Who would be Clementine's best guardian?
For all who have played The Walking Dead Season 1, you know that Lee was Clem's guardian. Do you think he did a good job, or there should be someone else taking care of Clem, or Clementine should take care of herself with no one being her guardian?
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
Clementine would be Clementine's best guardian.
That fact hit me right at the start of episode 4 when a terrified Clem is left all alone with the hoard of walkers. Kenny yells at her about Sarita before actually running off (leaving Clem surrounded by people eaters!!) and Luke goes and plays hero for Sarah (maybe he didn't see or hear Clem, but that's a big maybe). Then the option to call out for either Luke or Kenny pops up and that's when I knew neither of them were good for her, because none of them would have been there to answer. I'll give the others the benefit of doubt and say they were too far separated from Clem and thought it would be best to wait at the meeting point.
Seems like everyone else has their own priorities and it's really showing that Clementine isn't one of them; which means it's even more necessary that Clementine makes herself her own priority.
Mike and Bonnie should be her guardian.
Look, it seems like kenny would be best, but just because we knew him longer doesn't make him clem's best guardian. And luke royally messed up once, but that doesn't mean he can't look after clementine. He ran after sarah, hell, he'd probably to the same thing to clem.
But, I think clem could use someone watching her back once in a while, yet not another lee figure. She's pretty good on her own.
Apart from Lee she is the only one that can take care of herself. She is the strongest in that group, followed by Kenny (the guy lost his family right before his eyes, his girlfriend, his eye and yet keeps finding reasons to keep going and fighting. His main problem in my opinion is the anger accumulated inside him but let's be honest it's justified).
At this point, nobody. Clem is already tougher and more stable than most. I don't really think she needs to be protected anymore.
More than anything, I think Clem needs wisdom and moral support. A character like (TV Series) Hershel would probably be good for her.
I don't think she needs a guardian anymore, she needs a friend.
I don't think Clem needs a guardian, she knows how to take care of herself. Though if I had to choose, I would say Mike or Bonnie
Clem don't need one.
Pretty sure Luke didn't see her, and was focused on Sarah freaking out. With how much he cares for her, if he wasn't occupied with Sarah and had noticed Clem, he most certainly would have assisted her.
Of those who are left of the group? Yeah, they're who I'd go with.
Here's a situation: What if in Season 1 Lee was kicked out of the group because of his criminal record? What would happen to Clementine?
Clementine obviously doesn't need one :-). "You're strong Clem.. You can do anything"
But if I were to choose someone it would be between Mike and Bonnie. Those two are the most stable currently.