Overall Opinion on Episode 4.
I've seen alot of users say the episode was great, others saying it was bad. I'm just curious about what did you guys think about it overall
Vote here in this poll: http://strawpoll.me/2173301
If you feel like it, you can also say why you liked it/disliked it.
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
Best episode they made!
I thought it was great. Heartbreakingly great. I still think Episode 2 is the best this season, but this one was good too.
Amazing episode probably my favorite yet. That cliffhanger though grr!!! I wanna know what happens next!
Really good episode, finally some puzzles and hubs. 9/10
i am very puzzled about this Episode...i was actually expecting some Sci-fi shit because of that picture they have in the episode slide....the slide doesn't really have much to do with it unlike other episodes...where is Eddie?i was so pissed/shocked that nick died
...i seriously dont know what to say about this episode....i literally DID not feel anything...besides the shock for Nick's death and being extremely pressured during that arvo/jane meds scene...i did not feel anything about anyone in this episode
i did grow to like Mike more...i kinda liked him from the start though and i lulzed when Jane and Luke did the 8=D~~() thing...![:( :(](https://community.telltalegames.com/resources/emoji/frowning.png)
![:| :|](https://community.telltalegames.com/resources/emoji/neutral.png)
I was sad when Rebecca died...but i was even more sad when i kenny woke up beat to shit after Carlos bandaged him...Where is the part where Clementine Takes Kenny's Bandage off?
My face was literally like this at the end of this Episode o_o/
I seriously Cannot give any criticism or just say anything bad or good about this episode... it was just a big ":|" Fest...The ending did kinda get me excited for the next episode but only a little....
TL;DR-If you ask me to score this episode then i would score it ??/??(?? out of ??)
I thought this episode was pretty good. Whereas the last episode had a lot of action and not much reason to care about characters, this one had character development. Getting to know Jane and her back story made her much more interesting. (She leaves at the end, but I'm ok with that. It works for her character, and it's better than having a zombie kill her in a dumb way.) I liked that there were opportunities to hang out with a couple of the characters and find out what they thought about people in the group.
The episode also seemed a bit longer, and there were even some mini hubs to explore.
However, Sarita and Sarah were completely wasted. (Nick was wasted too ... Clem already shot Lee in the head; she doesn't need a lesson about killing people she cares about.) The whole cliffhanger choice from episode 3 was completely meaningless. It sucks when Telltale has no plan for some characters and just gets rid of them. I also was disappointed that Sarah got the Ben "fall and die" treatment. She was yelling for someone to save her, so it seemed like she was getting it back together instead of giving up like Jaime. But just like Ben, Sarah never got to redeem herself or prove that she couldn't handle it ... instead she died before anything happened with her character.
After seeing what happened to Sarita, she didn't even need to be in the game. We never learned anything about her. If she wasn't there, would it have made any difference? Kenny could have still been sad about his family and barely functioning / half crazy / sometimes able to rally.
I've also decided that even though Kenny died in my playthrough of season 1 (killed by zombies in the alley where Ben was), it's ok that Telltale retconned Kenny to be alive. Rather than just doing fanservice, Telltale is doing more development and writing for his character. I still think it's weird that he's survived this long though ... I kind of expect him to be killed by a zombie in his blind spot.
Remember him?
Wasn't very good to say the least, a few moments were enjoyable but choices have become more and more less meaningful as before. Harken back to S1 where you could've saved ben or drop him, that actually mattered a bit in the whole story where as here Nick and Sarah just fucking die off with little to no dialogue.
God damn it Telltale
I really liked it. It is clear that these are becoming more interactive movies then they are adventure games though. Little to no exploration. Just moves you from scene to scene and I do miss the exploration bits from Season 1. But the story is still excellent. This season is much more about these people just trying to survive then it is anything else. In season when it felt like they had a plan and purpose a lot of the time, but so many bad things happen to this group its hard to have a plan that lasts for more than a few hours. Some of the decisions in this episode were really hard to make too.
Guys Eddie was just a placeholder same as Carley and Doug
See? I don't get the hate for this episode. it had an intense storyline, good puzzles have returned from the dead actually some character development and some really funny lines. etc.
Wait. What puzzles? Did I miss something?
I thought it was good. Not great, but not bad either. The only things I actually hate about it are Nick and Sarah... not them, but what happened to them.
My criticism, is with handling Nick. I personally loved the episode, except for their handling of NIck. This is more a complaint against telltale and how they ALWAYS treat their characters who have the chance to die. Basically, even if you save them, they're essentially dead. Every time. You save them? They have a couple sentences in the next episode, then theyre dead anyways. It's irritating and they need to work on being less predictable
I thought it was great.. The first episode that made me completely scared and worried to do certain things. I actually ended up tearing up about 4 different times in this episode which is really something xD My only complain is.. the 400 days characters.. Come on, I thought from all the tweet's Telltale put out that they were actually going to be used by now. You already showed them off now just develop them. I'm not sure if they can do that along with concluding episode 5. Anyways really great and dark episode. Loved it.
Well distracting the walkers was the big one, it's pretty easy but it look me about 7 minutes too look at the ground.
All my faves died 0/10 frick u telltale