Why was what Luke did so wrong?

13

Comments

  • A wise man once said " the most important thing in your life is going to be getting some booty."

  • Famous last words.

    snyderman posted: »

    A wise man once said " the most important thing in your life is going to be getting some booty."

  • Luke: Clem what is the one thing a guy would walk hondred miles-

    Clementine: Omid and Christa made it clear for me

  • i was disturbed it happened after They killed sarah

  • Because there is a time and place for everything and this clearly wasn't it. I trusted him to be on the lookout and he goes and bangs Jane. Jeez Luke......(at least this proves he isn't gay lol)

  • That's how I felt too. I wasn't happy with how cruel Kenny was to Clem, and then he was acting very weird about the baby. I fear for his sanity. And I was very disappointed with and mad at Luke for shirking his duties for some sexy-time with Jane. I didn't always agree with Kenny's plans in s1, but I thought he was absolutely right this time about how the group had to keep moving. We didn't have the luxury of waiting a few days to see if Rebecca felt better. If they didn't find food and a warm, safe place to stay, everyone would be in danger of dying, including Rebecca and the baby.

    ll_Myko_ll posted: »

    That's debatable.. I disliked them both this episode, but obviously I'm going to have a stronger connection with Kenny considering I've know

  • Rick hasn't fucked ages either, because he had to lead the group

  • edited July 2014

    Was that a Boondocks reference? Awesome...

    Alt text

    snyderman posted: »

    A wise man once said " the most important thing in your life is going to be getting some booty."

  • " totally get where he is coming from. He hasn't got any in ages, of course he would want to do it." That is why I DO NOT WANT my Clem to be around Luke anymore.

  • The way she felt guilty that it might be Carver's suggests that she had an affair willingly.

    I thought Rebecca got raped? Wasn't that the whole situation?

  • Rebecca agreed with Kenny that they had to keep moving. It's not like slowly freezing and starving to death in the gift shop was a better option than trying to find somewhere safer.

    Flog61 posted: »

    So? His foolishness and unempathetic mindset led to her dying. If luke had refused you sure as hell be blaming him or her death. Kenny is responsible.

  • Totally agree. Bonnie and Mike are the only level headed people left.

    Kimi492 posted: »

    I disagree, both him and Luke acted like idiots or psychos this episode. If I can have my way I'm leaving with Bonnie and Mike.

  • edited July 2014

    Yeah, I am angry at him. Luke is the one who put himself on watch upon returning from the trailer park and then he decides to fuck Jane. When he should have been on lookout like he told the group he would be.

  • I rarely ever agree with Kenny. This time was different... Luke was so irresponsible sleeping with Jane. That was not the time, nor the place - unacceptable. I can forgive Jane since she didn't directly offer to watch camp.

  • The problem is that it is not the first time Luke has left his post and abandoned his responsibilities. He is starting to become like Ben

  • Vegas weekend?

    Just like Omid...just like Omid.

  • edited July 2014

    Because their is a such thing as Self Control I mean really in a time like this the last thing one should think about is getting laid when
    **

    1-Survivial

    2-Food and shelter

    3-Safety

    4-The god smack shitty situation the group is in and facing including the weather and past lost**

    Plus he had a Responsibility to look out and for Rebecca whom is pregnant. I mean seriously is that all men think about but cannot say that espy when Jane consented or offered and Kenny was in the right of what he said [ no am not team Kenny or Luke]
    Luke was in the wrong and ****when Jane left he was ONLY MAD since that was his ticket to bang ville** which is fucked up **considering the people around him with bigger issues and needs.

    Luke pissed me off in this episode for sure and the excuse he needed it was a BS. MASTURBATE/sex LUKE IN UR [FREE TIME]

  • I kept wondering why there wasn't an option for, "Let Rebecca rest, and we'll scout for supplies/hunt/fish. Not really fair that it was either stay and starve, or go and push a woman who'd just given birth/was sick and exhausted.

    Liayso posted: »

    Yeah, Kenny is kind of responsible. I think they should have waited to let Rebecca recover. Mike and/or Bonnie could have gone out to scaven

  • We don't know that Carver gave her a choice. Getting her pregnant could have been manipulation on his part, so she couldn't leave.

