›

Rate the Telltale Games

choircorgischoircorgis
edited January 2016 in General Chat

In your opinion, based on the games you've played, what are the best Telltale games in order?

Mine:

  1. Walking Dead
  2. Game of Thrones
  3. Borderlands
  4. The Wolf Among Us

UPDATE: Because I've been playing Minecraft and I finished Game of Thrones and Borderlands, my new order looks like this:

  1. Tales From the Borderlands
  2. Walking Dead
  3. Game of Thrones
  4. Minecraft
  5. The Wolf Among Us

Continue with the discussion. :)

«134567…12

Comments

  • AlfMusicAlfMusic

    Here is my list:
    1. Borderlands
    2. Game of Thrones
    3. The Walking Dead
    4. The Wolf Among Us

  • JamesDalton1995JamesDalton1995

    1. The Wolf Among Us

    2. The Wolf Among Us again

    3. Tales From The Borderlands

    4. Game of Thrones

    5. Walking Dead

  • freelancepolicefan11freelancepolicefan11
    edited February 2015

    1. Sam & Max: The Devil's Playhouse

    2. The Wolf Among Us

    3. Tales From The Borderlands so far

    4. The Walking Dead Season's 1 and 2

    5. Sam & Max: Beyond Time and Space

    6. Game of Thrones so far

    7. Back To the Future

    8. Sam & Max: Save The World

    9. Tales of Monkey Island

    10. Strongbad's: Cool Games for Attractive people

    11. Puzzle Agent

    12. Hector: badge of Carnage

    13. Jurassic Park

    14. Bone

  • dojo32161dojo32161 Moderator
    edited March 2015
    1. Tales From The Borderlands
    2. The Wolf Among Us
    3. The Walking Dead Season 1
    4. Sam & Max: The Devil's Playhouse
    5. Back To The Future: The Game
    6. Sam & Max: Beyond Time and Space
    7. Game of Thrones
    8. Sam & Max Save The World
  • Saltlick123Saltlick123
    edited February 2015
    1. The Walking Dead Season 1/ The Wolf Among Us (Tie)
    2. The Walking Dead Season 2
    3. Jurassic Park
    4. Law and Order Legacies
    5. Back to the Future
  • RevecRevec
    edited February 2015

    Taking out poker as it's just...well, poker. Got and TftB aren't done yet so can't comment.

    1. The Walking Dead S1
    2. The Wolf Among Us
    3. Sam and Max S2
    4. Sam and Max S3
    5. Sam and Max S1
    6. The Walking Dead S2
    7. Wallace and Gromit Grand Adventures
    8. Back to the Future S1
    9. Jurassic Park
  • MetallicaRulesMetallicaRules
    edited March 2016
    1. The Walking Dead S1
    2. The Walking Dead S2
    3. The Wolf Among Us
    4. Tales From the Borderlands
    5. Game of Thrones

    Now since TFTBL and GOT are still in development, there's a chance that they will move up, but I'm placing them where they are since they are not yet finished. I want to play Telltale's older games like Sam and Max, but I don't currently have the money, when I do I will play them.

    EDIT: So over a year has gone by since this comment, wow. Anyway, my new list:

    1. Tales From the Borderlands
    2. The Walking Dead Season 1
    3. The Walking Dead Season 2
    4. The Wolf Among Us
    5. Game of Thrones
    6. The Walking Dead: Michonne
    7. Minecraft: Story Mode
  • OfficialSheriffMaybeOfficialSheriffMaybe
    edited February 2015
    1. The Walking Dead
    2. The Wolf Among us
    3. Tales From The Borderlands
    4. Game of Thrones
  • TeamKennyW00TTeamKennyW00T
    1. The Walking Dead Season 1
    2. Tales of Monkey Island
    3. Sam and Max Season 2
    4. Game of Thrones so far
    5. Sam and Max Season 3
    6. Tales from the Borderlands so far
    7. Back to the Future
    8. Sam and Max Season 1
    9. The Walking Dead Season 2
    10. Puzzle Agent
    11. The Wolf Among Us
    12. Poker Night 2
    13. Hector: Badge of Carnage
    14. Jurassic Park
    15. Law and Order Legacies
    16. Poker Night 1
    17. Bone
    18. Wallace and Gromit's Grand Adventures
    19. Texas Hold'em
    20. CSI
  • Green613Green613
    1. Game of Thrones (if the rest of the season goes well)
    2. TWD S2
    3. TWD S1
    4. The Wolf Among Us
    5. Tales From the Borderlands
  • TheFurryOneTheFurryOne

    Out of the ones I've played:

    1. The Wolf Among Us
    2. Game of Thrones
    3. Tales from the Borderlands
    4. Sam & Max Beyond Time and Space
    5. TWD S1
    6. Wallace & Gromit's Grand Adventures
    7. TWD S2
  • Poogers555Poogers555

    Out of the ones I've played

    1. Walking Dead Season 1
    2. The Wolf Among us
    3. Walking Dead Season 2

    Not sure where to put GoT or Tales because they arnt finished yet

  • ShubbalubbadingdongShubbalubbadingdong
    edited February 2015

    So far (though I figure for the most part it will remain like this) -

    1. Walking Dead S1
    2. Game of Thrones (S1)
    3. Wolf Among Us
    4. Tales from the Borderlands
    5. Walking Dead S2
  • TheWolfOfTheDeadTheWolfOfTheDead
    edited February 2015

    Based out of the ones I've played:

    1. Wallace and Gromit's Grand Adventures
    2. The Walking Dead Game Season 1
    3. The Wolf Among Us
    4. The Walking Dead Game Season 2
    5. Back to the Future
    6. Jurassic Park

    (Might pick up TFTBL and the Sam & Max games later down the road)

  • basketcase6969basketcase6969
    1. Game of Thrones
    2. The Wolf Among Us
    3. The Walking Dead season 1
    4. The Walking Dead season 2
  • BelanBelan
    edited February 2015
    1. TWD S1. One of the best games I have ever played.
    2. TWAU. This probably could have been even better if more time and effort had been put into it. Loved it though.
    3. TWD S2. May have been riding off of the success of the first season, but I can't pretend that I didn't really enjoy going through it despite some of it's shortcomings.
    4. Game of Thrones. I really thought the first episode set things up well, but the second episode was a pretty big disappointment for me.
    5. Tales From the Borderlands. Decent first episode, can't really judge much at this point. Wasn't really a fan of the story at a few points (mostly the beginning).
  • ChuckTheLizardChuckTheLizard
    1. The Walking Dead: Season 1 (cliche I know, but no other game has left a huge impact on me as this one so yea)
    2. Tales from the Borderlands
    3. The Wolf Among Us
    4. The Walking Dead Season 2
  • dojo32161dojo32161 Moderator

    When you say tales do you mean from the Borderlands or of Monkey Island?

    TheWolfOfTheDead posted: »

    Based out of the ones I've played: * Wallace and Gromit's Grand Adventures * The Walking Dead Game Season 1 * The Wolf Among Us * Th

  • TheWolfOfTheDeadTheWolfOfTheDead

    Borderlands. Should make that more clearer :P

    dojo32161 posted: »

    When you say tales do you mean from the Borderlands or of Monkey Island?

  • JetLeeJetLee
    edited February 2015
    1. Minecraft: Story Mode
    2. Minecraft: Story Mode
    3. Minecraft: Story Mode
    4. Minecraft: Story Mode
    5. Minecraft: Story Mode

    All the other Telltale titles don't even compare to the might of Minecraft :D

  • Butterscotch-BirosButterscotch-Biros
    1. Sam and Max Season 1
    2. Sam and Max Season 2
    3. Tales of Monkey Island
    4. Sam and Max Season 3
    5. Wallace and Gromit's Grand Adventures
    6. Strong Bad's Cool Game for Attractive People (3/5 episodes)
    7. Puzzle Agent
    8. Poker Night 1
  • EpicMustacheGuyEpicMustacheGuy

    1. Game of Thrones

    2. The Walking Dead Season 1

    3. Tales from the Borderlands

    4. The Wolf Among Us

    5. Jurassic Park

    6. Filler

    7. Filler

    8. Filler

    9. Filler

    10. The Walking Dead Season 2

  • Omid's catOmid's cat Banned
    edited February 2015
    1. TWD s1
    2. TftB so far
    3. GoT so far
    4. TWAU
    5. ....
    6. TWD s2
  • InGen_Nate_KennyInGen_Nate_Kenny Moderator

    Pff hahahahaha.

    EpicMustacheGuy posted: »

    * Game of Thrones * The Walking Dead Season 1 * Tales from the Borderlands * The Wolf Among Us * Jurassic Park * Filler * Filler * Filler * Filler * The Walking Dead Season 2

