Lilly will not be joining us. The truth.

So if Telltale brings back Lilly that will be too unrealistic. Kenny has already happened and that was perfect and enough. But Lilly? Really? If that happens, I wont say Im done, but it wont give me the true feels. Im not againsts her, I just thought it would be ridiculous

Comments

  • I still expect to see Lilly Walker at some point.

  • Originally she was supposed to be Lilly from the comics, so they never planned to have her back.
    The changed Kenny's death so that he could come back so I think they planned for it.

    Not saying it won't happen but I think Clem was always going to meet up with Kenny again.
    But if we start saying Lilly then what about Molly? It would be strange if all the old characters started to show up.

  • Maybe not this season, but she has to appear sometime next season. I feel that her story isn't complete, and I want to know what happened to her after she was left on the side of the road/stole the RV.

  • Maybe she could star as one of the main characters of Season 2's DLC? If they make one, which I hope they do :p

    Rigtail posted: »

    Maybe not this season, but she has to appear sometime next season. I feel that her story isn't complete, and I want to know what happened to her after she was left on the side of the road/stole the RV.

  • edited July 2014

    She could be at Wellington because that's where everyone is heading aparently. In my opinion, it wouldn't be unrealistic to see her there.

  • edited July 2014

    because kenny somehow making it out alive was realistic.

  • edited July 2014

    It was confirmed in a recent interview that no more past characters would be returning. Sorry to break the bad news. :(

  • Woah woah hold on ONE SECOND because I am not sure if you meant it but I read this and couldn't tell if you were being sarcastic :

    "So if Telltale brings back Lilly that will be too unrealistic. Kenny has already happened and that was perfect and enough."

    Is this . . . serious? A man who was mobbed by 20+ walkers who when asked in Season 2 has no good answer besides "I was lucky" is more realistic than a woman driving away (alive) in an RV ? ?

    I think it'd be cool to see her come back but I don't think we'll see her again.

  • edited July 2014

    For crying out loud, not this again.

    The chances of Kenny's survival in both scenarios were slim, but not astronomical. Now, DOUG coming back alive after the way we saw him expire in S1? That's unrealistic.

    Incorporeal posted: »

    because kenny somehow making it out alive was realistic.

  • What on earth..

    Kenny survived in very dubious cirumstances, so yeah it's unbelievable that he survived really.

    But Lilly? She was in a position nowhere NEAR as bad. It would not be nearly as ridiculous to bring her back.

    You're just sayin this because you don't like her, not because you're worried about integrity, and it's oh so transparent.

  • edited July 2014

    Kenny only cameback because the fans demanded it, he was supposed to have died or at least be presumed dead for ever, since he cameback he's been an annoying prick and they have ruined the great character he once was. Just the way he acts now is just over the top.

    As for Lilly, she was always meant to have been the one from the comics where her role in the game would be like a prequel to her part in the comics, but they changed it at the last minute I think.

    Woah woah hold on ONE SECOND because I am not sure if you meant it but I read this and couldn't tell if you were being sarcastic : "So if

  • I don't like Lilly and Molly was an absurd character that doesn't belong in the same universe of the Walking Dead.

  • she is a minor character

  • I've heard some stories that her voice actress had some trouble with Telltale or something and that's the reason she's not coming back. Gavin Hammon said that they were originally going to have her come back near the end of Season One, but that didn't happen either. I think we've seen the last of Lily.
  • Well since she didn't die in season 1, why it would it be unrealistic for her to possibly return for season 2?
  • edited July 2014
    ok lets clear some things up cause some people seem to be a bit confused about what is going on with lily and why telltale got rid of her our lily was supposed to be the lily from the comics so she would have ended up with the governor after she left our group but kirkman fucked that up cause he decided to write a novel about lily's past so now our lily is an original character it isn't cause her voice actress had a fallout with telltale okay good? now I personally think it will be too unrealistic to see her come back BUT I would be interested in seeing her return at the very least while kenny is still alive just to see how they would interact

    also I would like to just say that comic lily says her dad's name is everett coincidence? I think not
  • if i remember correctly, lee was going to find the RV (if lily stole it) at the marsh house instead of the stranger
    Gavin996 posted: »

    Originally she was supposed to be Lilly from the comics, so they never planned to have her back. The changed Kenny's death so that he could

  • I think they were going to see Lilly and the RV in Savannah, I don't think she replaced the stranger though.
    doggywoggy posted: »

    if i remember correctly, lee was going to find the RV (if lily stole it) at the marsh house instead of the stranger

  • I somewhat agree (I think Lily could have survived, but I don't expect a return unless in a DLC).

    But Goodness, Do you have to be so condescending about it?
    Flog61 posted: »

    What on earth.. Kenny survived in very dubious cirumstances, so yeah it's unbelievable that he survived really. But Lilly? She was in

  • edited July 2014
    Sorry, but no. The Christa scenario is fine by me because you can't see the room but it naturally has a way out and you can't see just how many walkers there are in the building. Many different possibilities abound in that scenario.