    I don't think that was the cause of her death. She probably would have died anyways. It's a little harsh to put all the blame on Kenny. Rebe

  • I don't think it's anyone's fault that she died, but you can't say someone who's had experience with childbirth before wouldn't know just how fragile a woman would be just after giving birth in those conditions. Frankly, I'm shocked Christa made it.

    Kenny didn't know that she was so exhausted that she may die. You can't pin all the blame on him.

  • Double post

    Tyranitar posted: »

    cough Sarah cough

  • Double post

    Tyranitar posted: »

    cough Sarah cough

  • Yes it was. Booty is more important than drinking water.

    Sarangholic posted: »

    Was that a Boondocks reference? Awesome...

  • Virgins be jealous. That's why.

  • Luke shrugged off his duties to the group to fuck a girl he barely knew. A man does not have a need for sex. You can survive perfectly fine without it. Sarah arguably died because of him(if you saved her at the junkyard) and the group had to have a very dangerous battle with a hoard of zombies because Luke was having a good time with Jane. Luke was selfish and one of my favorite characters died because of it.

  • Considering she was doing it with Troy, she probably had at least a few condoms on her. Or maybe she only gave Luke oral.

    Graysonn posted: »

    It wasn't really the time to do that shit, although I'm even more surprised Jane went along with it. She was basically talking shit about

  • Definitely one of my favourite moments after JUST having talked to him about how 'broken people become reckless.' SO glad my response to him was 'Who are you to judge?" following that. I really do love when these events sort of set themselves up that way! And I totally slapped my knee when I walked in on them.

  • People are selfish. Surprise!

    The zombie apocalypse has taught survivors to live in the moment. People living in modern society often don't live in the moment and deny their own mortality. If people weren't scared of eternal retribution from a wrathful God, there would be a lot more random sex and people living in the moment.

    When any moment could literally be your last, taking a moment of happiness (no matter how selfish) is perfectly understandable to me. Would I be angry with said person if someone died as a result? Yes... but I would do the exact same thing in Luke's shoes. That may make me a shitty person but at least I'm honest about it :)

    Luke shrugged off his duties to the group to fuck a girl he barely knew. A man does not have a need for sex. You can survive perfectly fin

  • Did they had sex or did they just flirting wit each other ?_?

  • You can see Jane putting on her boot after Clem gets up there.

    Xemnes posted: »

    Did they had sex or did they just flirting wit each other ?_?

  • Alt text

    Bygler posted: »

    Vegas weekend?

  • and? It didnt mean they fucked?

    bloop posted: »

    You can see Jane putting on her boot after Clem gets up there.

  • And Luke said he hadn't felt that human in awhile.

    Xemnes posted: »

    and? It didnt mean they fucked?

  • edited July 2014

    And??? That doesnt mean they had sex either. Flirting or kissing can make u feel like a human too

    bloop posted: »

    And Luke said he hadn't felt that human in awhile.

  • They had sex. It was super obvious. You don't get that nervous around a kid if you were just hanging out.

    Xemnes posted: »

    And??? That doesnt mean they had sex either. Flirting or kissing can make u feel like a human too

  • He did it at the wrong time, Not only was Rebecca in bad shape, Walkers were everywhere. Where is Luke and Jane? Riding the hobby horse.
    That's why it made me mad.

  • So what was he supposed to do? Build a fucking castle, warning mechanism and maybe gather couple of machine guns from all junk he could find?

    It wasn't Luke's fault that walkers always show up at the critical moment.

    Liayso posted: »

    I don't hate him for having sex, I hate that he didn't check the perimeter like he was supposed to do. The group got surrounded by walkers without warning because he wasn't doing his job.

  • edited July 2014

    People were counting on him, while he was having fun, Everone was working on something, believe me, if Alvin and Carlos were alive Luke wouldn't have to worry about walkers, Alvin would have killed him or hurt him pretty bad for putting his family in danger, and Carlos would have definitely killed him for Sarah.

  • Yeah guys I guess Luke has to get his thrust on every day or else he will die!

    he doesn't even need water, or food, no nothing, he just needs THRUST.

  • Luke even admits that Jane "made the offer". Pretty obvious if you ask me.

    They had sex. It was super obvious. You don't get that nervous around a kid if you were just hanging out.

Sign in to comment in this discussion.