I'd give it an 8. It was a very intense episode that carried a lot of emotional weight, but a few things could have been handles better. For example, Nick's death. If you get Nick through episode 2, you'd expect that his presence would change some things in future episodes right? WRONG. All that really changes is he gets a few lines of dialogue, and when he finally does die in episode 4, no one seems to really care. The same goes for Sarah's death. While it was still handles better than Nick's, it annoys me that whenever you save a character they are still doomed to die later on, it makes it feel as if your choices have no real impact on the story itself. I get that from a writer's perspective it's hard to write a script where certain characters may be live or dead, but that doesn't mean you should just kill them later. I'm sire there could've been some interesting things done with Sarah and Nick. Again, I just feel like my decisions have no real weight, The episode ends the same no matter what you do (with a few very SLIGHT modifications in the dialogue). Hopefully our decisions in the season will carry some weight in episode 5, but i'm starting to lose hope.
That was part of it, I also liked Walter, the beginning scene with Pete or Nick, That creepy house scene with Carver, and just overall I liked it more than the other episodes...
7 or 8, but I tend to 7. It had some great elemens, but the death rate was almost annoying. I mean, it was like Death, death, death, no time to let it sink in. Some deaths made sense (in a way), like Sarita (I hacked her arm off.. bad decision, but of course that led to her death) or maybe even Rebecca (childbirth is critical, especially without a sterile environment).
Sarah was kinda coming, but it hit me when I realized how father and daughter just.. vanished so quickly. I felt terrible because she just died when I saved her before, in that episode. And Nick? Killed off because he was determinant. That one I really did not like.
So, yes, most deaths had some reason or explanation but it was just too much
Comments
9
I liked everything except that Nick died, i'm over it now. I concentrating on my buddy who loves eating raccoon.
I would give it a 8, and ranking the episodes of the season here's mine...
1.A House Divided
2.In Harms Way
3.Amid the Ruins
4.All that Remains
I'll give it Marco Bott out of Eren Jaeger.
I also hate that nick died and sarah although i think jane might be back. I hope Mike made it out of the gunshots
I didn't like episode 1 that much either.
8.5.
My one bad point was how poorly handled Nick's death was.
Was a house divided your fav because of Kenny?
I'd give it an 8. It was a very intense episode that carried a lot of emotional weight, but a few things could have been handles better. For example, Nick's death. If you get Nick through episode 2, you'd expect that his presence would change some things in future episodes right? WRONG. All that really changes is he gets a few lines of dialogue, and when he finally does die in episode 4, no one seems to really care. The same goes for Sarah's death. While it was still handles better than Nick's, it annoys me that whenever you save a character they are still doomed to die later on, it makes it feel as if your choices have no real impact on the story itself. I get that from a writer's perspective it's hard to write a script where certain characters may be live or dead, but that doesn't mean you should just kill them later. I'm sire there could've been some interesting things done with Sarah and Nick. Again, I just feel like my decisions have no real weight, The episode ends the same no matter what you do (with a few very SLIGHT modifications in the dialogue). Hopefully our decisions in the season will carry some weight in episode 5, but i'm starting to lose hope.
That was part of it, I also liked Walter, the beginning scene with Pete or Nick, That creepy house scene with Carver, and just overall I liked it more than the other episodes...
At first I would have given it a 9, but now it's an 8 for me. I just hate how they handled Nick's death, and how Luke didn't give a shit neither.
Id give this thread a 8. I gave the other 20 threads on this topic a 8.5.
Isn't there a thread like this already? Mods are probably going to merge it.
Give it CPR.
There is but it died....
I'd give it a 9.5 out of 10 only complaint is how they handled Nicks death.
Im surprised nobody is annoyed about rebeccas death!!
7 because of what happen to nick and Sarah and not seeing any 400 people...but it was alright... I liked that episode
probably a 7 I liked it but I think they threw away some good characters like Sarah
7.5/10
Pretty good episode. It felt kind of long, had some hubs. Pretty good.
8/10
It was a great episode, they managed to fit in enough dialogues and good ones too, not to mention allot of badass moments.
But I felt like some of the characters died for no reason when they could've been further developed and play a bigger role in the story.
10/10, because Kenny didn't die
I give it 8/10
The only negative point is: POOR WRITING (for Nick's Death)
That f**king lazy writers killed Nick without one good reason.
7 or 8, but I tend to 7. It had some great elemens, but the death rate was almost annoying.
I mean, it was like Death, death, death, no time to let it sink in. Some deaths made sense (in a way), like Sarita (I hacked her arm off.. bad decision, but of course that led to her death) or maybe even Rebecca (childbirth is critical, especially without a sterile environment).
Sarah was kinda coming, but it hit me when I realized how father and daughter just.. vanished so quickly. I felt terrible because she just died when I saved her before, in that episode. And Nick? Killed off because he was determinant. That one I really did not like.
So, yes, most deaths had some reason or explanation but it was just too much
A strong six!
Seriously, I'd give it a 8.75, it was really good.