What is it specificly that turns you off to her character? I'm just genuinely interested. Cause I see the very edges of what you're saying (she still ranks up there with the greatest fictional characters in my book -no. 2 or 3-)
A lot of people are gonna disagree with me, so I'll brace myself for the onslaught of downvotes as I say this:
I don't think Clementine i… mores that interesting of a character. I feel like Telltale hasn't done much with her, and at the same time, I feel like it's too late to do much with the character. I wouldn't mind starting fresh with a new group if they were to make a third season.
EDIT: Fixed a typo.
But in all honesty, I would enjoy a fresh perspective also. And Clementine is possibly my favorite video game character of all time, but people need to understand character development can only go so far in fiction. And I feel like Clementine is reaching the end of hers.
Jeez, angry fan boys disliking me because I wanna new protagonist...
Really mature, I guess some people start to hate other people who don't have same opinion as their's.
Clem's story arc doesn't have to end, I mean it's the Zombie apocalypse, it's never really going to end until she dies from either a human, zombie or just of old age.
I'd prefer it if Season 2 ends with Clem alive and that to be it. I find the mystery of a characters whereabouts much more interesting than the closure of one in The Walking Dead world. I mean the last appearance of Kenny in Season 1 was the entire reason for why there was so much buzz around him coming back in Season 2, same goes for Lilly.
Don't get me wrong, I'd like Clem to appear in Season 3 in some fashion but just not as a playable character, I just find there are more avenues to explore with an entirely new character.
Welcome to the Internet.
But in all honesty, I would enjoy a fresh perspective also. And Clementine is possibly my favorite video game ch… morearacter of all time, but people need to understand character development can only go so far in fiction. And I feel like Clementine is reaching the end of hers.
Now, heres a like to help you feel better!
In one hand, i'd love to see a teenager/adult Clementine, but the timeskip would be enormous.
I'd probably would rather see a complete new story with a new protagonist, but it feels weird without Clem.
In my opinion, they should have Clem as the protagonist in Season 3 and finish her story (Hopefully without....You know.) Then change the protagonist in Season 4.
BS! Clementine is the reason why season 2 isn't as good as first one. Wee girl fightning zombie is absurd. Wouldn't stand a chance. Clem should appear in 3rd season but not as protagonist.
BS! Clementine is the reason why season 2 isn't as good as first one. Wee girl fightning zombie is absurd. Wouldn't stand a chance. Clem should appear in 3rd season but not as protagonist.
Clementine IS one of the reasons I don't like season 2 as much as the first. The adults are written to be morons so you that you, as clementine, can be the hero or at least have something to do... like shut down a wind turbine. Really, she was the only one out of all those adults who couldn't turn a key. I still like the game, but it's just not as good as it could be.
BS! Clementine is the reason why season 2 isn't as good as first one. Wee girl fightning zombie is absurd. Wouldn't stand a chance. Clem should appear in 3rd season but not as protagonist.
teenager clem would be ridiculous. It's hard enough to imagine that 2 years after the zombie's appear that there has not been some form of a society rebuilding. But maybe that's just me.
If S3 features Clem as the main character again, I would like a teenager Clem, I think the comic allows Telltales to have a 14-15 years old … moreClem (correct me if I'm wrong). And the gap between S2 and S3 would be because she reached Wellington and it's finally a good community. But S3 starts when something is threatening Wellington's peace or something like that.
Or, I would also be okay with a completely fresh start with new characters.
What the fuck!? First of all, nobody can tell me wether I'm a fan or not. I only know that. I am a true fan of this game and Im smart enough to know it. I agree with some of these people. If Clem dies, I will not play this game. I will not. Maybe I will look at some playthroughs but my interest will no longer be in Telltale's TWD season 3. @rigtail , I'm not just a Clem fan, Im a season 1 and 2 fan. And if Clem dies then I just won't be in favor of that in season 3. I would love Clem as the protagonist next season! If she dies, YOU even gotta admit, it wouldnt be the same...at all. All we have had is Clem since season 1 and then all of a sudden just take her out?! She is the star of the game. I mean C'mon! The Last Of Us fans would never play if they made a new season and Ellie died and Joel was alive!
To be honest, I'm torn.
I want Clementine to carry on as the protagonist in season 3 because there's so much more potential for an older … moreversion of her. Depending on the choices we picked in season 2, did we perhaps Clem turned into a colder, hardened teenager, or does she still hold an idealistic view of the world and remember all that Lee taught her? Would we stumble upon past characters like Glenn or Lilly again? Can you imagine their surprise at how much Clem has changed; would they even be able to recognize her at first?
