Unforgiven?
I have had this thought for a while and was wondering what you all think. We know Carley/Doug died on account of Ben's actions, but what do you think would have happened if they lived? Lets say Carley/Doug noticed Lilly was raising her gun and avoided the shot. Do you think they would have forgiven Ben for slipping up? Would they have shown an understanding like Lee did? Would either one have defended Ben in Crawford when Kenny wanted to leave him behind?
I think both Carley and Doug would have forgiven Ben, but both would be distrusting towards him for almost getting them killed. However I feel that Doug and Carley are kind hearted and would have voted to let him stay. What are your thoughts?
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
interesting but id love too see what they would have done with lily after they avoided the shot
They weren't such douches as Kenny.
They would've done the best for the group and sided with Lee instead of bitching arround.
Well Kennys just trying to help but yeah Doug and carley were more reasonable bat times than Kenny S1....
Not sure. I'd be more interested in the interaction with Lilly after she tried to kill the character and failed.
Well, Carley was killed in cold blood, while Doug was only trying to save Ben.
I think Doug would forgive him in an instant, while Carley would take some doing but ultimately would forgive him.
But what would Lilly say after failing to kill one of the two?
I think the whole scene would have been the same with the exception of either one dying and slight dialouge changes. She would still say that Carley can't be trusted and Carley would have been able to respond to those accusations. In Dougs case I think it would have worked better if he was shot in the shoulder instead and lived. Lilly might say something like, "It was an accident I didn't mean to. Why did you get in the way?". Both of these senerios would have still prompted the choice to leave Lilly or let her back in.
I think the choice could have been the same. We can either forgive Lilly for attempted murder and let her back into the R.V, or we can leave her because she almost killed one of us.
Yeah. Imagine the dialouge choices.
I think Carley really cared for Ben, kind of like a big sister. She would have been dissapointed, but forgiving.