Will Lilly Be in Episode 5?

Hey! Found a really good theory video I think will take you by surprise...
[

Comments

  • Theories are as trustworthy as politicians are these days...

  • edited August 2014

    (I'm directly replying to the title of this thread I haven't watched the video yet)

    I personally think that if they are going to put Lilly back in it they won't do it in episode 5, they would do it in season 3.

  • edited August 2014

    Well I dont think she is and it works now :p

  • Your nickname is funny ^^

    #TeamSarah posted: »

    (I'm directly replying to the title of this thread I haven't watched the video yet) I personally think that if they are going to put Lilly back in it they won't do it in episode 5, they would do it in season 3.

  • Yeah. The person making this video says that we could be overanalyzing things, so... yeah.

    Lingvort posted: »

    Theories are as trustworthy as politicians are these days...

  • Me too.

    #TeamSarah posted: »

    (I'm directly replying to the title of this thread I haven't watched the video yet) I personally think that if they are going to put Lilly back in it they won't do it in episode 5, they would do it in season 3.

  • I get that a lot. :) thank you. Though I don't know how much '#TeamSarah' matters anymore..

    Darwin_99 posted: »

    Your nickname is funny ^^

  • Oops! Sorry! I'll fix it!

    Kenny4Eva posted: »

    Well I dont think she is and it works now

  • I saw this theory video a few days ago I mean it would be a surprise if she returns..

    Oops! Sorry! I'll fix it!

  • Yeah... But could you imagine the cliffhanger that would be?

    Kenny4Eva posted: »

    I saw this theory video a few days ago I mean it would be a surprise if she returns..

  • edited August 2014

    It would be great to see her back as she was a cool character in season 1 even though I didn't like her she was some who was strong mentally. She was meant to be in the comics but Kirkman decided to write a book on her Called Road to Woodbury if i'm not mistaken.

    Yeah... But could you imagine the cliffhanger that would be?

  • Really? O.o Huh. I'll have to read that!

    Kenny4Eva posted: »

    It would be great to see her back as she was a cool character in season 1 even though I didn't like her she was some who was strong mentally

  • I've just started reading it today :D It's not the same Lilly though.

    Really? O.o Huh. I'll have to read that!

  • Isn't it but she was meant to be in the comics supposedly... but Kirkman dropped the ball on that one I believe.

    I've just started reading it today It's not the same Lilly though.

  • I hope Lilly returns but I'd rather she returned in season 3. I think she could make quite a cool antagonist.

  • edited August 2014

    ppl are still dreaming of lilly. but hey guys tbh, you're exaggerating already. even after everything that has happened in twd, you're still in thoughts of lilly returning.

  • It defo would be cool to see Kenny and Lily relive an old rivalry but I doubt will live after episode 5 unfortunately:(

    I hope Lilly returns but I'd rather she returned in season 3. I think she could make quite a cool antagonist.

  • Yeah! It would be really awkward. "Hi... LILLY??????!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

    I hope Lilly returns but I'd rather she returned in season 3. I think she could make quite a cool antagonist.

  • edited August 2014

    Lilly from the game was supposed to carry on into the comics and go to woodbury but then Robert Kirkman decided to write the book and it changed the backstory for Lilly in the comics. There was an achievement in season 1 that got changed I think.

    I'll try find it on the wiki.

    Kenny4Eva posted: »

    Isn't it but she was meant to be in the comics supposedly... but Kirkman dropped the ball on that one I believe.

  • I like your nickname tooz.

    #TeamSarah posted: »

    (I'm directly replying to the title of this thread I haven't watched the video yet) I personally think that if they are going to put Lilly back in it they won't do it in episode 5, they would do it in season 3.

  • Telltale don't really like leaving characters fate as unknown, just look at Kenny for example and we might be seeing Christa in the near future. But with Lily it has been over a year since we've seen so a lot could've o happened since we last seen her!

    Free_Dead posted: »

    ppl are still dreaming of lilly. but hey guys tbh, you're exaggerating already. even after everything that has happened in twd, you're still in thoughts of lilly returning.

  • Found this on the wiki.

    ◾Upon the release of the The Road to Woodbury novel, which features a different back-story for Lilly than the video game, the developer Telltale Games removed from the official website all references to Lilly being the same character from the comic series. Also, the in-game achievement that displays when Lilly leaves the group was changed from "Woodbury bound" to "What now?"

    Kenny4Eva posted: »

    Isn't it but she was meant to be in the comics supposedly... but Kirkman dropped the ball on that one I believe.

  • Yeah I believe the achievement was some along the lines of " Way to Woodbury" I know it had Woodbury in the achievement.

    Lilly from the game was supposed to carry on into the comics and go to woodbury but then Robert Kirkman decided to write the book and it cha

  • What if Lilly turned out to be the leader of Wellington or something and Clem and Kenny just turn up on the doorstep. That would be awkward XD

    Yeah! It would be really awkward. "Hi... LILLY??????!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

  • I believe in theories since theories always have a chance of being correct :p

  • edited August 2014

    I hope she will be, but telltale showed that they favour Kenny fans aaaages ago so I really don't think she will.

  • I doubt it. I mean Lily has a novel written by the creator called The long road to wood something...she has a lot of plot in there.

  • The novel contradicted the events of the game though, and so the Lillys are actually two separate characters now.

    sunfell posted: »

    I doubt it. I mean Lily has a novel written by the creator called The long road to wood something...she has a lot of plot in there.

  • edited August 2014

    I think the R.V. is supposed to be the same R.V. from the T.V. series.

    I the Pharmacy on a note-board there's a flyer for an Easter Egg Hunt at the Motel. I was wondering whether that's something put in to the game to tell us there's an Easter egg somewhere at the Motel. The best I can work out is that the Easter egg is actually the R.V. since it's got the same unreliable radiator hose.

    I know they don't look the same but if that's not the Easter Egg then what is or is the Easter Egg Hunt flyer just a red-herring or just random set-dressing that was included without the developers realising it could have a more meta meaning?

    Maybe the idea is we keep looking far the R.V. and that it might appear at least once in each series?

    If it was Cinema then that R.V. would be there for a reason, but here maybe not.

  • That won't help. How Lilly departed everyone (whether you left her or not) is different here though. You can't know what might have happened due to such a departure. Telltale not liking to inform us of anyone's fate is just a rumor lol.

    You can't just possibly, outta nowhere, just meet Lilly or find her body, it's hard right now. Many years have passed, and it'd be ridiculous/unrealistic. People talking about her, yes maybe, but meet, hard.

    Kenny4Eva posted: »

    Telltale don't really like leaving characters fate as unknown, just look at Kenny for example and we might be seeing Christa in the near fut

Sign in to comment in this discussion.