    The Ben scenario is full-on unrealistic, end of story. There is simply no way Kenny could have fought his way out with nothing but an unloaded pistol in one hand and the walkers he ran into wouldn't be distracted by Ben either because he was up front. Given the amount of strength we've seen even *one* walker possess and the struggling necessary to push it off, somewhere between twenty or thirty walkers in a cramped space being pushed through just doesn't happen. The walkers Lee pushed through were at least spread out over a wide space and never attacked all at once because their attention was not solely focused on him. Not that it wasn't pretty unrealistic as well, though. Most of episode 5 was.

    I mean, you can't say it's not unrealistic when they literally skipped over what happened. Kenny goes quiet for a bit then says he got lucky. No specifics, because they couldn't think of anything.

    Doug coming back wouldn't be "unrealistic" as much as it would be a metric assload of game-breaking stupidity. Not really a valid example since we see him die, and him coming back would imply either immortality or some dark magic at work. A better example would be Justin surviving to season 2, despite having his leg blown off and bleeding out and with walkers after him, since we never *see* him die.

    For crying out loud, not this again. The chances of Kenny's survival in both scenarios were slim, but not astronomical. Now, DOUG coming back alive after the way we saw him expire in S1? That's unrealistic.

  • Maybe he jumped into a window that was in the wall that we couldnt see from our point of view?
    damkylan posted: »

    Sorry, but no. The Christa scenario is fine by me because you can't see the room but it naturally has a way out and you can't see just how m

  • Lilly =A woman with an RV or a pistol = unknow

    Kenny = a man in a room/dead end full of walkers and with a bullet iy = lives.

    NO SENSE
  • I don't see how people can say that Molly is anything out of place, considering the Walking Dead universe also contains Michonne, who is far more untouchable badass than Molly ever was.
    Corvan posted: »

    I don't like Lilly and Molly was an absurd character that doesn't belong in the same universe of the Walking Dead.

  • Lee took the pistol from Lilly. Remember, the Stranger said that "You left a defenseless, grieving woman on the side of the road", if you leave her behind.

    And if you conserve your bullets (ie don't shoot the walkers at the house), you can give your bullets to Kenny at the alleyway.
    Shumisha posted: »

    Lilly =A woman with an RV or a pistol = unknow Kenny = a man in a room/dead end full of walkers and with a bullet iy = lives. NO SENSE

  • edited July 2014
    False, they decided him surviving before they released the episode, they asked GH to play a little less obvious death. And btw calling someone an "annoying prick" while using a Shane avatar is just silly.
    ShaneWalsh posted: »

    Kenny only cameback because the fans demanded it, he was supposed to have died or at least be presumed dead for ever, since he cameback he's

  • This is because Robert Kirman released the novel stories about Woodbury where Lilly is one of the main characters, in the comics her faith was unknown so they most likely wanted to bring her back that way. I doubt they had any problems wih Lilly's voice actors, from all the panels and stuff I've seen her in she seems really nice.

    I've heard some stories that her voice actress had some trouble with Telltale or something and that's the reason she's not coming back. Gavi

  • I... I have no original words. Thankfully this remarkable stupidity has been rebutted numerous times here already.

    You got your Kenny-candy despite the ridiculous odds, now step aside and shut up. You are making yourself sound like a married straight guy condemning gay marriage.
  • Are you sure? Anyway she still have her legs u.u

    Lee took the pistol from Lilly. Remember, the Stranger said that "You left a defenseless, grieving woman on the side of the road", if you le

  • Well, there is a reasonable explanation. Many people are apparently heading to Wellington in the story, Lilly(and Molly, since some people are talking about her too) is a capable survivor who would probably think it's reasonable to go to Wellington and could probably get there. I'm not saying she'll show up, but if she did, it wouldn't really be insensible. Plenty of reason for her to be around.
  • edited July 2014
    Yeah, I'm sure. And she does, I reckon.

    But the point is, Lilly's fate is unknown and should be unknown. There's no real need to see her again.
    Shumisha posted: »

    Are you sure? Anyway she still have her legs u.u

  • The Ben scenario is full-on unrealistic, end of story.

    It's not the "end of the story," and it's arrogant to even make a statement like that in the first place. We're done here.

    damkylan posted: »

    Sorry, but no. The Christa scenario is fine by me because you can't see the room but it naturally has a way out and you can't see just how m

  • id shoot her on sight

  • MyushaMyusha Banned

    End of story = We're done here.

    The Ben scenario is full-on unrealistic, end of story. It's not the "end of the story," and it's arrogant to even make a statement like that in the first place. We're done here.

  • What about Khrista?

  • We forgot about glen...

    she is a minor character

  • She sure touched a lot of people for someone who is "untouchable"...

    I don't see how people can say that Molly is anything out of place, considering the Walking Dead universe also contains Michonne, who is far more untouchable badass than Molly ever was.

Sign in to comment in this discussion.