Who else Realized that ** wasn't dead?
Who else figured out that AJ wasn't dead?
At first when i Saw Jane i got really upset and then thought to myself that the baby might still be alive,The moment Kenny goes out of the door all mad like and Jane tells Clementine to watch What Kenny is going to do i realized that the Baby is still Alive.
Did you guys also Realize he was Alive?
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
I suspected he was alive, but I figured out that whatever Jane did to him was on purpose.
When I saw Jane, I remembered the kind of person she was, when she gave Clementine that look, I knew that she was hiding the baby and after telling Clementine to stay back no matter what happens, I knew what Jane was playing at.
I figured AJ was still alive, but i still sided with Kenny.
I guessed he was okay, but you can't be sure. Jane might of just been saying stay out of it because she knew what Kenny was capable of.
I'll honestly admit that I couldn't tell Jane was lying. When I heard him crying in the distance, my heart jumped.
Honestly? I wasn't sure what to think. At first I thought that she really left AJ (=he's dead) because back in the car she wanted to leave with Clem but without the baby. She said back then "Clem, I know he's close to you but Kenny would never leave him behind" or something like that so I really thought Jane left the baby = killed him because what are the chances for such little being to survive on his own? None. When I discovered what Jane did I was kind of mad at her. I understand what she tried to show me but... well I don't know. I guess I was mad at her that she put AJ at danger just to prove a point. Think about this - what if Clementine couldn't heard his cry? What if she could never find him at this moment?
That's why I shot Kenny. If the baby was still alive as she hinted she was the only one that knew where it was. Jane and Kenny were both wrong for what they did. I left her on my main play through.
Yeah but what if he wasn't alive? I can say that I don't know why I didn't shot Kenny. I wanted to but... I just couldn't. I almost shot him but just before timer run out I chose "look away". I guess I really believed back then that Jane left AJ just to escape the walkers and then knowing what Kenny will do she warned Clementine to stay out of it.
Like I said - I don't know for sure why I didn't killed Kenny. Maybe because he was with us from season 1, maybe because we have too much history with each other despite that he was an ass**** sometimes for me in episode 4 for example or maybe because I believed that Jane left AJ for good. I don't know. Anyway I can say that back in that moment I kind of believed that she left the baby. She said it was accident but... maybe she tried to escape and then walker grabed AJ. I don't know.
So many thoughts back then. Too many of them.
I saw it coming from miles away, not so sure about my Clementine. Jane sort of gave it away with the whole I'll show you what he's really like act.
I at first i killed Kenny,i feel i betrayed him....everything we went through since season 1.... ='(
i was very unsatisfied with my ending so i changed it and let Kenny do his thing...it was sad i was mad that one of em' had to die
But That moment with Kenny when he begged That woman to Let CLementine and AJ into Wellington made me realize i did the right choice....When Kenny was dead i felt like a part of me was missing,When Jane died i was still sad but felt a little bit better...Overall this Episode has left me Empty inside :''|
Yes.... Exactly like me :P
You and me both.
I ended up with Kenny in my first playthrough and when I saw other endings on YouTube I understood that I made the right choice. I mean... I don't like other endings as much as the ones with Kenny so I didn't change anything. 
I "allowed" Kenny to kill her....I just always wanted to keep Kenny alive until the end, cause Lee said in Clementine's dreams: "Sometimes you got to protect your loved ones even if you hurt the others" (something similar.)
That's true :'C
I completely agree with you......when I heard that soundtrack in the end, from the first season (I believe the song is called Alive Inside) that left me basically paralyzed in my room in the middle of the night, I was so.....so fu**ing sad and everything else at the same time... Best episode ever...Well yeah I even cried a little in the end..
I saw right through Jane's intentions. I thought there was a high chance that the baby could be alive and she was just trying to prove her point, but the chaos that followed right after the fight broke didn't give me enough time to think about where AJ could be. Then, when Kenny called Jane a babykiller, it made me doubt her true intentions, it made me doubt if she was being honest.
I have to admit that I really disliked the post-fight dialogue options with Jane. All the choices are pretty much "oh, I can't believe you were lying!" despite the fact that she asked Clementine to trust her true intentions. It was almost like the developers were trying to punish me for my choices. At least they gave us a "forgive her" option.
I figured there was more to the situation than Jane sans baby, so I tried to break them up every chance the game gave me. Wanted to know the full story.
If nothing else, Jane seemed smarter than to lose the baby and still show her face to Kenny. Something had to be up.
It's weird. I thought at first that Jane was lying about the baby when she acted all sketchy about it. But when Kenny came back in with that psychotic look on his face, asked her how she could have killed a baby, and her reaction was "It was an accident," I concluded that the baby must have actually been dead. It sounded like what Kenny saw was a corpse or blood puddle or something along those lines and what Jane said only made it sound more like there was an "accident" scene. So yeah. It was a truly despairing couple of minutes there before the baby cried.