...However, I also wouldn't mind a completely new character. It would be interesting to see how they have survived this far into the infection and what it cost them, what their relationships are, etc. Plus, I love the idea of running into a Clementine that we no longer control.
The comic now takes place two years after the game (and the game is in the same universe as the comic, if you didn't know that), Clem is eleven so it's very possible for her to be thirteen in S3, just sayin'
teenager clem would be ridiculous. It's hard enough to imagine that 2 years after the zombie's appear that there has not been some form of a society rebuilding. But maybe that's just me.
The comic now takes place two years after the game (and the game is in the same universe as the comic, if you didn't know that), Clem is eleven so it's very possible for her to be thirteen in S3, just sayin'
npc: hey maybelle.
maybelle : moo
npc: how's you today ?
mayb: mooo
npc: k so lets go kill walkers...
may: moo
npc: oh come o… moren babe don't be like that..
may: mooooooooooo
npc: fine i'll go alone ..
may: good i hate you anyway...
npc: what did you say ?!
mayb: moooo
or
the choices would be 1. moo 2... moooo. 3 moooooo...4.........
A lot of people are gonna disagree with me, so I'll brace myself for the onslaught of downvotes as I say this:
I don't think Clementine i… mores that interesting of a character. I feel like Telltale hasn't done much with her, and at the same time, I feel like it's too late to do much with the character. I wouldn't mind starting fresh with a new group if they were to make a third season.
EDIT: Fixed a typo.
Clem has been in 2 whole seasons so far. I wouldn't say i'lll not play the next season if Clem died but i seriously can't see myself enjoying it as much.
A "fan" that plays a game only for a character, and will stop playing that game if that character is no longer in it. It's considered to be … morea false fan because you aren't truly a fan of TWD if you only play it for Clem, you are a fan of Clem and that's it.
Me on the other hand, I AM a fan of TWD and I WILL continue playing if Clem dies. Not saying I want her to though, she's one of my favorite video game characters.
then they can do it like it is good and bad choices clem's not crazed killer on how you playing she will always hate to see her people die no matter who they are
Well, I didn't see any reason to start from the beginning of the outbreak so I guess we'll play as Clementine. Like I said a few times earli… moreer I don't think like that because it's my favourite character but because it makes more sense and like YOU said it'd be difficult for Telltale to create her dialogues with different playthrough of each players.
I don't like people deciding for me whether I am a "true" fan or not of something based on my preferences. Some people strongly like a series because there is something in in it (you name what), when it is gone, it is only human to feel less enthusiasm towards it. If you are a fan of the core concept and will continue to enjoy it further, even without that element you loved, good. If the core concept didn't really do it for you, but that one element or elements allowed you to enjoy it nonetheless and you are bummed out that they are gone, fine, too.
Some people are only fans of one incarnation of The Walking Dead because it has something they enjoyed more than the comics or the TV show. Repeat in different combinations.
What the fuck!? First of all, nobody can tell me wether I'm a fan or not. I only know that. I am a true fan of this game and Im smart enough… more to know it. I agree with some of these people. If Clem dies, I will not play this game. I will not. Maybe I will look at some playthroughs but my interest will no longer be in Telltale's TWD season 3. @rigtail , I'm not just a Clem fan, Im a season 1 and 2 fan. And if Clem dies then I just won't be in favor of that in season 3. I would love Clem as the protagonist next season! If she dies, YOU even gotta admit, it wouldnt be the same...at all. All we have had is Clem since season 1 and then all of a sudden just take her out?! She is the star of the game. I mean C'mon! The Last Of Us fans would never play if they made a new season and Ellie died and Joel was alive!
Comments
who ever disliked my comment i hope you randomly fall of a building that is 25 floors high
Get a boat
What is it specificly that turns you off to her character? I'm just genuinely interested. Cause I see the very edges of what you're saying (she still ranks up there with the greatest fictional characters in my book -no. 2 or 3-)
Welcome to the Internet.
But in all honesty, I would enjoy a fresh perspective also. And Clementine is possibly my favorite video game character of all time, but people need to understand character development can only go so far in fiction. And I feel like Clementine is reaching the end of hers.
Now, heres a like to help you feel better!
I don't really care. The zombie hype is over, all that is left is addicts. TTG really messed up this season.
Clem's story arc doesn't have to end, I mean it's the Zombie apocalypse, it's never really going to end until she dies from either a human, zombie or just of old age.
I'd prefer it if Season 2 ends with Clem alive and that to be it. I find the mystery of a characters whereabouts much more interesting than the closure of one in The Walking Dead world. I mean the last appearance of Kenny in Season 1 was the entire reason for why there was so much buzz around him coming back in Season 2, same goes for Lilly.
