Alternate Ending if Kenny did not appear?
I've been wanting to write this a long time but do you think the final choice could have possibly been different?
I was thinking what if it was Carlos vs. Jane instead of the Kenny situation? Think about it, Carlos would have been devestated if Sarah was killed, he would have cracked. Plus there were numerous times that said he could have had a temper, such as in the cabin when Luke tells Sarah that Carlos is a good guy and won't doing anything crazy?
I think it could have worked especially since a lot of Kenny's parts in the story could have correlated brilliantly with Carlos if he wasn't killed in Episode 3?
What do you guys think?
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
Carlos and Pete could and should have done everything Kenny did in game in season 1
Sarah = Dead.
AWWW HELLL NAW.
That he sedates 3 of her limbs and then says "oraleh ,come get me puta...c'mon skip skip... SKIEP!!! ye can do it bumpbumpbump c'mon !!!" something like ace ventura 2
Characters wouldn't be overshadowed and we would get actual character development.
You feel?
.
No one would kill Carver and they would all be back at Howe's.
(ignore this)
If nobody living killed Carver then somebody dead would have.
A happier one.
I felt like Christa could have maybe filled Kenny's role. I mean, she's actually spent the last 2 years wallowing in misery rather than finding new love and, unlike Kenny, it would actually make sense for her to imprint on AJ and get all crazy and protective about him.
Carlos would've played Kenny's role and Sarah would have died instead of Sarita (we would have cut off her arm).
After playing episode 1 I thought Sarah was going to go from being a nice friend into a crazed person and you would have to choose to side with her or kill her at the end. But any story without Kenny would have been fine by me.
uhhuhhh...
Hard to say how season 2 would have turned out, really. Though I do agree with the thought that the other characters like Alvin and Carlos, for example, would have gotten more screen-time, focus, and development. Or had more of a chance for that, at least.
The group might have taken Luke's suggestion and hunkered down at Howe's waiting for the right time to bail. Luke acts as the glue of the group (reminds me of when he tells Clem, 'a group's only as strong as its leader') so if he were to stay alive for a while there's a chance that conflicts within the group wouldn't be scarily intense. I won't say 'definitely wouldn't be' because it's impossible to say for sure, but I do feel like he'd do his best to keep folks together and try to get them to chill (barring his own moments of frustration). Now I'm imagining Carlos losing Sarah and possibly blaming Luke for it in his anger and grief. Wouldn't have been pretty, that's for sure.
Carlos vs Jane would be good. Just replace kenny for carlos and AJ for sarah. Carlos see Jane and Sarah traped in the car after a crash, but cant help because the walkers are close. So he run. He find clem in the stop and ask for sarah, after this Jane enters the stop without her, So carlos blame Jane for sarah death. using almost the same words as kenny
How can you kill my daughter ?!
It was an accident, was impossible to save her!
Bullshit! you never cared about her! you almost left her to die in the deck!
Dont come near me you son of a bitch!
Fight
carlos upon Jane ready to kill her
me: [Shoot carlos,] easy
Jane telling the truth this time, sarah dead.
But I think the choice would be very easy, even if Jane who was going to kill Carlos, i would still pick her. i would Choose her all the times, except when kenny is involved. kenny >>>>>> Jane >>>>> others. So the final choice was really hard to me, i liked the original fight. because i like both of them
I actually think the final decision would have been easier for me had it been Carlos. I wasn´t that attached to him.
Decisions between Jane, Christa, Kenny and Luke would have been hard for me, though.
Luke or Clem? Luke or Lee?
We play as Clem so I can´t decide on her...and Lee died in the first season.
If you mean my choice then obviously them above anyone.
Sorry , but i have to do something:
I can´t see that but the URL says "Luke dead" so...