Luke's ribs
Hello everyone, this is my first post ever, but tbh i have been lurking around this forum for quite a while.
Anyway, I couldn't help but wonder just how the hell did luke get his ribs broken?
I mean, he said it happened back at Carver's, but we have all seen that he was the one to disarm Carver AND help Rebecca hop down from the building. If he had enough strength to do those by the end of ep3, then I don't think his ribs got broken when he was beat up after getting caught.
We don't know what happened with Luke, Nick (determinantly) and Sarah since the beggining till we rescue Luke and Sarah, but sadly I still feel like this is a legitimate plot hole OR rewritting.
What do you guys think? Anyone has evidence of Luke getting his ribs broken at Carver's? Maybe he did indeed get hurt while looking for Sarah? Or is it just an overlooked detail on the writer's part, and as such, a plot hole?
Also, am I the only one that is REALLY pissed off that there was no mention of Lee OR Omid in the whole episode? (Or at least i didn't get any chance to) I mean, they were at a damn Civil War museum!
Comments
Carver could have knocked him around a bit when he first found him sneaking around.
Also, there were two Lee references. One is an option you could have told Sarah when you were trying to motivate her, the other is when looking at one of the dioramas in the museum, Clementine says "Lee would have loved this place..."
I got two or three mentions of Lee at the Civil War Museum.. I think you get it from clicking basically EVERYTHING. I also got a few mentions of Lee when saving Sarah at the trailer park. I'm sure I had another, too.
lee was mentioned twice in my ep4 playthrough
-once to sarah
-once in the museum
To be honest I don't think it's a
There's a third one; You can call Kenny an asshole and say that you too went through tough times by shooting Lee.
Oh, that's nice, though I can't remember any dialogue options that explicitly had Lee's name on them.
Welcome man.
Luke was the most confusing character this episode...
Luke: "My ribs are broken. I can't carry Sarah."
Luke: "My ribs are broken... oh hey Jane, yeah sure, let's make out!"
Alrighty then.
Thanks!
Well, that's the point: after Clem jumps on/shoots Carver and Kenny punches him, Luke managed to disarm him and then push him away. And after Kenny kills Carver, you can see Luke holding Rebecca with both his arms to help her hop down from the store. If his ribs were broken at that time, I don't think he would've been able to push Carver away or support Rebecca's weight.
Could Luke's ribs just be bruised? Carver caused it sure, but Luke could've knocked them on something when escaping the herd, and that's why he couldn't give Clem a boost at the time?
I wouldn't say his ribs were broken fractures yes but not fully broken
Didn't he say something about his ribs being broken back at the trailer park? Well, maybe I misunderstood... but still. The way he was cringing implied that he was in severe pain and it doesn't make sense that he was able to do a love session with Jane on a hard, wooden floor, just a few hours later. Seriously. It's confusing... (unless Jane's bajingo has some healing powers or something... who knows these days...)
Welcome