hmmmm seems someone else is dumb, not releasing the caps. Anyway, back to the point. Why is it stupid that Lilly would be in the Russian group? It's not impossible. Specially when you consider how many nationalities there were in the second world war for example.
Doesn't matter that Lilly is American, we all have our cross to bear.
You guys are really dumb...IT'S A DAMN RUSSIAN RUSSIAN RUSSIAN GROUP HOW COME SHE WILL BE IN IT WHILE SHE IS CAUCUSIAN-AMERICAN WTF IS WRONG WITH YOU PEOPLE??????!!!!!
I'm pretty sure the RV is just a reused model. You can also see the RV Shel and Becca had in the same trailer park. Although it's just a quick flash of that one, so I might be wrong. As for Lilly returning? It's just too contrived and unrealistic. Last time they saw her they were just outside of Macon in Georgia. Now it's about two years later and they are in Virginia. Meeting Kenny was pushing it enough already. I think Kirkman still has a say in some of the scripting and direction of the games, and I don't believe he would like something like that.
I don't really see the logic here. Not that I don't think Lily will ever return, its kind of likely since she got retconned into a separate character from the comics , but RV and Oxycontin don't really mean anything to me other than Arvo may be a drug addict and people live in RVs after the apocalypse.
Yes it would. Omid, Christa, and Clem were together from the start of S2 so they don't count as returning in the sense he is referring. Kenn… morey was the only character to actually leave the group and miraculously find his way back. That was unrealistic enough. Having the same fan service happen twice would be horrible.
Possible lol. Plus in 400 days what if the RV Shel has is the RV Kenny used. After Lily got away she parked the car in the place where Shel's group was.
Generally when people say Caucasian in America they mean white (granted, it's a misnomer). They tend not to distinguish between ethnic Russians and Armenians, Georgians, Azerbaijanis, etc. I don't know how people would know Lilly's ethnic background and I think the guy I was responding to was using it to mean 'white.'
Generally when people say Caucasian in America they mean white (granted, it's a misnomer). They tend not to distinguish between ethnic Russi… moreans and Armenians, Georgians, Azerbaijanis, etc. I don't know how people would know Lilly's ethnic background and I think the guy I was responding to was using it to mean 'white.'
I see your point, but having multiple returns is still not unrealistic, it's happened in many games before and it worked, besides, if past Seasons are to have importance, returning characters are a necessary.
Yes it would. Omid, Christa, and Clem were together from the start of S2 so they don't count as returning in the sense he is referring. Kenn… morey was the only character to actually leave the group and miraculously find his way back. That was unrealistic enough. Having the same fan service happen twice would be horrible.
A forced plot = a bad plot, which sounds like what you people want. I swear, if Lily miraculously shows up in episode 5 or in any other Walking Dead episode, I will never play it again. You people don't know what you're talking about.
He said 30 miles, which would be enough for her to manage some fuel from other cars along the way, she's a survivor and was apart of the military, I think she knows what she's doing.
How is it completely impossible? She knows how to kill Walkers and we even see Russell walking down the same road as the R.V. and it is heavily indicated that he has been walking for a while, so it's completely possible for Lilly to walk down a road to reach the R.V.
Whether you abandon her after she betrays you (in which case she's seen by all the walkers), or whether you take her along in which case she… more will betray you again (in which case she gets away with the RV), her death is not confirmed. At all.
If she abandons you, then... Well of course she'd have the RV.
If you abandon her, then I suppose it is completely possible that Lily caught up to the section of railroad where the group found the train and took the abandoned RV from there.
She could've just stumbled upon it, when people say it's too unrealistic... it's pretty impossible to tell unless it's been proven. There's allot of things we might've have missed that would tell us how realistic such things could turn out to be. It's not unrealistic to find someone alive when you almost knew for a fact they were dead, happens in real life y'know...
Unlikely, improbable, even implausible, but not impossible (I thought it implausible. For me Kenny was almost certainly dead and having him … morebrought back seemed too unrealistic but it is what it is.).
Lee being alive just seems to defy all possibility.
Edit: Oops wrong thread. It's not impossible that she could have spent the time off-screen tracking down the R.V. but it just seems completely unlikely to me without some kind of R.V.-centric revenge plot.
He said 30 miles, which would be enough for her to manage some fuel from other cars along the way, she's a survivor and was apart of the military, I think she knows what she's doing.
Also, the 400 days people all appeared (unless they didn't go with Tavia) and is that unrealistic? If Christa had heard about Wellington then why couldn't anyone else have?
I see your point, but having multiple returns is still not unrealistic, it's happened in many games before and it worked, besides, if past Seasons are to have importance, returning characters are a necessary.
I see your point, but having multiple returns is still not unrealistic, it's happened in many games before and it worked, besides, if past Seasons are to have importance, returning characters are a necessary.
Also, I'm glad you didn't leave, I can be a real dick sometimes. I'm living thru hard times now so I've become verbally more agressive. I'm really sorry, I know I hurt your feelings, it was VERY wrong what I said. I apologize :]
I honestly agree with this theory, and in my opinion, it really isn't much of a long shot, seeing as how it's been 16 months, and Lily could be anywhere. The chances of Clementine and Lily remeeting gets higher nearly every minute, since the human population is declining drastically.
Other games aren't held to the same standards on realism. For three different people, in different places, to take the exact same path and happen to be at the exact same point at the exact same time is hilariously outrageous. Once was bad enough.
I see your point, but having multiple returns is still not unrealistic, it's happened in many games before and it worked, besides, if past Seasons are to have importance, returning characters are a necessary.
That's because the purpose of 400 days was to introduce those characters making appearances in season two. They didn't leave the group and appear, they just happened to be the characters we ran into during season 2, and they gave us a DLC including them at the end of season 1 with no prior interaction.