Don't get me wrong, I'd like Clem to appear in Season 3 in some fashion but just not as a playable character, I just find there are more avenues to explore with an entirely new character.
Thank you kind sir/lady, here, you can have my like too
I don't know how i feel about that...
In one hand, i'd love to see a teenager/adult Clementine, but the timeskip would be enormous.
I'd probably would rather see a complete new story with a new protagonist, but it feels weird without Clem.
In my opinion, they should have Clem as the protagonist in Season 3 and finish her story (Hopefully without....You know.) Then change the protagonist in Season 4.
So if Kenny doesn't die in ep5, the whole "Kenny confirmed for Season x" thing will start again ?
What about if we play as a new group of survivors in in the starting of episode 1 and people die and shit goes down (The usual)
And at the exact end of the episode we run into a girl and she turns around and it's Clementine but shes older (13 or 14) and it ends there.
Well then I'm Hitlersatan then
I would love to have Clem as a protagonist, but a part of me wants a new protagonist. Either with a new story or has a connection with Season 1 and 2.
Start a new story and then return to clementine's in another season
No it isn't. I have my own problems with Season Two (despite overall liking the season) but the protagonist is not one of them.
I have 99 problem's, but the protagonist ain't one.
"And anyone asking for Clem to be a protagonist in season 3 has shit taste and should feel horrible, because you're literally worse than Hitler."
And you can fuck off. Seriously, what kind of logic is that? Are you sure you're alright in the head?
Clementine IS one of the reasons I don't like season 2 as much as the first. The adults are written to be morons so you that you, as clementine, can be the hero or at least have something to do... like shut down a wind turbine. Really, she was the only one out of all those adults who couldn't turn a key. I still like the game, but it's just not as good as it could be.
teenager clem would be ridiculous. It's hard enough to imagine that 2 years after the zombie's appear that there has not been some form of a society rebuilding. But maybe that's just me.
What the fuck!? First of all, nobody can tell me wether I'm a fan or not. I only know that. I am a true fan of this game and Im smart enough to know it. I agree with some of these people. If Clem dies, I will not play this game. I will not. Maybe I will look at some playthroughs but my interest will no longer be in Telltale's TWD season 3. @rigtail , I'm not just a Clem fan, Im a season 1 and 2 fan. And if Clem dies then I just won't be in favor of that in season 3. I would love Clem as the protagonist next season! If she dies, YOU even gotta admit, it wouldnt be the same...at all. All we have had is Clem since season 1 and then all of a sudden just take her out?! She is the star of the game. I mean C'mon! The Last Of Us fans would never play if they made a new season and Ellie died and Joel was alive!
What about this idea? Play as Clementine AND a new character like Tales from the Borderlands!
MIND BLOWN
The comic now takes place two years after the game (and the game is in the same universe as the comic, if you didn't know that), Clem is eleven so it's very possible for her to be thirteen in S3, just sayin'
I didn't know that.
npc: hey maybelle.
maybelle : moo
npc: how's you today ?
mayb: mooo
npc: k so lets go kill walkers...
may: moo
npc: oh come on babe don't be like that..
may: mooooooooooo
npc: fine i'll go alone ..
may: good i hate you anyway...
npc: what did you say ?!
mayb: moooo
or
the choices would be 1. moo 2... moooo. 3 moooooo...4.........
Can't wait to play as her
oh god no...
ceaser grow up...
this is clem's tale that is why only she can be the P_C just like the comics is rick's story
Clem has been in 2 whole seasons so far. I wouldn't say i'lll not play the next season if Clem died but i seriously can't see myself enjoying it as much.
then they can do it like it is good and bad choices clem's not crazed killer on how you playing she will always hate to see her people die no matter who they are
Crippled Potter for Protagonist!
ok everyone kenny must die we can live with kenny mercy killing by clem
Kenny > Clementine
I don't like people deciding for me whether I am a "true" fan or not of something based on my preferences. Some people strongly like a series because there is something in in it (you name what), when it is gone, it is only human to feel less enthusiasm towards it. If you are a fan of the core concept and will continue to enjoy it further, even without that element you loved, good. If the core concept didn't really do it for you, but that one element or elements allowed you to enjoy it nonetheless and you are bummed out that they are gone, fine, too.
Some people are only fans of one incarnation of The Walking Dead because it has something they enjoyed more than the comics or the TV show. Repeat in different combinations.
Maybe we will have TWO protagonist like in Tales from the Borderlands. Clem and some adult. What ya think?
I never said it would be the same, it would definitely be different without her character, but that doesn't mean I would stop playing.