Who Would Win In A Fight To The Death Round 1

  1. Jane Vs Molly

  2. Carver Vs Roman

  3. Kenny Vs Nate

  4. Mike Vs Luke

  5. Carley Vs Christa

Bonus Round: Maybelle Vs Juicy

Comments

  • My Personal Opinions:

    1. Jane- More tactical

    2. Carver(We already saw how that turned out, but it probably want a fair fight.)

    3. Kenny- He's invincible!

    4. Mike- He's stronger.

    5. Carley- She's a badass crack shot.

  • 1.Molly (Close match but Hilda would give her the advantage)
    2. Carver
    3. Kenny (Godlike Beard)
    4. Mike (Eats the shit out of raccoons, Urban Powers)
    5. Carley (I think she's a better shot)
    6. Bonus Round The collision causes a massive explosion where both competitors receive a Godlike stache...

  • Molly

    Carver

    Kenny

    Mike

    Christa

  • I think Nate would win a fight against Kenny, we've all seen how Kenny ''fights'' in the train. Nate's psychotic nature could give him some advantage (As well as it could also be a disadvantage). But who knows...

  • edited August 2014

    Kenny's hand to hand has improved a lot since Season 1, He's able to overpower Mike(Who is a strong guy) and after Clem shoots or jumps on Carver, Kenny punches him knocking him back a bit, and Kenny was able to take an almost fatal beating from Carver and got up like it was nothing. So in short, Kenny is a tough guy to take down.

    I think Nate would win a fight against Kenny, we've all seen how Kenny ''fights'' in the train. Nate's psychotic nature could give him some advantage (As well as it could also be a disadvantage). But who knows...

    1. Molly
    2. Carver (heh Roman is no match for him)
    3. Kenny
    4. Mike
    5. Carley
  • edited August 2014

    Molly: She is a lot faster and more agile, plus she has that weapon whatever it's called

    Carver: There probably was a gun battle between them and had Carver on the wining side

    Kenny: He's a lot stronger since Season 1

    Mike: He's the strongest member of the group(Besides Kenny)

    Carley: She's better shot

    And here's some of my own

    Lee VS Carver

    Clem VS Becca

    Arvo VS Reggie(Crippe fight!)

    Christa VS Rebecca(Pregnant fight!)

    Ben VS Sarah(Who's more useless fight!)

  • Molly is superior to Jane in every way and that is the only fight I care about

    1. Molly.

    2. Mr. Blonde, i mean Carver.

    3. Tie.

    4. Mike.

    5. Christa.

  • I disagree with that last scenario.

    bloop posted: »

    Molly: She is a lot faster and more agile, plus she has that weapon whatever it's called Carver: There probably was a gun battle between

  • They made the fight like that for GP purposes.

    I think Nate would win a fight against Kenny, we've all seen how Kenny ''fights'' in the train. Nate's psychotic nature could give him some advantage (As well as it could also be a disadvantage). But who knows...

  • edited August 2014

    Double post..

    I think Nate would win a fight against Kenny, we've all seen how Kenny ''fights'' in the train. Nate's psychotic nature could give him some advantage (As well as it could also be a disadvantage). But who knows...

  • edited August 2014

    I was only kidding with the last one, but most people say they're useless, annoying and cause people to die.

    BenUseful posted: »

    I disagree with that last scenario.

  • Lee (Carver would only need a sneak attack to be over powered)
    Clem (Becca doesn't have nearly as many survival skills as Clementine)
    Arvo ( Reggie is too nice I don't think he has to guts to even hit someone unless hes forced to do so)
    Christa ( Rebecca is even larger than Christa without being pregnant, Christa could move faster and do some damage)

    bloop posted: »

    Molly: She is a lot faster and more agile, plus she has that weapon whatever it's called Carver: There probably was a gun battle between

  • My own:

    1. Lee vs Troy.

    2. Kenny vs Andy St. John.

    3. Ralph vs Mike.

    4. Walter vs Nick.

    5. Buricko vs Luke.

    6. Ben vs. Arvo.

    7. Travis vs Carver. Travis, IMO. MY DAD WAS SPECIAL FORCES!

    8. Kenny vs Vitali.

    9. Carlos vs Roman.

    10. Eddie vs Nate.

    11. Jerry vs Marcus Crabtree.

    12. Stranger vs Vernon.

    13. Chet vs Omid.

    14. Larry vs Buricko.

  • edited August 2014

    Lee

    Kenny

    Mike

    Nick

    Ben

    Luke

    Travis

    Kenny

    Carlos

    Eddie

    I don't who those 2 are

    The Stranger

    Omid

    Buricko

    My own: * Lee vs Troy. * Kenny vs Andy St. John. * Ralph vs Mike. * Walter vs Nick. * Buricko vs Luke. * Ben vs. Arvo.

  • edited August 2014
    • Molly
    • Carver
    • Kenny
    • Mike
    • Carley
  • Jerry and Marcus are from Vince's story.

