Lily NEEDS to come back in episode 5
Seriously if ANYONE can potentially make this season redeemable it would be her. Kenny fans got their guy back, now bring back the person who was CLEARLY alive and is CLEARLY not dead.
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
Bring the character back in Season Finale? Tell me when this happened before, please.
Unless it happens right in the final scene, bringing us yet another cliffhanger, then no.
That would be a pretty cool cliffhanger.
Can't disagree there.
It'd be fun to watch the Kenny fans rage.
No. I dont want new writers to ruin her.
No. The last thing we need is another dose of convenient writing.
Bring Christa back instead.
''Kenny will be very happy to see her again, just look at the flowers''
Convenient?? Kenny and Christa coming back are convenient. Lily coming back is logical. SHE SURVIVED, and she has her own damn RV truck. Her leaving was obviously meant for her to come back. More so than Mr Kenny.
Do you really expect me to believe that Clem reunites with Kenny AND Lilly after two years, within one week? No. That would be far too contrived and unlikely. For me, it would have a substantial impact on the quality of the story, and overall experience. Besides, if TT felt like making Lilly an integral part of this season's story, she would've shown up already. She was an interesting character, but the story doesn't need her.
Blame Kenny for that. Her running into him was unlikely. Her running into Lily isn't.
Okay, I'll somewhat agree that Kenny coming back was somehow convenient, but Christa coming back is by no means convenient. The prospect of Wellington was introduced to us by her remember? I'll find her being there much more plausible than Lily being there with her RV truck.
lol keep saying Kenny coming back wasn't anything but fan service. It was EXACTLY that.
Sure, keep telling yourself that. Clem was on her way to Wellington, and so was Kenny. It is somewhat contrived that they reunite, but it wasn't immersion-breaking. And we have no idea what happened to Lilly after we left her/she left us. There is no proof whatsoever that she's" CLEARLY alive".
Lily isn't coming back trust me.
No, keep Lilly a million miles away from the writers who want to kill off all the female characters. And if they try the same thing they did with Sarita or Sarah with Christa, keep her away too.
But in all seriousness, I could see her showing up in Wellington if she were to come back.
People are gonna die in episode 5. They need to reload the deck somehow for a possible future season.
Lilly will be back at some point for sure maybe nxt season but there is no way she wont come back
I would love for Lilly to return. I like her Character a lot more from the Governor books. Also considering I dislike everyone remaining in the group besides Kenny. I liked looking after Sarah because I respected Carlos - There Gone. I really liked the bonding between Jane and Clem - Shes Gone. I never Liked Luke or Bonnie. All I care about is a Broken down Kenny and a New born baby.
"there is no way she won't come back."
So you're saying it's completely, 100% objectively guaranteed that Lilly will return at some point. A bold statement. Can you prove that this is irrefutable fact?
Yeah, honestly i found her more interesting than Kenny.
Well of course i cant prove it but why not just kill her off if she wont be back same thing happened in the tv series the block who saves rick in the first ep with his son he came back after like 3 seasons and lilly coming back is an irrefutable fact in my opinion sorry if that offends you
So whenever a character disappears, they're guaranteed to come back? That's not good. If we expect everyone to reappear, it loses its meaning and surprise. TWDG is art, and art does not have "rules". TT should not conform to this idea of no character ambiguity.
Well we will see sooner later every charachter who had disappeared in the show and comics and apart from lily and christwin the game to has come back otherwise its just a sort of a plot hole she will be back when the plot says so dont get why your so against the idea honestly
Too bad that's not Telltale Lily.
Maybe not but they have similar personality's, You could make the argument they are. I know a lot of people consider them too be.
Nah it's totally not Telltale Lily they have different backstories she was gonna be but she's been given another backstory in the comics so it's not the same person and that's why she can't really come back atleast that's what i heard.
I think lily would be good coming back but we have already had all the Lily/Kenny arguments so i dont think she could bring anything back. but my friend has said about Molly (the girl from crawford) coming back but it would cause conflict with Jane.