  • Vinnie StickmanVinnie Stickman
    1. Sam and Max: The Devil's Playhouse
    2. The Walking Dead Game Season 1
    3. Tales From the Borderlands
    4. Wallace and Gromit's Grand Adventures
    5. Puzzle Agent
    6. Sam and Max: Beyond Time and Space
    7. Poker Night 2
    8. The Wolf Among Us
    9. Puzzle Agent 2
    10. The Walking Dead Game Season 2
    11. Back to The Future
    12. Sam and Max Save The World
    13. Game of Thrones
    14. Poker Night
    15. Jurassic Park
  • bloopbloop
    1. The Walking Dead
    2. The Wolf Among Us
    3. Game Of Thrones
    4. Tales From The Borderlands
  • Lee4everLee4ever
    edited February 2015
    1. The Walking Dead season 1
    2. Game of thrones (so far)
    3. The Wolf among us
    4. Sam and max DPH
    5. Tales from the boarder lands (so far)
    6. The Walking Dead season 2
  • ralo229ralo229

    The Walking Dead: Season One (10/10)

    Tales from the Borderlands (10/10)

    The Walking Dead: Season Two (9.5/10)

    The Wolf Among Us (8.5/10)

    Back to the Future (8/10)

    Jurassic Park (3/10) (Yeah, I really fucking hated this game)

  • basketcase6969basketcase6969
    1. Game of Thrones
    2. The Wolf Among US
    3. The Walking Dead Season 1
    4. The Walking Dead Season 2
  • basketcase6969basketcase6969

    doh....was a double post sorry.

    Alt text

    basketcase6969 posted: »

    * Game of Thrones * The Wolf Among US * The Walking Dead Season 1 * The Walking Dead Season 2

  • ClemenemClemenem
    edited March 2015

    1. The Walking Dead Season 1

    2. The Wolf Among Us

    3. Game of Thrones (So far)

    4. Tales From The Borderlands (So far)

    5. Back To The Future

    6. The Walking Dead Season 2

  • jules_v_gjules_v_g
    1. The Walking Dead Season 1
    2. The Walking Dead Season 2
    3. Game of Thrones (it's too bad I don't like Lord Tyrions sort of unfitting personality and the game's music or it'd be much higher.)
    4. The Wolf Among Us
    5. Game of Thrones gets a second spot :P
  • JenniferJennifer Moderator
    edited February 2015

    This is quite hard for me, since I've played and enjoyed them all at some level, so I'll rate it based on my fondness for the game, and how likely it is that I'll go back to play it. I'm not going to include Tales from the Borderlands or Game of Thrones here, since it's too early to really tell for them yet.

    1. Wallace & Gromit's Grand Adventures
    2. Tales of Monkey Island
    3. The Walking Dead
    4. Sam & Max: The Devil's Playhouse
    5. The Wolf Among Us
    6. Sam & Max Beyond Time and Space
    7. Strong Bad's Cool Game for Attractive People
    8. Hector: Badge of Carnage
    9. Nelson Tethers: Puzzle Agent
    10. CSI: Fatal Conspiracy
    11. Puzzle Agent 2
    12. Poker Night 2
    13. The Walking Dead: 400 Days
    14. Sam & Max Save the World
    15. The Walking Dead Season Two
    16. Poker Night at the Inventory
    17. CSI: 3 Dimensions of Murder
    18. Back to the Future: The Game
    19. Bone: The Great Cow Race
    20. Law & Order Legacies
    21. Jurassic Park: The Game
    22. CSI: Deadly Intent
    23. Bone: Out from Boneville
    24. CSI: Hard Evidence
    25. Telltale Texas Hold'Em
  • OzzyUKOzzyUK Moderator
    edited February 2015

    I really enjoyed all these games and they are very close but The Walking Dead Season 1 has a strong first place position because it got me into Telltale's games.

    1. The Walking Dead Season 1
    2. The Walking Dead Season 2
    3. Game of Thrones
    4. Tales from the Borderlands
    5. Back to the Future
    6. The Wolf Among Us
    7. Tales Of Monkey Island
  • EhkayEhkay
    1. Wolf Among Us
    2. Walking Dead Season 2
    3. Walking Dead Season 1
  • finlanderfinlander
    1. The wolf among us
    2. The Walking Dead
    3. Tales from the borderlands/Back to the future (tie)
  • True_ScumTrue_Scum
    1. The Walking Dead S1
    2. Game of Thrones (S1)
    3. Tales From the Borderlands
    4. The Wolf Among Us
    5. The Walking Dead S2
  • TheCornPopperTheCornPopper
    1. The Walking Dead S1
    2. The Wolf Among Us
    3. Game of Thrones
    4. The Walking Dead S2
  • MiklausMiklaus
    1. The Walking Dead Season 1
    2. Game of Thrones
    3. The Wolf Among Us
    4. Tales from the Borderlands
    5. The Walking Dead Season 2
  • BufkinandLillyBufkinandLilly

    Of the five I've played:

    1. Walking Dead Season 1
    2. Wolf Among US
    3. Borderlands
    4. Game of Thrones
    5. Walking Dead Season 2
Sign in to comment in this discussion.