Also, the 400 days people all appeared (unless they didn't go with Tavia) and is that unrealistic? If Christa had heard about Wellington then why couldn't anyone else have?
Other games aren't held to the same standards on realism. For three different people, in different places, to take the exact same path and happen to be at the exact same point at the exact same time is hilariously outrageous. Once was bad enough.
In my opinion your theories are weird sometimes but I respect them but about ''at least im being active here as a true TellTale fan.'' that was just a dick move
Comments
I hope that is not the case because if it is I will have to go back to season 1 episode 3 just to change that one decision.
Yeah, I never doubted that Lilly was Russian after her father showed his communist tattoos.
hmmmm seems someone else is dumb, not releasing the caps. Anyway, back to the point. Why is it stupid that Lilly would be in the Russian group? It's not impossible. Specially when you consider how many nationalities there were in the second world war for example.
Doesn't matter that Lilly is American, we all have our cross to bear.
I'm pretty sure the RV is just a reused model. You can also see the RV Shel and Becca had in the same trailer park. Although it's just a quick flash of that one, so I might be wrong. As for Lilly returning? It's just too contrived and unrealistic. Last time they saw her they were just outside of Macon in Georgia. Now it's about two years later and they are in Virginia. Meeting Kenny was pushing it enough already. I think Kirkman still has a say in some of the scripting and direction of the games, and I don't believe he would like something like that.
She mentioned oxytocin and then said hell, anything with opium in it about the stolen meds
I don't really see the logic here. Not that I don't think Lily will ever return, its kind of likely since she got retconned into a separate character from the comics , but RV and Oxycontin don't really mean anything to me other than Arvo may be a drug addict and people live in RVs after the apocalypse.
What has Lee's choice to do with how Lily responses to Clem?
Do you honestly think Telltale would put that kind of effort to make this choice affect anything? Just look at Ep. 4
Lilly was never obsessed with any drug, she only mentioned "oxy" as one of the medicines that were being stolen from the supplies for the bandits
Yes that's exactly what I'm saying, thanks Viva.
That makes no sense.I like lilly,but your theory(ies) are usually weird.
My theories might be weird, but at least im being active here as a true TellTale fan.
When was she ever addicted to drugs? I don't think Lilly would be the type of person to pull off something like that in the ZA.
What if that RV is Shel and Becca's RV though? Couldn't that be a possibility too?
Possible lol. Plus in 400 days what if the RV Shel has is the RV Kenny used. After Lily got away she parked the car in the place where Shel's group was.
Generally when people say Caucasian in America they mean white (granted, it's a misnomer). They tend not to distinguish between ethnic Russians and Armenians, Georgians, Azerbaijanis, etc. I don't know how people would know Lilly's ethnic background and I think the guy I was responding to was using it to mean 'white.'
Got you. I understand it wrong , because in Russia we calling Caucasians only Armenians, Georgians, Azerbaijanis etc.
i agree with your comment
I see your point, but having multiple returns is still not unrealistic, it's happened in many games before and it worked, besides, if past Seasons are to have importance, returning characters are a necessary.
We all have our opinion. Also, I remember when people talked the same about Kenny...
He said 30 miles, which would be enough for her to manage some fuel from other cars along the way, she's a survivor and was apart of the military, I think she knows what she's doing.
Well it depends, a person's ethnicity plays a role in their ability to learn new languages.
How is it completely impossible? She knows how to kill Walkers and we even see Russell walking down the same road as the R.V. and it is heavily indicated that he has been walking for a while, so it's completely possible for Lilly to walk down a road to reach the R.V.
She could've just stumbled upon it, when people say it's too unrealistic... it's pretty impossible to tell unless it's been proven. There's allot of things we might've have missed that would tell us how realistic such things could turn out to be. It's not unrealistic to find someone alive when you almost knew for a fact they were dead, happens in real life y'know...
it was gonna break down i believe
Also, the 400 days people all appeared (unless they didn't go with Tavia) and is that unrealistic? If Christa had heard about Wellington then why couldn't anyone else have?
This is a zombie apocalypse game though.
Who says its the Russians' group? Maybe they're part of Lilly's group and they can only stay because of Arvo
Well this is good theory but this is will be my just theory shes been killed by Stranger from EP5
LOL dude your a joke
Could be or at least part of the group.
Also, I'm glad you didn't leave, I can be a real dick sometimes. I'm living thru hard times now so I've become verbally more agressive. I'm really sorry, I know I hurt your feelings, it was VERY wrong what I said. I apologize :]
....dick move...I think...
I honestly agree with this theory, and in my opinion, it really isn't much of a long shot, seeing as how it's been 16 months, and Lily could be anywhere. The chances of Clementine and Lily remeeting gets higher nearly every minute, since the human population is declining drastically.
Other games aren't held to the same standards on realism. For three different people, in different places, to take the exact same path and happen to be at the exact same point at the exact same time is hilariously outrageous. Once was bad enough.
That's because the purpose of 400 days was to introduce those characters making appearances in season two. They didn't leave the group and appear, they just happened to be the characters we ran into during season 2, and they gave us a DLC including them at the end of season 1 with no prior interaction.
In my point of view, if it happens commonly enough in real life, it isn't too unrealistic for it to happen in games.
Yeah, but I think she knows a bit about fixing R.V.s, or at least someone new could have helped her.
I'm sorry, I forgot that this forum doesn't allow opinions...
I don't think so. But your theory isn't bad.
So you're comparing modern , real life to that of the fictional zombie apocalypse?.... do you see the flaw in this argument?
In my opinion your theories are weird sometimes but I respect them but about ''at least im being active here as a true TellTale fan.'' that was just a dick move