did any1 else feel sorry for lilly (not saying what she did was right please just read first)?
BenSawyer90
Banned
now B4 U HATE ON ME im not justifying what she did when she shot carly/doug, it was appalling and really bad
but lik put yourself in her position for a sec
All ur family is dead (killed quite brutally in front of ur own eyes as u tried to save them)
U tried to help the group by saying how medecine was missing and they called u crazy
Kenny tried to LEAVE U TO DIE IN THE MOTOR INN
An then carley calls her hurtful things (least bad but triggered emotional outbrake)
what she did was really really bad but i can understand why she acted how she did, ther is such little empathy on these forum
'forgive but don't forget' a wise man/woman once said - we should forgive lily if she apologises (she already did in my playthrough) but not forget she did what she did
im not sayin she was right to kill carley/doug just i can empathise with her you understand?
pls dont be mean an say im stupid for not hating her
ALSO: look at her face after she fires her gun: SHE IS SHOCKED AT WHAT SHE DID! SHE DOESN'T LOOK AT THEM WITH HAPPINESS AND MALICE, SHE LOOKS WITH GILT AND SHOCK
Comments
I did at first (even though I Saltlicked Larry, I thought he was going to turn..) But when she shot Carley (in my playthrough) I left her behind without hesitation, but IF she comes back, I understand she's had it rough so it depends on how she acts if I forgive her... (I really want her to team with Kenny so they could form an alliance but that might seem a little cliche) But remember Lilly coming back is just SPECULATION, (But those tweets are odd, she's either coming back, or Telltale is trolling us) I would like to see her come back but not in the same episode as Christas return so maybe in season 3 for me.. thoughts?
I agree I kinda feel sorry for her. I wouldn't forgive her for killing Carley or Doug but if she returned in season 3 I'd give her a chance.
she doesnt work for telltale so it wnt be them trolling
all that matters to me is that u r willing to forgive her, thats all that matters
some people say they will shoot her the second they see her (which is just as bad as what she did if not worse) which i find appalling (just my opinion)
I don't agree because she shot Carley for no reason If she was angry she could just punch her in the face... But no... She has to kill her in cold blood.
didnt u here she's probably gunna be in episode 5
It depends on how she acts IF we see her Again for me ... so we'll see..
It's just a rumour though isn't it? I'd rather she returned in season 3 because it might just feel like their squeezing her in if she comes back in episode 5.
no but i know it wasnt for a great reason but it wasn't for NO reason: she thought she was working against the group and she thought that by killing her she was helping
when you have undergone a traumatic experiance ur mind works in weird ways and seriously she just blew it out of proportion but she did still have (terrible) reasoning, it was bad but existant.
I'm talking about why we can FORGIVE HER even though she did kil (kim not saying she was right to kill)
she only killed because she had a horrible time and the group treated her like shit and tried to leave her to DIE (imagine how horrible that must have made her feel!)
her mind just bursted and she shot
it wasn't a 'cold blood' murder: it was very 'hot' blood fueled by anger, just like Lee killing the senator!
she might be cliffhanger
its a very strongly suppoorted rumour
Yeah, I would like her to return in Season 3, but her voice actor tweeted she just got done recording for a game or something like that... and Kennys voice actor retweeted it or at least I heard, we'll see what happens...
tht is fair enough
but if u shot her when u saw her tht isnt even giving her a CHANCE to act
Yes, I've always felt sorry for her. In my playthrough I tried to bring her along, but unfortunately she took off.
She really did genuinely care for the group, and one interesting bit of trivia is that she was the one who taught all the adults in the group how to shoot guns, and kept them on a strict military training regimen for the months they were at the motor inn, as mentioned by Lee in EP2. They had several offscreen bandit attacks happen over the course of these months, as also mentioned by the characters, which they were able to defend themselves against thanks to her training.
That act itself of giving them military training saved their lives in more than one occasion. Imagine if Lilly wasn't there? They'd most likely have fallen the moment the first bandit attack happened. What do you think would have happened to Clementine if they'd fallen to those Save-Lots bandits? Ever heard of Jolene and what they did to her daughter?
