Rebecca dies anyways so yes he did.
Kenny didn't know that she was so exhausted that she may die. You can't pin all the blame on him.
[removed]
Going from what I'm reading since I haven't played, it was a terrible, selfish decision that put the group at major risk and naturally people are going to talk about it, but the reason it's going to be THE thing that gets talked about is because people that already didn't like Luke are going to be crowing from the rooftops about how this confirms their belief that he's Satan.
Better than Kenny refusing to let Rebecca rest and thus causing her death.
I've loved Luke's character from the start, still do, but I am very disappointed that he put the group in danger like that.
Um, excuse me?
I am not 'sucking Kenny's dick' thank you very much. And I would class that as quite offensive. Don't you have any respect for other members?
Well I thought it was fairly obvious she was in trouble.
But even if you think it wasn't, 95% of the blame lies on kenny.
So, are you still always team Kenny? Did you agree 100% with what he did to rebecca?
Kenny didn't mean to get Rebecca killed.
So?
His foolishness and unempathetic mindset led to her dying.
If luke had refused you sure as hell be blaming him or her death.
Kenny is responsible.
Yeah, me too, and it bums me to hear that he went that way but I'm not washing my hands of him. He's a good guy at his core, my Clem was forming a bond with him, and everyone has their weak, selfish, and/or stupid moments in this game.
Maybe he was getting cold?
If someone runs a guy over while drink driving, he is still responsible for the death, even though he didn't mean to run him over.
Yeah, Kenny is kind of responsible. I think they should have waited to let Rebecca recover. Mike and/or Bonnie could have gone out to scavenge for supplies while the others fortified the Observation deck in the meantime. Rebecca really needed the rest. Kenny shouldn't have pushed her so hard. I don't hate him for it. I just wish that he wasn't focused so narrowly about getting to Wellington with out any regard for the others' well being. It's the boat all over again.
Maybe he was getting cold?
Didn't seem much like a joke to me.
..what?
You obviously get offended easily, I'm sorry.
But it was a joke.
aghh double post
It's more that he can't take an idiom, which is even more ridiculous.
Anyway, give the guy some slack. He's probably having a crisis of faith after seeing that Kenny isn't 100% a hero.
It's a Kenny fan.
Yes, I am still Team Kenny.
And what do you mean by 'what he did to Rebecca'? Shooting her? Makes sense since she probably would have eaten her own baby. Clem can shoot Rebecca herself. If you mean telling her she can't rest then maybe not 100%, but he just wanted to keep moving. Sitting out in the cold wouldn't have been much better.
Wasn't very funny.
And I don't appreciate what you said.
I'm right here, you know.
I'm sorry, but aren't you the same guy who told me that even though I was a Kenny fan, I still respect other people's opinions.
Yeah, it bums me too, as a Luke fan. Expected better of him.
I never had much faith in him anyway, i knew he would lost his shit after Sarita died
Double post, sorry
You respect others opinions which is awesome.
Just because you respect others opinions doesn't mean I can't personally disagree with you.
You can think Kenny is perfect and respect those who dont, but I can still disagree with you thinking he's perfect.
I didn't ask if you were team Kenny, I asked if you were still ALWAYS team kenny. As in, you don't think that any of what he did was wrong.
An I have no issue whatsoever with ken shooting her. I ha a problem that he could have given her a much better chance by stopping for five minutes.
It wasn't really the time to do that shit, although I'm even more surprised Jane went along with it.
She was basically talking shit about Rebecca being pregnant the whole episode and then she goes and.. y'know.
Unless one of them just conveniently had a condom available I think that's pretty hyprocritical writing....