    And you skipped some of them.

    bloop posted: »

    Lee Kenny Mike Nick Ben Luke Travis Kenny Carlos Eddie I don't who those 2 are The Stranger Omid Buricko

  • Hmm, good point.

    bloop posted: »

    Kenny's hand to hand has improved a lot since Season 1, He's able to overpower Mike(Who is a strong guy) and after Clem shoots or jumps on C

    1. Hilda xD
    2. Carver
    3. Hard to say, but Kenny would probably win
    4. Mike
    5. Carley
  • Jane
    Carver
    KENNNNNNNNYYYYYYY
    Mike
    Carley

  • That's what my list would say.

    My Personal Opinions: * Jane- More tactical * Carver(We already saw how that turned out, but it probably want a fair fight.) * Kenny- He's invincible! * Mike- He's stronger. * Carley- She's a badass crack shot.

    1. Molly
    2. Carver
    3. Kenny
    4. Mike
    5. Christa

    Bonus Round: Maybelle would drink the shit out of Juicy.

  • Pregnant Christa vs Pregnant Rebecca?

  • Yup.

    DoubleJump posted: »

    Pregnant Christa vs Pregnant Rebecca?

  • 1.) Molly, she is quick and very smart, I mean she beats up Lee (determiant) and knocks Kenny on his ass even if Lee doesn't mention Kennys behind her

    2.) Roman, we know that Carver gets taken out by Kenny in one punch (I say taken out because Carver was fighting for his life but was defeated with one slug to the face) plus Roman seems like the kind of guy who's scrapped before

    3.) Tie

    4.) Tie, although Mike is very strong, Luke seems to be smarter and faster, so it really depends on the situation to see who would win

    5.) Yet another tie

  • I've got some!

    Ben. vs Larry.

    Sarah. vs Lee.

    Duck. vs Carver.

    Becca. vs Mike.

    Who would win? :D

  • Carver

    Clem

    Reggie

    Christa

    Sarah

    bloop posted: »

    Molly: She is a lot faster and more agile, plus she has that weapon whatever it's called Carver: There probably was a gun battle between

  • Larry, Lee, Carver, Mike (He would beat the shit out of those Beccoons)

    Emyl19 posted: »

    I've got some! Ben. vs Larry. Sarah. vs Lee. Duck. vs Carver. Becca. vs Mike. Who would win?

  • lee, kenny, mike, nick, ben, Buricko(he seems a lot stronger. With guns, maybe luke), Carver, Kenny, Nate, Stranger, Omid, Buricko

    Jerry and Marcus are from Vince's story. And you skipped some of them.

  • Jane

    Carver

    Kenny

    Mike

    Carley

  • Molly

    Carver

    Nate

    Mike

    Christa

  • edited August 2014

    I think it depends on if they have their signature weapons or not.

    Fist fights:

    1)I'd say Molly wins, she seems to just be generally a better fighter than Jane.

    2)My money's on Roman, I reckon we are supposed to assume neither side will have loyal guards wielding AKs.

    3)I think Nate wins, Kenny's never been actually good at fighting. Besides, Nate might just pull a Rick (TV show) and tear Kenny's throat with his teeth, for all we know.

    4)This one's the hardest for me, but I believe Mike would be victorious. This is basically a 'strength vs agility' scenario. However, I think this fight is the least likely to happen out of these 5: neither Luke nor Mike seem to be the kind of guys to resort to violence when there's a problem. I'd also like to point out that neither has truly proven to have good fighting skills: Mike is strong, but can he actually make good use of all that strength in a brawling situation? Luke is also strong (I don't think he's as strong as Mike though, but no way to be sure about that) and somewhat agile. But then again, neither of the two has been in a brawl that we've witnessed (Kenny holding Mike against the wall shouldn't count as Mike wasn't even really trying).

    5)Carley, I think she's probably really fierce when angered, though the post-Omid's death Christa seems to be really tough.

    Bonus Round) Maybelle, stomp stomp

    Armed fights, but still somewhat balanced (no guns vs melee weapons)

    1)Hilda (Molly) vs Screwdriver (Jane): Hilda has better reach and can inflict more damage, while screwdriver is really easy to wield. I think Hilda, wielded by Molly, wins.

    2)Well, Roman will probably just have a pistol whereas Carver would have an AK: Carver wins

    3)Rifle vs Rifle: Kenny has proven he has very good aim, much better than what we've seen from Nate: Kenny would stand a better chance this time

    4)Machette (Luke) vs Sledgehammer (Mike): Well, both of them are really deadly, but even though Mike IS really strong, the hammer is much heavier and more difficult to swing around. Still, it's a one-hit K.O. weapon, whereas the machette needs to cut through a vital blood vessel/organ in order to kill. Yet, I do believe Luke could dodge the first hit and then quickly strike back, so I'd say the odds are in his favor for this scenario: 60-40 Machette wielded by Luke.

    5)If both have a pistol, Carley wins hands down. If Christa has a Rifle, she stands a better chance but I still think Carley wins in both cases.

    Bonus Round) Juicebox would use his nuclear abilities and end the zombie apocalypse, but by doing so, he would also extinguish every life form in the planet. :(

Sign in to comment in this discussion.