When the last bandit attack caused by Ben happened, she had the opportunity to sneak away and take off, leaving them to be killed by the bandits. And yet she still took the first shot, and saved everyone in the process. Despite that, Kenny still speeds off as she is trying to catch up to the RV. I do think he was going to leave her to die, there.
in my game she apologised when she left so in my opinion it was okay but thats not the case for everyone
i would have left in her situation too: the whole group hates me, kenny left me to die...
i'd feel like shit that didnt deserve to be with them, i think thats what lilly thought
Yeah, I'm not planning on doing THAT, Clem straight up murdering the woman who gave her the hair thingies, without even explaining herself would be too dark for Clem, I want to get to interact with Lilly then see how she is...
I don't mind if she does as long as it makes sense and doesn't feel forced. It could be pretty cool like maybe she's the leader of Wellington or something.
thats fair enough
plus as pride says below something worth considering is that she taught the group how to use guns between episode 1 and two and kept them on a strict military regimen
without her they could easily have all died in the bandit attacks
Maybe she will come back in episode 5 then. There was the whole RV thing in episode 4 too.
nope hell I agree she is an interesting character and there is potential left in her so I'm
glad we will be seeing her BUT she is a horrible person for what she did
I supported her when Kenny killed her father and I was with her from the beginning and then she suddenly
gets paranoid and crazy and just kills carley who Lee liked (at least in my playthrough) because she said hurtful things to her??
From that moment on I wanted to kill her so because we couldn't I left her and if the option is given (to leave her to die or to just
make her feel bad because of what she did I will choose that)
she was a horrible person at that specific time but people can change, people can feel guilty for past actions
i remind u that LEE KILLED SOMEONE! HE MURDERED SOMEONE!
HOW WAS LILLY KILLIN CARLY WORSE THAN LEE KILLIN THE SENATOR
If u can forgive lee 4 that u can forgive lilly for this
do u think lee is a horrible person for what he did to the senator?
we've all done bad stuff in the past, it doesn't make us 'horrible people' all the time
she gets paranoid and crazy because kenny and other group memebers are horrible to her and dont trust her
kenny left her to DIE in the motor inn i remind you, before she did anything wrong! that is appalling!
if your group had tried to ABANDON you you'd feel pretty shitty okay, she was very fragile at that time and she broke
I think that, if I were in her situation, I would've snapped as well. So, because of that, I do sympathize with her and want her to come back eventually.
i think in dougs situation her position was even more understandable as ben was the thief so she was trying to protect the group still
sorry for forgetting him though i'll try not to do that in future
Remember Doug?
It's not just you, it's as if every time we remember this it's. "Carley was shot", and "Carley will be missed", but Doug is overlooked.
I'm not mad, and you can always edit your post
Pepperidge farm remembers.
I don't think its any more understandable. She was still about to murder someone just like she murdered Carley. Even though Ben was the thief there were better ways to deal with it than just trying to shoot him.
that true actually
so less understandable but still understandable
jajajaja
teameveryonewho'snice
No I dont feel sorry for her
TeamDoug
I think the word your looking for is understandableish :P
no idea why you always bring Lee up sure he killed the senator but it was an accident
(or so he said in my playthrough) he didn't do it on purpose and he was the protagonist and Clems guardian
not even a justified comparison he was an awesome character don't even try to put him in the same
league as Lily
Lily just took her gun out and shot Carley
not sure how that wasn't on purpose she even shot her in the head
fucking bitch no idea how people can forgive her
sure if you didn't like Carley I understand but she was one of my favourite characters
and when Lily killed her that was way too much don't care about the reasons
hopefully you understand stop with your lily obession
oh I hated her for shooting lovely Carly, but her comeback would be a great thing for the game, hope she does
did u hate lee for murdering the senator
jajaja i like this word
nop
No. I did not feel sorry for her in the slightest.
so why would u hate her for shooting carley, how is lee murdering the senator better than lilly murdering carley
tht doesn't answer any of the reasons i brought up as to why u should
ignorin them is just being closeminded
lol... its just a game remember? don't need to get too deep into that, and I love this game because of that, that it gets you emotionly involved, make u angry sad happy etc. that's the point, that's why game works so well
answering your question, no not better, but Lee redeemed himself for that, I hope Lilly does too 