Crazy Notion! (SPOILERS)
Remmember that scene when just as Rebecca was shot, Luke -- willing to turn his head away from a man pointing a gun at him -- turned his head and yelled out "NO!"
Doesn't this imply...
That LUKE is the real father of Rebecca's baby?
(And I will acknowledge that there's a chance that someone brought this up).
I really don't know how that slipped my mind up until now -- his scream sounded dramatic and genuine, why did I dismiss it as being out of shock at the loss of a group member...
What are your thoughts? It would provide a proper and more shocking conclusion to the question of who the real father of Rebecca's baby is...
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
Apart from Luke, Rebecca was the last survivor in the Cabin group... until the end of Episode 4.
I actually call Luke the deuteragonist (tritagonist if you call it Kenny) of the game; he is the one who saved Clementine and isn't he the only one who stays with her throughout the whole episodes?
What kind of logic is that? Seriously?
Luke freaked out because he heard a gunshot go off and knew that everyone was going to start shooting. How on earth did you somehow jump to the conclusion that because he reacted, it somehow meant he was fucking Rebecca?
There are obscure theories, and there are stupid ones.
Really? Everyone knew? Well since I look a little silly with it all described there, I just edited it out. (If you actually aren't familiar with the special easter egg with Molly in episode 4 (I call it that cause you probably didn't encounter it on a first playthrough), then watch this (
)).
Anyway, Carver's voice actor (Mr Masden) actually confirmed it? Lemme go look that up doe...
Hmm, can't find it. You mind linking me to your source?
Well he was the first and only one to react.
And of course this is a theory, a fully unproven one at that, but it's just a theory.
And sure Luke was fucking Jane as well, but still, it feels almost symbolic to me how Luke was the only one who would call out to Rebecca.
And while I can understand why you would think this theory is stupid, I strongly disagree with you.
There's tons of dialogue supporting the fact that Rebecca had an affair with Carver while also still being loyal to her husband, Alvin. There's absolutely nothing supporting anything about Luke having sex with Rebecca.
If we go by your logic, Carlos, Nick and Pete all had sex with Rebecca too.
Not necessarily. My logic is that it isn't coincidental that Luke was the sole one to call out for Rebecca.
Or maybe Luke yelled because firing a shoot like that would kill most of their group? Him turning arround and yelling probably didn't "happen" tho. How stupid would one be to do that xD
On another note, leaving Carvers camp seems to have been the cabins group worst decision!
He knew her the best everyone else there knew her for like a couple days
It's confirmed by Alvin's voice actor, not Carver's.
Sorry it's quite a stupid theory
He just says "No !" because Clementine / Kenny opens fire (to kill rebecca)
In the confusion, russians don't know what's happening, they think clementine's group are shooting at them
Buricko answers and opens fire
Luke just says "No!" because he knows that, by hearing gunshot, russians would react, even if they were just killing zombified rebecca
He says "No!" because he's thinking "No don't start to shoot ! We had to kill rebecca zombified, we did not start to shoot AT YOU"
But it's too late
What did i just read? lol
I'm not dismissing this theory just yet but i suppose you all do have a point.
How did he confirm it? These forums, his twitter, an interview? And I'm pretty sure he isn't allowed to spoil his work, I wonder why'd he do that...?
Hang on, lemme get it for you.
http://walkingdead.wikia.com/wiki/The_Walking_Dead_Wiki_Interviews/Jim_Dorian_Lockett