Old Clementine or new Clementine
Hey so I was wondering if people like the new Clementine or if they prefer the season 1 young Clementine?
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Hey so I was wondering if people like the new Clementine or if they prefer the season 1 young Clementine?
Comments
They're the same person
I liked Season One Clementine better. Season Two Clementine has no personality.
Clem 1 is pretty cool
And again I have to use recaptcha lol
I like them both. Season 1 Clem was cute and innocent while season 2 Clem is tougher and more of a badass.
That's just like me!
I like season 1 Clementine. Only cuz Lee was alive
I know right, Lee was perfect. He had personality and he was a protagonist.
True that.
If this S2 Clementine was a completely new character and we never knew the younger Clem then I'm sure everyone else would straightaway see that she is a boring kid with no personality whatsoever.
Well If they keep her alive next episode, i hope they rotate the Protagonist, again. Another Season of Player Controlled Clementine is like getting socks and underwear for Christmas.
Yeah and someone with emotion maybe Bonnie? Well we should first see who survives the gun fight
I would be fine with anyone. I think Bonnie would do a great job.
I'll be happy as long as Clem isn't the PC again, maybe Lily comes back and is the next PC.
I like S1 Clem better.
What if its Kenny Lilly and Clementine for Season 3. That would be funny.
At first the idea of Clem as the PC was good but it has turned out to be mediocre. Playing as an adult Male you can do all kinds of things.
Well, in Season 2 you are playing as Clementine, remember? And if you are familiar with this particular game, you'll know that you literally get to choose what Clementine says, and mold her "personality". So if you're Clementine has no personality, well then I guess you'll have to pick some dialogue that gives her one.
Season 1 by a landslide
What exactly was so interesting about her in season 1?
Season two by a long shot
Well, I'd like to see them as both the same person, just molded by the world for what they needed to be. In season 1, she doesn't exactly need to fend for herself like she does in season 2, she has Lee, so she becomes more of a moral compass and moral supporter. But in season 2, she's lost Lee and needs to change in order to survive. I guess it just depends on the situation. If I had to choose which one to hang out with, or protect, I'd choose Clementine's season 1 personality, but if she had to survive on her own, or with a group of random people that really don't care for each other, like season 2's group, I'd have to say Clementine's season 2 personality. I guess I'd prefer cute, innocent Clem from season 1, but you can still make her rather innocent and sweet in season 2 depending how you play.
In season 1 Clem was cute but in season 2 she is tough
I like both of them.
In season 1 she was so innocent and pure that you had to love her, and yet a strong-willed character who isn't scared to say what she thinks, even when everybody else has a different opinion (like when the group wants to steal supplies from the car in the woods, or when Kenny says that there is no place on the boat for Ben).
In season 2 we get Sassy Clem, and she is much more funny and badass, keeping her strong personality and teaching some lessons to grown-up men...
I can't choose, I like them both XD
Old by far
Yet we're the people controlling her?
It shows how much horror has gotten to her, that's why she's so silent and keeps to herself at times.
Seeing as in Season 1, she had the personality of a little girl. She didn't experience all the havoc without someone there, where in Season 2, no one is there to stop her from seeing it, like Lee was.
Now, we see her as SASSY BADASS MOFO CLEMENTINE, WHO DON'T TAKE SHIT FROM NO BODY.
yeah.
Season 2 Clementine is Voltron, so automatically is better.
Sorry super cute cool season 1 Clementine, you're just not Voltron material.
I prefer the younger Clem, but people change whether you like it or not. She became tough and i still like her, but sometimes i feel like she's a lack of something. I mean not even a teardrop can be found in her eyes, yet so many people die around her.. I hope she'll survive and we can see her as a young adult.
Same person just a little older.. All people change a bit as they age and according to their environment.
When we first met Clem she was simply an innocent 8yo girl, now she's 11 with 2 years of zombie apocalypse survival expirence. That would change anyone to a point!
Why not both?
I like season 2 Clementine better.
-Ready for downvotes
I do not know, but at some point should be a badass ... why? they are two years living without Lee (I'm sure Clementine not remember Lee's face if not it were by Lee's picture and surely forgotten the face of her parents), besides being cared later by Christa (you know who is Christa? ) she is a cynical person, with a strong personality without actually being selfish and I'm sure she transfers some of her personality to Clementine after Omid die in the 16 month skiptime.
I doubt she remained sweet and dependent after two years.
Is the same case with Carl in the comic, the problem is that Carl is a crazy and dangerous, more lethal than Clem.
Season 1 The classy Clem we all know and love
Season 2 I'm sorry, but it feels like im FORCING MYSELF to think that's Clementine. Maybe its the skin, the personality, the voice change, but that isn't the Clem i know and love
There were many cute clem moments in season 1, that we will never forget. R.I.P Clemmy Clue