I also didn't like that 2nd dialogue option for some reason
I tried to break the fight all the time,i swear i was watching them kill each other and i was helpless to stop them,i felt so bad
Hopefully in Season 3 Clementine will hit the Gym and get dat Muscle mass to stop shit like that from happening again.
It was obvious that Jane hadn't killed/lost AJ because of her complete change in tone of voice and inflection after Kenny ran out, and I knew she had hid him somewhere in order to provoke Kenny so that she could be rid of him.
This was basically a version of her running away with Clementine.
I shot Kenny since he's an unstable crazy who will and has become completely unhinged at the thought of the baby dieing, with Jane being the more levelheaded one.
Yeah. The soundtrack with Kenny was also very very good. I mean the one that played during Kenny's death and at the Wellington when he tries to convince Edith to let Clementine and AJ in so they could be safe. I'm talking about this one if you're still curious.
God damn it man...God damn it telltale...God damn it feels
This is one of the best Franchises i ever played
Well depending on if was it was an accident as she claimed to Kenny before they started fighting I wouldnt hold it against her. For all we know Clem could of accidentally got Crista's baby killed. That didnt give Crista the right to kill Clem if so. Taking care of babies is hard in the zombie apocalypse.
Jane was wrong for lying and putting the baby in danger but not enough to be sentenced to death. I left her though because of that in my first play through.
But the solo with baby ending was BS on TTGs part because they didnt let you have the option of going to Wellington alone. ( If you were so close why wouldnt you go check it out at least -.-)
Im glad TTG made the Wellington for the people that went with Kenny and let everyone magically find the baby without Jane. It would of made people rage more didn't do that.
The solo ending should really give you the option of going there but that's probably asking to much of TTG. Its alright though since no ending is truly a bad ending or non canon. Its set up so that Clem lives with the baby in every ending, Determinate characters can be easily killed off, and everyone will start off the same when her story picks back up.
Pure truth
Every single second spent waiting for all the episodes was 100% worth it.
I suspected that she'd done something other than kill/lose it, but my thoughts on the baby went completely out the window once the two started trying to kill each other.
And now we have to spent another year or two waiting for season 3 but after season 1 and 2 I'm more than sure that it'll be worth it.
That's the beauty of this game. Everyone can make their own, personal choices, right? I think that I felt like... Kenny was with us from the season 1 and I know he's tough to like but I didn't want him to die. He's brutal to others sometimes but he could never hurt Clementine because he really care about her. Jane on the other hand left us in episode 4 and then in episode 5 put AJ in danger just to prove a point. Kenny never would've done something like that to Clem. At least in my opinion but like I said - this is why this game is so beautiful. Everyone has their own point of view on certain situation and can make their own choices.
I knew he wasn't dead from the moment Jane walked in.What i was wondering was where he was?
Of course, it was pretty obvious the baby was still alive.
I didn't think the baby was alive. I had already decided I was done with Jane and her manipulative nature though. I shot Kenny but not to help Jane in my mind. I figured Kenny was too far gone and it was time for him to die. Still liked him better than any of the other group members even at the end. He was no Lee but he was a better person than all the new characters in my opinion......flaws and all.
At first, I didn't know what to think. But when Kenny went outside to look for AJ and came back very pissed, I figured that he found his corpse or something. So yeah, I believed he was dead.
I also thought he was dead. I just didn't see a way for her to keep him safe outside. Before we reached the rest stop it was literally walkers and snow, and she came from the same direction we did. Kenny's reaction didn't help matters, I figured he saw a body or something (I asked "Is it true?").
Her calm cool voice telling me that she would reveal Kenny's 'true' personality honest to god freaked me out. She had been obsessed with telling me that Kenny was unstable and trying to sow the seeds of discontent through the whole game, I was thinking - why are you trying to talk to me about Kenny when you threw the baby to the walkers to escape? Or left it outside in the cold to die?
After all that talk about being protective of her younger sister and then leaving her to die, and telling me to leave Sarah - I thought, the baby can't talk back about what has happened to it,* it had no say in what just happened*. Truth to be told, I saw red just as much as Kenny at the point and wanted to kill her too. I thought the baby was dead, but to honest even if he was not I still saw red - because to me, leaving him is just as bad as killing him.
I thought Kenny might have seen his corpse outside as well, as Pipas said - and when Jane went on about Kenny's personality I flipped, I thought - you are gone, there is no saving you. I really liked Jane and Kenny, both of these characters had an amazing standoff and both were interesting. I should bring myself to do the Jane ending on a different save as it is obvious the story is branching out - but man, bringing myself to see things from Jane's POV will be hard - but interesting I guess.
Yea as soon as she put her hands on my shoulders and her sudden mood change I knew the baby was still alive... And then I saw Kenny walking back all angry and I was like... "Ok, Kenny... lets see how too far gone you have become" Of course I had to end with Kenny anyway but still...