I feel guilty...
I feel guilty for saving Jane over Sarah. I panicked! XD I only had a short time to think, and this is what raced through my mind: "OH NO!! JANE!! Um....Sarah...or Jane...I LIKE JANE BETTER AND SARAH'S ALREADY CRAY CRAY!!" And then I grabbed Jane's hand. XD
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
I feel this was one point where the message should have been a bit different. plenty of people see it as a Jane or Sarah choice when it really isnt.
I think clem should have told her to save Sarah she says she dosnt want to. then the choice
Fine (Pull her up)
Please we cant leave her
Less people would have been confused
Actually, Sarah dies either way. But you could force Jane to help her, even though she won't succeed in this.
I feel the same way! What made up my mind was that Jane knew how to survive and she had skills. If I had known she'd leave the group 10 minutes later, I may have picked Sarah. I'm not sure. But if Sarah dies either way then that can't be helped I guess. Just felt awful since she was calling out for Clementine.
I feel bad because I've been so nice to Sarah all the time...but when she needed me most, I wasn't there for her.
I just am thinking over in my mind about the situation. Luke had a good grip on Jane's hand/forearm. He didn't REALLY need Clementine's help, did he? Yeah his ribs were sore and he was in pain but he's still pretty strong. I should have tried to save Sarah, I just really wish that she survived. I had Clementine teach her how to use a gun so I thought that she would be able to protect herself.
But it does lead to Jane getting bitch-slapped by a piece of wood XD
I was actually concerned about losing them both by insisting Jane help her so I just pulled her up. Seeing the alternative scene however, I was kind of annoyed that Jane was able to still reach the deck even after she tried to help Sarah. Which begged the question why was Clem not allowed to go down and assist her? Seems there's always a narrative goof like this per episode.